{"version": "1.0.0", "segments": [{"startTime": 0.009, "endTime": 4.309, "body": "I can just confirm that building is more than consuming.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 4.73, "endTime": 14.069, "body": "I would encourage everyone to look on it as I use the technology for, for my own unique creativity or or processes.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 14.22, "endTime": 20.25, "body": "That's, that's the positive thing compared to having fear of someone, some AI takes over.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 20.469, "endTime": 21.67, "body": "I don't believe this at all.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 32.869, "endTime": 38.33, "body": "Welcome to a brand new episode of our podcast, Human and AI Minds Machine and in creating the san.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 39.08, "endTime": 48.479, "body": "Thanks for tuning in to our geeky podcast where we discuss the fascinating field of AI and machine learning, corporate craziness, passion for technology, and the role of humans.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 48.68, "endTime": 52.56, "body": "We are your hosts, Uli and Ari, and we're happy to have you with us", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 52.56, "endTime": 52.779, "body": "today.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 53.4, "endTime": 57.835, "body": "You know what, Ari, Let's talk not about the boring stuff, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 57.965, "endTime": 59.316, "body": "Large language model.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 59.636, "endTime": 60.636, "body": "Oh, that's so boring.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 60.706, "endTime": 62.105, "body": "It's so yesterday, is it?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 62.195, "endTime": 62.995, "body": "So yesterday.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 63.236, "endTime": 65.996, "body": "You know what, what is today and what is tomorrow actually?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 66.515, "endTime": 68.585, "body": "Physical AI, I guess, you know.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 68.805, "endTime": 71.966, "body": "Let's let's talk about profoundly something physical, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 72.075, "endTime": 77.236, "body": "Or let's say physics AI seem to be in everywhere, every world, every buzz nowadays, everybody's.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 77.382, "endTime": 79.321, "body": "Talking about this, what does it actually means, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 79.552, "endTime": 87.632, "body": "What does it mean physics drives our car, our planes, our, our trains, our, you know, the products actually everyday we're using here, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 87.921, "endTime": 90.632, "body": "And so, let's let's talk about the role of physics.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 90.671, "endTime": 93.952, "body": "Is it, you know, AI that understands the dynamics of physics?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 94.022, "endTime": 97.211, "body": "Is it physics AI in terms of this is the embodiment?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 97.391, "endTime": 98.232, "body": "Is it robotics?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 98.302, "endTime": 99.052, "body": "Is it human?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 99.272, "endTime": 104.919, "body": "Is it I guess we need to have a cool guest, right, about talking about these aspects.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 105.04, "endTime": 110.79, "body": "So how to cope with things that not yet are built but need to be able to be built, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 110.919, "endTime": 112.9, "body": "Is there a technology that helps us with this?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 115.75, "endTime": 120.019, "body": "But I'm happy, I'm sure we'll we'll have just the right person to help us unpack this.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 120.19, "endTime": 136.82, "body": "And actually if we look at The market and some numbers, we, we can see that the market for simulation software is already a multi-billion dollar industry as well, and is also projected to nearly double in the next decade, quietly powering the next wave of industrial innovation.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 136.979, "endTime": 140.72, "body": "So we're really like bridging physics, AI and simulation here.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 142.6, "endTime": 163.38, "body": "We bridge somehow two really cool things, which is, uh, you know, a bit of the science of data and actually the science of rockets, right, and about, you know, utilizing this predictive capability, this power of AI at the very core of physics and engineering, right, and maybe doing things we even can't imagine.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 164.229, "endTime": 166.47, "body": "And Oi, you, you already alluded to it.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 166.55, "endTime": 176.229, "body": "We, we've got just the right person here with us today to help us unpack some of these questions, some of these aspects, and, uh, shed some light to the dark.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 176.55, "endTime": 183.169, "body": "And we're so happy to be joined by Moritz Freeze, global technical director for Engineering data.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 183.69, "endTime": 187.869, "body": "Otto at Aldair and Moritz is a true innovator.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 188.21, "endTime": 195.69, "body": "He's a status quo challenger who champions creativity and teamwork, and he loves to bring people together and technology.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 195.97, "endTime": 197.789, "body": "So Moritz, welcome to the show.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 198.089, "endTime": 198.25, "body": "Thanks,", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 198.279, "endTime": 198.61, "body": "Aubrey.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 198.69, "endTime": 199.149, "body": "Thanks.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 199.41, "endTime": 202.58, "body": "Great pleasure to have you here and have this conversation as you.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 203.039, "endTime": 204.449, "body": "Started with a lot of questions.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 204.5, "endTime": 213.429, "body": "I'm curious how we, how we get going here.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 213.75, "endTime": 218.69, "body": "We, you know, you know, you're dealing with some aspects, you know, engineering and AI, you know.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 218.774, "endTime": 221.445, "body": "Have some experience I guess in the mobility, you know.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 221.654, "endTime": 224.014, "body": "So um let's, let's, let's look forward, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 224.085, "endTime": 229.535, "body": "This is what, what we do in our tax base, you know, let's look forward to shaping narratives for sure.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 229.615, "endTime": 232.214, "body": "But um you know, with the tons of experience that you have, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 232.535, "endTime": 234.514, "body": "Let's imagine 2035.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 235.054, "endTime": 238.914, "body": "It's now 2025, those who, who, you know, so 10 years.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 239.175, "endTime": 240.774, "body": "That's a huge, huge gap actually, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 240.854, "endTime": 248.0, "body": "So the 2035, you know what What's one groundbreaking feature of technology you love to see in engineering, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 248.16, "endTime": 251.24, "body": "That could be the game changer, as we say, right, in corporate", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 251.24, "endTime": 251.55, "body": "sometimes.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 251.639, "endTime": 254.509, "body": "10 years, so engineering is fast and slow.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 254.88, "endTime": 259.82, "body": "So if you look on cars, airplanes, infrastructure, let's start slow.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 259.88, "endTime": 270.88, "body": "I mean, we, we would desperately wait for year-wise update of our infrastructure, but obviously engineering of bridges is not as fast as we wanted it, so.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 271.98, "endTime": 276.64, "body": "No change in 10 years, maybe an update of the same bridge, maybe, maybe not.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 277.22, "endTime": 285.0, "body": "On the other hand, the, the, the, this digital aspect of things is so fascinating, fast, so there the speed is just amazing.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 285.54, "endTime": 292.959, "body": "Maybe that's what drives even more passion for this physical or engineering creating things, building things.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 293.66, "endTime": 297.019, "body": "And there, a lot of things can happen in just 10 years.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 297.359, "endTime": 301.179, "body": "So the, the software, the algorithms are growing extremely.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 301.42, "endTime": 307.94, "body": "So if we take this car, I think, well, the, the standard OEMs have their plans already.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 308.1, "endTime": 315.76, "body": "So it'll be a car, maybe a very nice one, it'll have 44 wheels, and they, they, they engineered it to scale.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 316.48, "endTime": 337.059, "body": "Um, but maybe there is someone with another creative idea I'm, I'm not aware of, and then this guy creates a mobility asset, a car with 5 wheels, where everyone knows 5 wheels are not going through right now, but then it's appealing, and then you have this, well, disruption.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 337.589, "endTime": 353.79, "body": "But someone has tried it out using some like all these digital assets, so that guy will not be a global um shipping OEM it will be something local, maybe with, you know, fast localized manufacturing, whatever is behind there.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 354.239, "endTime": 357.32, "body": "Question is, is this product then really appealing?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 357.399, "endTime": 358.559, "body": "Would it arrive with you?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 358.88, "endTime": 366.279, "body": "Or is this just another nice example of this one Ferrari 2.0, which someone likes but no one else touches it.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 366.359, "endTime": 370.92, "body": "So that scaling across the world is still a challenge of, of", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 370.92, "endTime": 371.269, "body": "engineering.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 371.38, "endTime": 378.5, "body": "So that would mean it's like, you know, would be in terms of yeah, yeah, in 10 years we will have autonomous driving.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 379.149, "endTime": 387.049, "body": "Right, um, but you say like, yeah, maybe one thing, but maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe it's not, not the car.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 387.429, "endTime": 390.059, "body": "Maybe, maybe it's not the car as we envisioned.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 390.309, "endTime": 393.399, "body": "Maybe AI found different designs.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 394.1, "endTime": 399.39, "body": "That makes, makes the car totally repurposing its its aspects, not only flying and stuff like that.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 399.47, "endTime": 412.029, "body": "So this, this is the thing we need to break our steroids and you know, in, in, in terms of, you know, what do we actually imagine, maybe, you know, we get hit by a totally different innovation from some random dude, you know.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 412.19, "endTime": 415.73, "body": "Tackling with cool technology, some different angle to innovation", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 416.179, "endTime": 424.41, "body": "and and and questioning this is always, you know, if we call it a car, it's probably global OEMs and you buy it in that same shop, but via website.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 424.829, "endTime": 433.13, "body": "But if it's a mobility asset which serves that same purpose, that is bound to be engineered by someone else.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 435.5, "endTime": 436.779, "body": "Yeah, I'm I'm excited.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 437.22, "endTime": 452.63, "body": "So, uh, maybe it could be like the next car is, I don't know, an entertainment space uh where we can go across the world and Watch movies and be in immersive spaces.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 453.07, "endTime": 459.66, "body": "Or finally, the train is as comfortable as today your car is and then you feel better in sitting in that same asset.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 460.119, "endTime": 460.5, "body": "Yeah.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 460.839, "endTime": 466.609, "body": "OK, and what would be your best guess if you were that, that, that guy to come up with.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 467.69, "endTime": 468.92, "body": "With a crazy idea.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 469.98, "endTime": 470.799, "body": "That's a tough one.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 471.019, "endTime": 471.69, "body": "Yeah, that's a tough one.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 471.739, "endTime": 486.239, "body": "I think again it'll serve diverse needs so that You know, individualization will scale further and further, and that's why it makes it difficult to name it the global asset of a car or a train.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 487.1, "endTime": 490.489, "body": "But the need will be served with different, different solutions.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 490.66, "endTime": 494.899, "body": "That brings us in a bit of the pillar of, you know, in the role of creativity, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 495.029, "endTime": 498.709, "body": "And the role creativity plays in the age of AI, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 498.829, "endTime": 505.549, "body": "We see currently a lot of aspects with regards to generative eye, producing images, you know, even the cool movies, I must admit, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 505.589, "endTime": 512.549, "body": "It's pretty cool to see, you know, it's moving from a couple of seconds to actually maybe almost minutes, right, of movies.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 513.07, "endTime": 516.71, "body": "So, that, that somehow is, is it, is it creativity?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 516.789, "endTime": 518.789, "body": "I'm sure it, happy to hear a few, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 518.83, "endTime": 520.809, "body": "Is this a creative process.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 520.94, "endTime": 530.15, "body": "And the other one is about how does this new paradigm then fit to this actually engineering perspective with your eyes it's like, you know, form follows function, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 530.669, "endTime": 537.419, "body": "So are we finally having cool things that look cool, but also, you know, functions cool?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 537.51, "endTime": 542.53, "body": "Is that, is that the art of the impossible with the eye and tech and simulation and stuff?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 543.229, "endTime": 551.27, "body": "First, I'm, I'm a bit skeptical at first maybe sitting here on that chair, um, because for me creativity is more than creating.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 551.83, "endTime": 554.21, "body": "So creating a movie, creating a song.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 555.609, "endTime": 563.03, "body": "For me to, to have a relaxing evening is is more of this pattern like creating new things.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 563.28, "endTime": 573.15, "body": "It serves its purpose, but I would still say creativity is something way more complex, maybe that thing which is still human.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 573.88, "endTime": 583.489, "body": "I mean you can discuss with musicians and they still are out there, although AI can generate songs, so that's where I haven't seen any creativity from AI.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 586.369, "endTime": 608.38, "body": "But obviously the the the terms of generative AI and and and all this, you know, the the the tools to create craft will scale very, very fast and that's also the heart of engineering because I would believe engineering is way more connected to creativity than to physics, by the way so um.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 609.45, "endTime": 616.21, "body": "And, and therefore that'll, that'll scale a lot and that's why I'm so fascinating of this whole field, right?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 616.289, "endTime": 628.63, "body": "What, what is tool and what is augmentation and what is, well, lazy replacement of just another engineer where we have so many millions of engineers out there.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 629.89, "endTime": 636.609, "body": "Maybe they can then focus on something or don't even become an engineer because it's just creating another car which drives from A to B and.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 637.429, "endTime": 638.109, "body": "Does the job.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 638.369, "endTime": 640.229, "body": "That's repetitive crafting.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 640.45, "endTime": 645.38, "body": "That's execution and what you're referring to is like that stage before that, like what are we even building?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 646.049, "endTime": 653.44, "body": "And and then maybe also to refer or link it back to our first question where we thought about, OK, what, what is that new vehicle of the future looking like?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 653.609, "endTime": 657.609, "body": "So where, how do we get to that stage and how do we break out of those patterns?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 657.84, "endTime": 665.869, "body": "And like how do you see that role of creativity um being like these days in the age of AI we can like build and execute so fast.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 666.52, "endTime": 668.2, "body": "Invention or innovation, right?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 668.32, "endTime": 669.599, "body": "These are also these two terms.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 669.919, "endTime": 674.59, "body": "Invention is this creative element and then innovation is bring it to scale, bring it to market.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 674.96, "endTime": 684.559, "body": "So, um, one of my personal assets was to have a part which drives around in this, uh, BMWs uh out there and is a patent from, from mine.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 684.64, "endTime": 688.179, "body": "OK, that's my personal footprint, but it was.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 689.02, "endTime": 694.619, "body": "Obviously innovation from the whole organization and not the invention from myself, so.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 695.5, "endTime": 721.27, "body": "On the other hand, now, if people can invent in a democratized way and don't need this large organization to drive innovation because it's erial production, it's globalized and it's cost efficient, then we will see way more exploration and way more fascinating new new engineered things due to the democratization of, well, innovation.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 722.049, "endTime": 730.049, "body": "Although the invention still comes from minds and and humans, and then comes these, you know, the, the, the subjective appealing aspects.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 731.039, "endTime": 732.289, "body": "What is something nice.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 733.729, "endTime": 736.03, "body": "Style is style design?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 736.119, "endTime": 749.239, "body": "Yes it is, but is it engineering design, you know, also these English terms mix and match sometimes and uh once it's subjective, then you, well, it's not a pattern anymore and that's where I would say still um.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 750.32, "endTime": 756.02, "body": "Core AI technology lives more from pattern and existing things and not from", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 761.96, "endTime": 763.919, "body": "I think we're working in a in a in a setup where we kind of chips with AI.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 764.46, "endTime": 782.919, "body": "Right, and, and, um, of chip design, you know, of, of transmissions and heating and, you know, modulating the complexity space of how to design the best way and it has a 3000 parameters, right, which is crazy and that's why these folks uh which are work there, it's like they come up with certain kinds of templates and certain kinds of experience that they have, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 783.179, "endTime": 791.52, "body": "And then we thought like, you know, could it be that AI actually comes up with a cool design that makes all the functional totally worth things.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 791.78, "endTime": 795.77, "body": "And I, I somehow compared them to I don't know, Netflix paradigm, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 795.95, "endTime": 806.83, "body": "Netflix recommends me, we have, I don't know what, 30,000 movies on Netflix, um, and it recommends me always 10 to 15 more I don't read probably, right, or 20 likes.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 807.109, "endTime": 812.08, "body": "And then I do the selection, so it should be cool and I like this kind of style, I like this kind of aspects.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 812.229, "endTime": 821.789, "body": "But the pre-selection, right, in terms of, I think the preferences, the recommendations, people like me look like that, my history looks like that, and my knowledge about this is that.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 821.895, "endTime": 821.905, "body": "Right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 822.635, "endTime": 831.994, "body": "And these kinds of recommendation, I think these systems also in a simulated environments and tactic data generated or you know, exploiting the space of design paradigms, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 832.275, "endTime": 838.645, "body": "Gives gives already certain kinds of indications of, I think you have a preference, you as a person, a preference.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 838.674, "endTime": 840.155, "body": "Even so, the decision is with you, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 840.215, "endTime": 853.409, "body": "We're still human in the loop or a human in In leading the decision making and in a lot of processes in the infrastructure, but I feel, I don't know, sometimes, you know, he knows me very well", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 853.409, "endTime": 853.989, "body": "actually.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 856.159, "endTime": 861.88, "body": "A chip, I mean, I'm sorry, I'm not the the the chip engineer, but chips sounds like performance.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 862.2, "endTime": 868.239, "body": "So whenever you want to have maximum performance, it's not about subjective style, it's about performance.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 868.53, "endTime": 871.739, "body": "Now still engineering to performance is a challenge on its own.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 872.2, "endTime": 883.179, "body": "So here, computers augment us, have augmented us, and they will take more and more of these highly complex decision making while productizing things.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 884.049, "endTime": 893.45, "body": "And, and that's just a great continuation of what computers help us as now computers use more and more data and so it's more data driven.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 893.809, "endTime": 904.849, "body": "I think if you, if you have now a a somehow a general, right, which is like this is human in elite, right, and this is AI in elite, like a shift on the level of autonomy, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 905.469, "endTime": 927.07, "body": "Do you think you know that we are in the next 5 to 10 years, we are able to move this on the on the one side in terms of you know that we feel like, OK, now the AI is in the elite and the human will take the The, let's say observation, the right, Rather the safeguard channeling, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 927.19, "endTime": 932.57, "body": "But you leave a system, multi-agent or agent, right, or whatever bus you take now, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 932.869, "endTime": 944.109, "body": "But do you have the feeling specifically in the science space, in the simulation space, this, this is a needed paradigm we need to embrace this, you know, moving up the autonomy ladder, let's say.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 945.099, "endTime": 966.599, "body": "There I would say this is the this disruption challenge and it's so, I mean, I, I love changes, so I, I, I like to be part of the disruption because, you know, that's slide, the question is who, who drives the slider and if like many people in an organization or even without an organization can drive the slider to design your bicycle.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 967.25, "endTime": 975.609, "body": "Then you, you may like to do it and then it comes whether you focus more on style or on performance and then you can take the decision.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 975.969, "endTime": 993.15, "body": "But nowadays engineering is still, let's say, driven by large organizations because you cannot scale on your own to productize and ship and and do it at cost, and these organizational elements will be disrupted because it doesn't require or.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 993.679, "endTime": 1003.489, "body": "Software and AI can augment this and then you can do it on your own and you don't need to go into the shop and have a global manufacturer do it for you.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1004.229, "endTime": 1014.09, "body": "And that's where, you know, it even inspires more, more engineers because I still believe engineering as that part of bringing physics and creativity together um grows on this.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1014.429, "endTime": 1019.25, "body": "It's simply augmented and that's uh yeah, that's what I'm so looking forward to.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1020.02, "endTime": 1022.489, "body": "It also drives the creative disruption.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1023.25, "endTime": 1024.619, "body": "Or distraction actually.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1025.3, "endTime": 1030.739, "body": "So we mentioned in the introduction that you're coming from Alt air and that's super exciting.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1030.839, "endTime": 1040.03, "body": "I think um a lot of people in our audience would also like to to understand more about Alt air and what makes them special and what we can maybe also learn from them.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1040.319, "endTime": 1055.369, "body": "And um now just like with the beginning of this conversation, we can already see like that like that you have that that passion that also aligns a lot with the motto of AlTA, which is when data science meets rocket science, incredible things happen.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1056.209, "endTime": 1076.439, "body": "Could you maybe share how this philosophy actually drives out Air's commitment to really empowering engineers and not to just consume AI and AI models, but maybe to really create and build and craft and things that we're just that we're discussing now in the beginning and what does this actually mean for how you envision the future of engineering?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1077.839, "endTime": 1087.01, "body": "So first of all, thanks for bringing this uh the the the quote from Jim Scapper because I I I I like that quote very much and it tells more than than all the technology.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1087.369, "endTime": 1091.729, "body": "Um, because rocket science is that placeholder for high class engineering, right?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1091.869, "endTime": 1106.56, "body": "Everyone would, would take this, and then data science before it was famous is actually, it was there in particular early like banking, it's the dustic statistics, uh, experts, but I mean they make a lot of money.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1106.849, "endTime": 1116.15, "body": "So the, the, the, the asset as such of data science has been there and has its value all the time and it comes with computing.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1116.979, "endTime": 1129.939, "body": "Analysis calculation, so the scale of computers helped this and well Altair was a a combination of software to um you know ease access to users so.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1130.43, "endTime": 1155.29, "body": "In both things, you don't serve the result of a data analysis, but you, you just simply make it more appealing for more than the statistical experts being very unique and the same was in, in the engineering side where then the simulation comes into play, which was there like again since 40 years so and simulation was even earlier for building rockets.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1155.739, "endTime": 1159.75, "body": "Altair's software element was to, to have a, well.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1160.219, "endTime": 1167.04, "body": "A good access for many, many engineers to do things which were able before.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1167.15, "endTime": 1172.489, "body": "So Altair hasn't invented the core algorithms but brought algorithms to users.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1172.949, "endTime": 1173.069, "body": "So", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1173.069, "endTime": 1176.91, "body": "things that were reserved for others are now suddenly available to a lot of people.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1177.069, "endTime": 1181.41, "body": "Yes, and they they they scale at least into organizations, so that's already great.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1181.91, "endTime": 1184.01, "body": "Now bringing these concepts together.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1184.39, "endTime": 1202.93, "body": "Is, I think exactly what what the the new, I call it hype or what the new world is because data is so abundant that you eventually leverage more knowledge from data than from the simulation once it's a complicated physics simulation and you need expertise to set this up.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1203.189, "endTime": 1205.209, "body": "So that's why this slider.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1205.489, "endTime": 1218.609, "body": "Is exactly sitting also on this software tools Altair one like brings to market and that's um well, exactly what what what what attracted me so I'm, I was happy to join that company.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1219.43, "endTime": 1228.739, "body": "I think as it is part of this engineering vision where Siemens has such a powerful background, that's uh that nice thing which brought us together.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1229.28, "endTime": 1234.079, "body": "Maybe it's it's called when data engineering meets rocket engineering.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1235.29, "endTime": 1235.329, "body": "to build rocket.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1240.839, "endTime": 1247.329, "body": "So, um, you know, simulation in engineering, right, it's it's um we briefly touched already, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1247.64, "endTime": 1252.959, "body": "So, so bringing in the predictive power and the exploitation, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1253.0, "endTime": 1255.239, "body": "There's always this balancing out, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1255.76, "endTime": 1261.579, "body": "Um, in, in scaling out in the trade-off between, you know, speed and accuracy of this application.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1262.189, "endTime": 1279.42, "body": "And then you have the other interface, which people are mostly confused because someone, there's one that is saying like, physics, AI in terms, you know, and please detangle it and physics informed AI, right, in terms of surrogate model and stuff like that.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1279.63, "endTime": 1283.709, "body": "Can you, can you just separate for our audience a bit of the two concepts?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1283.75, "endTime": 1284.39, "body": "Is that OK?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1285.64, "endTime": 1289.05, "body": "If you allow, I make a controversial statement in the beginning where we", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1289.05, "endTime": 1291.239, "body": "love we love controversial statements.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1292.569, "endTime": 1296.189, "body": "Maybe physics is overestimated in engineering, so.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1297.189, "endTime": 1303.369, "body": "Um, engineering is, is scaling, rethinking, repeat things, and a bit of creativity.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1303.709, "endTime": 1306.369, "body": "This is what engineering is all about, but.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1307.4, "endTime": 1337.4, "body": "Physics lovers rarely become engineers because physics on its own are, you know it very well, very complex, and Maybe it like it distracts from each other so that's why um the the the the rare engineers close to both things are maybe the nerdy ones, maybe I am a nerdy one because well yes I studied quite a bit of these equations behind but in essence engineering is simply do it,", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1337.439, "endTime": 1338.8, "body": "build it, use it.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1339.189, "endTime": 1357.489, "body": "And that's why now, the same with AI which is this famous intelligence behind, if I bring physics next to AI it is a driver of fascination, but sometimes out of, out of touch, out of reach, so someone else should detangle this.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1358.88, "endTime": 1377.959, "body": "Now, well, Altair has a product which is called physics AI and that is let's say the, the, the element of bringing what has been there being physics driven simulated because we have the solvers built ones where there is equations inside.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1379.27, "endTime": 1380.989, "body": "And then if this.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1381.689, "endTime": 1399.41, "body": "Input is used in an AI sense, making it repetitive, have some data, learn out of patterns, then you predict things instead of running another simulation, but is this like the new unique way of using physics for something?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1399.569, "endTime": 1411.51, "body": "No, it's not, and that's where also physics informed AI all this I, I simply don't know whether this is maybe more an excuse of not embracing.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1412.229, "endTime": 1435.349, "body": "Or allowing the sheer amount of data to scale and just live on existing things and copy and paste, if copy and paste serves what you need, just use it and don't care whether it's like physics will tell you whether this, Beam breaks, yes or no, but it hasn't broken before, so it's probably a good beam.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1435.68, "endTime": 1440.489, "body": "Maybe this is not new to you, to you, but obviously for for many customers, it's new, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1440.599, "endTime": 1446.109, "body": "So a technical system that understands where you can model the dynamics of physic behavior, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1446.16, "endTime": 1451.479, "body": "I don't know, like wind and and pressure and friction and these kinds of things, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1451.839, "endTime": 1457.77, "body": "Um, is something, I guess, which, which, you know, is for many companies.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1458.27, "endTime": 1460.969, "body": "Untapped potential, I would say, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1461.27, "endTime": 1468.989, "body": "Because it never dinner, I don't know how to do it and it seemed to be the technology now gives and for many years for you, right, since agents like, what are you talking?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1469.03, "endTime": 1471.03, "body": "I'm doing this since many, many, many, many moons, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1471.189, "endTime": 1474.109, "body": "But for most of the in the industry segments, it's, it's not the case, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1474.189, "endTime": 1477.77, "body": "It's like, OK, I still have to question, how do I model my stuff?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1477.859, "endTime": 1482.77, "body": "How do I, how to bring the physical dynamics actually into a, into a digital.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1483.39, "endTime": 1489.219, "body": "Digital representation so I can tweak and test and what if and, and these kinds of things, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1489.67, "endTime": 1492.459, "body": "So is, is this part of an accessibility?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1492.53, "endTime": 1501.26, "body": "Is this part of, is this, is, has this leaped in terms of that, you know, oh, suddenly we get this tool stack, oh, I'm pretty cool, now I can do it.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1501.469, "endTime": 1504.65, "body": "What happened the last, I don't know, 5 years?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1504.709, "endTime": 1506.01, "body": "Why is it now possible?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1506.989, "endTime": 1509.689, "body": "And the question is like, who who's asking?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1510.109, "endTime": 1521.93, "body": "Because do you want to simulate the the whatever the the the bicycle, take again this example, you're riding, do, do, are you, do you like the physics behind?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1522.31, "endTime": 1522.869, "body": "Yes or no?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1522.949, "endTime": 1525.03, "body": "That's to me still a subjective question.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1525.55, "endTime": 1534.089, "body": "But yes, meanwhile, the, like the and and the concepts of physics in the computer or in, well, they're in games.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1534.189, "endTime": 1535.13, "body": "So if, if you.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1535.42, "endTime": 1540.15, "body": "Uh, you know, watch, uh, movies, then they use physics to make it more realistic.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1540.51, "endTime": 1556.689, "body": "So obviously physics is, is, is great, it's a great asset to have, and if physics being only for nerds now becomes accessible for everyone, because we simulate things, which means bring realistic physics into a digital asset.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1558.4, "endTime": 1568.579, "body": "Let's do it and let's let's have access for everyone and yet these advanced simulation as you describe it, were also within engineering, often bottlenecked.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1569.16, "endTime": 1574.14, "body": "So if this goes at scale, um then whether it's via simulation or data, it doesn't matter.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1574.28, "endTime": 1577.0, "body": "What what what were the bottlenecks which are now re released?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1578.92, "endTime": 1586.38, "body": "Yes, the combination of the experts understanding the basic physics, then maybe accessibility to software.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1586.599, "endTime": 1595.739, "body": "So UI is an important concept, then the collaborative aspect, you know, no one does things on its own, so you need interfaces.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1596.66, "endTime": 1604.319, "body": "Meanwhile, it it it it scales and then and like we, we, we tear down interfaces, there's not the one department owning aerodynamics.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1604.329, "endTime": 1607.199, "body": "Everyone wants to have some aerodynamics in his design.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1607.68, "endTime": 1609.04, "body": "That's, that's what changes a lot.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1609.39, "endTime": 1618.119, "body": "So that means in the, so companies in the movement embracing more digital technology, upgraded knowledge, or competence went in these companies in there.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1618.52, "endTime": 1629.88, "body": "Second aspects, the user interface of a very muddlab, crazy, geeky things meet it up and say like, OK, I can use it actually, um, computer, I guess, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1630.04, "endTime": 1634.239, "body": "Oh, it's complicated, a heavy computer, we have now this computer acceleration also to do.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1634.78, "endTime": 1637.14, "body": "Things of, you know, machine learning, stuff like that.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1637.439, "endTime": 1644.0, "body": "And then you can see that this is cross-functional across across more department level.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1644.28, "endTime": 1645.599, "body": "That's an interesting aspect.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1649.38, "endTime": 1652.459, "body": "I mean the compute power was there, so that's for sure a given.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1653.329, "endTime": 1660.829, "body": "I would maybe add the appealing element of things, right, because physics is also physical, so we see it, it's a 3D object.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1661.369, "endTime": 1680.63, "body": "Now, if your decision making process is visually appealing because you still see the airplane, you see, you see maybe bending or, or, you know, airflow or make even electromagnetics visible, that gives you more confidence in taking decisions.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1681.069, "endTime": 1692.4, "body": "And that's why the thing scales and you don't go to the one expert in your company and ask him, is it correct, yes or no, but you take the decision more on your own and that scales responsibility.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1708.27, "endTime": 1711.109, "body": "I have two daughters, right, young kids.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1711.229, "endTime": 1714.949, "body": "No, actually, no, not young kids, sorry, they, they kick my ass now, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1715.069, "endTime": 1717.15, "body": "No, they are not young, you're grown up, all good.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1717.39, "endTime": 1718.869, "body": "Um, so.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1719.839, "endTime": 1727.38, "body": "I found it fascinating the last year, so they, they embraced AI in terms of Chativity as, as most kids write school and stuff like that.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1728.079, "endTime": 1732.56, "body": "Is there, is there a hope that they will embrace simulation at scale soon?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1732.719, "endTime": 1741.92, "body": "Is it on that kind of democratic, democratized that, you know, everyday people which are not technique will say like, hey, I'm building a small simulation of this scenario, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1742.04, "endTime": 1745.26, "body": "And um and with the recommendation of, you know.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1745.65, "endTime": 1746.609, "body": "This is a good thing.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1746.77, "endTime": 1751.969, "body": "Will, will simulation technology, will that kind of democratized and accessible?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1752.05, "endTime": 1756.489, "body": "Do you foresee that, or is this, will it remain for the next 5 to 10 years still a very nichey thing?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1756.689, "endTime": 1758.349, "body": "I have no fear for your daughters.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1759.119, "endTime": 1764.79, "body": "My fear is for the kids.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1765.045, "endTime": 1767.974, "body": "Grown up, it's the same with with mine, they're anyways curious.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1768.055, "endTime": 1776.984, "body": "So, so they pick what they want and they like to have more physics uh behind the scenes and I mean, they even have to learn physics.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1777.334, "endTime": 1782.114, "body": "So if this is appealing and they use today's tools for this, they would pick it up.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1782.974, "endTime": 1793.834, "body": "Challenge is more on transforming existing engineering organizations and still the concept of please design an engineer for maybe.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1794.89, "endTime": 1812.589, "body": "Durability of 100 years, that's where, where it becomes challenging because that's maybe what your daughters don't foresee and that's where expertise from engineering should still be in place, although it looks nice in the computer.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1813.689, "endTime": 1817.39, "body": "Hopefully, it it is nice in the physical world as well.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1818.41, "endTime": 1818.53, "body": "So", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1818.53, "endTime": 1840.489, "body": "you're you're saying that actually that like on the one hand, like that human agencies being like driven like because now everyone has access and maybe one day everyone like simulates their own stuff, but then on the other hand, it might also be like a people challenge that people that have been in a space for long and they've like done things in a certain way that might be especially hard for them to adapt to like those new tools.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1841.055, "endTime": 1842.454, "body": "Although they're there and very effective.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1842.994, "endTime": 1843.005, "body": "OK.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1843.464, "endTime": 1862.805, "body": "And that's, I mean, going back to school, I mean, the Newton's law of an apple falling is this now, do you need the equation or just need to have in my Google eyes or Google goggles, the ball falling exactly to the right position and that's now where you know, learning and all this uh new ways of perceiving things.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1864.53, "endTime": 1865.38, "body": "in your mind as well.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1865.92, "endTime": 1881.339, "body": "Growth mindset as we say at Siemens and we'll get to that in in a minute, but maybe um like to stay in in the space of like new things arising and we've seen um AI making quite some strides when it comes to understanding text and images.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1881.489, "endTime": 1888.17, "body": "But what if LLMs could also understand 3D geometry and would like sky be the limit?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1888.29, "endTime": 1892.619, "body": "Um, how could that really transform engineering and design.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1893.01, "endTime": 1895.42, "body": "Um, can you maybe elaborate on that?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1895.5, "endTime": 1897.92, "body": "And I also heard something about a dishwasher.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1898.75, "endTime": 1903.54, "body": "I would allow it to say geometry is the intersection of style, appeal, and performance.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1904.469, "endTime": 1908.18, "body": "So geometry is what you like, but", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1909.349, "endTime": 1910.06, "body": "form follows", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 1910.06, "endTime": 1910.709, "body": "functions.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1910.91, "endTime": 1911.719, "body": "you will get a t-shirt.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1914.829, "endTime": 1920.15, "body": "So, but, but then understanding all aspects of geometry is just as ambitious as understanding all physics.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1920.31, "endTime": 1928.189, "body": "So I mean there there's a lot of math behind and I, I, I don't go deep into this, but it touches your daily problems.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1928.27, "endTime": 1933.25, "body": "So if you want to combine geometry with performance, then it's, it's mastery.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1934.719, "endTime": 1938.439, "body": "Do you need mastery for your daily dishwasher problem?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1940.02, "endTime": 1940.03, "body": "My,", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 1941.329, "endTime": 1945.869, "body": "my ambition is actually to fill the dishwasher to have maximum performance of cleaning.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1945.959, "endTime": 1952.51, "body": "So understanding geometry of different objects and how the water cleans this is.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1952.939, "endTime": 1958.54, "body": "I, I like to do this on a daily basis, but I wouldn't force others to do it.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1958.819, "endTime": 1969.339, "body": "Sometimes it's just fill it in and get out and maybe measure the, the, the energy it takes, but why the heck should I understand the geometry pieces I filling in the dishwasher, so.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1970.04, "endTime": 1982.699, "body": "That's where such an example of how, how do people work with geometry is, is different and which geometry drives their performance KPIs is also very, very subjective.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1983.64, "endTime": 1987.349, "body": "Some people, yeah, do the dishwasher this way and some the other way.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 1987.56, "endTime": 2007.3, "body": "Some follow patterns, pattern is trainable to AI, but some may, you know, like to have the, the, the physical cleaning in their heads when, when, when they place it that way or the other way and um like the openness of the cup is downwards, yes, better instead of upwards.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2007.64, "endTime": 2011.619, "body": "For me it's a trade-off between, you know, cleanness, noise.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2012.5, "endTime": 2014.5, "body": "Speed and water consumption.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2015.43, "endTime": 2019.229, "body": "Right, I think that's, that's hopefully a simulation can build.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2019.39, "endTime": 2022.319, "body": "I have only one button there to be frankly, it's called start.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2023.229, "endTime": 2035.949, "body": "But maybe I can, I can have a twiggle and say like, you know, now go for speed, ah, now go for energy consumption, and now go things and it simulates my stuff real time on life and um based on, based on my preferences.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2036.599, "endTime": 2039.27, "body": "And, and wouldn't that depend on what you put in the dishwasher?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2039.56, "endTime": 2039.719, "body": "So,", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2040.93, "endTime": 2041.109, "body": "that's the point, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2042.16, "endTime": 2043.17, "body": "Nowadays you have those other programs, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2046.369, "endTime": 2047.52, "body": "Your, your dishwasher has that too.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2048.86, "endTime": 2071.469, "body": "So, um, if we talk a bit uh a bit uh once again on, on the simulation, right, um, there is, um, there's quite a picture and we, we said like, you know, there's a balance between, you know, maybe sustainability aspects and, and the diffusion that um that there is um technology push, then we see quite some aspects in terms of photorealistic stuff comes into the play, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2071.58, "endTime": 2074.939, "body": "It's like I guess, you know, realistic rendering.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2075.02, "endTime": 2077.479, "body": "I'm not sure, you know, the combination of this so.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2078.229, "endTime": 2088.819, "body": "How do you see the trade-off between realistic worlds being built in AI and simulation and Business, business reality, let's say, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2089.029, "endTime": 2090.648, "body": "Can you, can you resonate on this?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2091.229, "endTime": 2096.989, "body": "So I, I would say like coming from the business side of things, simulation is just better decision taking, right?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2097.188, "endTime": 2103.918, "body": "You, you explore, you build scenarios, and, and that's what helps you to take the real decision.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2105.0, "endTime": 2106.58, "body": "With less risk, right?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2107.919, "endTime": 2121.959, "body": "Now if that as you mentioned um or and also my field if that goes to physical objects and and and physic requirements, physical requirements, then it gets more complicated and.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2123.449, "endTime": 2126.729, "body": "Still, decision making is the process side of it.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2126.889, "endTime": 2146.53, "body": "So do I prepare the, the stuff for others to take the decision, and that's where these fancy animations from other companies come in and then I had the same like a lot of this was my life in uh in in a former company, you know, you prepare the material for others to take the decision.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2147.0, "endTime": 2148.57, "body": "Now if you augment this with.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2149.479, "endTime": 2153.639, "body": "Appealing visualization, it helps the decision maker to take it.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2154.159, "endTime": 2157.29, "body": "But still the question is who wants to take decisions.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2157.439, "endTime": 2165.0, "body": "We could also argue that if at your hand, you can build the scenarios and you can explore, then you could take the decision already on your own.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2165.08, "endTime": 2168.1, "body": "Why don't you, did you need to go to someone else to take a decision?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2168.6, "endTime": 2174.979, "body": "Because like the the the better design compared to the worst design on your energy consumption.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2175.489, "endTime": 2178.02, "body": "Yeah, you have your target, you can take the decision on your own.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2179.33, "endTime": 2185.229, "body": "Well, it's, uh, we, we touched upon that people aspect earlier and I wanted to, to pivot back, back to that.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2185.659, "endTime": 2192.55, "body": "And it's quite interesting now like Altair was acquired by Siemens and Altair has like about like 3000 people.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2192.629, "endTime": 2195.909, "body": "We had Siemens are like about like 300,000 people.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2196.229, "endTime": 2204.05, "body": "How do you see like these like cultures coming together like for one, like what could like be, yeah, I don't know, like emerge from that.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2204.229, "endTime": 2230.669, "body": "And then that other thing and that was what you alluded to earlier, there are also like a lot of like personal challenges now with like the rise of technology and new tools and Also democratize access to a lot of tools, but at the same time I still have to like expose myself to that to that and be open to that and embrace that and maybe that's also something that we could like at Siemens is the giant could learn from more of a like a company like Aldair or so what's your take on that", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2230.669, "endTime": 2232.719, "body": "first of all, like my personal learning, right?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2233.05, "endTime": 2234.79, "body": "Because I, I, I've grown up in Munich.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2234.949, "endTime": 2237.06, "body": "I'm a German engineer um.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2237.56, "endTime": 2238.699, "body": "High quality, they're good.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2239.669, "endTime": 2242.129, "body": "That is your, your judgment.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2242.75, "endTime": 2251.729, "body": "I, I left some high class German engineering companies to follow this Altair US software company on that size you just described.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2252.11, "endTime": 2260.919, "body": "Is this, it's not a startup anymore, but it was way smaller than now the the our nice Siemens company uh or family is.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2261.429, "endTime": 2261.879, "body": "So.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2262.409, "endTime": 2268.979, "body": "The the simple argument smaller organizations act faster compared to large organization may hold.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2269.639, "endTime": 2272.199, "body": "Now you, you touched on the cultural aspect.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2272.32, "endTime": 2274.6, "body": "Culture is not a, not a number, right?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2274.719, "endTime": 2277.199, "body": "Culture are, are other differences.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2277.28, "endTime": 2278.77, "body": "So what is the Siemens culture?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2278.87, "endTime": 2280.59, "body": "What has been the Altair culture?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2281.159, "endTime": 2282.84, "body": "Do we fit together?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2282.969, "endTime": 2284.419, "body": "I think we do.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2285.04, "endTime": 2287.58, "body": "I'll tear this only forward now we're forward together.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2289.719, "endTime": 2317.58, "body": "That is still upcoming and I like to even bring this little bit of Alter experience from these 2.5 years into the largest Siemens organization to maybe, you know, push, push here and there and, and, and be faster, not going back into, OK, this was the large organization, it defines where we go and I, I fill in because that was maybe part of the reason that I've left other companies.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2318.01, "endTime": 2322.33, "body": "So that's, that's my own learning, that's my situation right now while being integrated.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2322.919, "endTime": 2327.739, "body": "Um, yeah, let's see how we, how we execute on this, uh, being part together.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2328.08, "endTime": 2330.219, "body": "Um, yeah, I'm looking forward to this", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2332.479, "endTime": 2334.51, "body": "for sure, and let's look, look even further.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2334.59, "endTime": 2350.699, "body": "Let's look in 2035 once again, right, closing the loop, you know, when, when we, when we, when we recorded with Richard So, you know, back in the days, aspects, and he was, he was resonating, he's like, you know.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2351.02, "endTime": 2356.629, "body": "Um, hey guys, you need to accept that in the future, you will be a manager of AIs, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2357.11, "endTime": 2361.909, "body": "Um, and I think it resonate is a bold statement, a good tagline I have the feeling, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2361.989, "endTime": 2362.659, "body": "Yeah, maybe.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2362.909, "endTime": 2374.61, "body": "And it's, it, it resonated with quite, quite some folks actually also in Siemens and about these aspects and what does it mean and so if you, if you resonate with this tagline a bit, right, what does it do for engineering?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2374.989, "endTime": 2375.57, "body": "You know what I mean?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2375.719, "endTime": 2380.25, "body": "Uh, are we, are we now the conductor.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2381.04, "endTime": 2403.729, "body": "Of little AI powered, you know, engineer agents, let's say, you know, software capabilities and on the, I don't know, APIs or MCPs or agent to agent whatever frameworks, right, around it, do we, do we, do we see that as we can package certain kinds of skills and we need, we need to as engineers learn to, you know, how do we, how do we cope that?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2403.83, "endTime": 2405.689, "body": "We need to accept that there are agents there.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2406.879, "endTime": 2410.05, "body": "Clear, yes, where's the problem with this?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2411.209, "endTime": 2411.219, "body": "Because.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2412.05, "endTime": 2413.01, "body": "What the heck are you?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2413.34, "endTime": 2413.35, "body": "Well,", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2414.01, "endTime": 2418.07, "body": "you know, yes, OK, we had it with computers as well.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2418.33, "endTime": 2424.01, "body": "I mean, I, I still like people told me that engineering has been done before computers.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2424.29, "endTime": 2425.729, "body": "That's not my personal story.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2426.04, "endTime": 2432.11, "body": "But yes, I, I already had the challenges of, we'll use a computer for this and don't draw it with hand.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2432.59, "endTime": 2434.86, "body": "Oh, but some calculation, you should do it with hand.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2435.03, "endTime": 2436.31, "body": "Yeah, maybe you should or not.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2436.389, "endTime": 2438.179, "body": "But I, I, you know, I'm on the computer side.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2438.429, "endTime": 2442.429, "body": "I love computers, um, because they're they're such a nice tool.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2442.51, "endTime": 2454.56, "body": "So taking out trial and error of expensive hardware testing, who would not love this trajectory?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2454.949, "endTime": 2461.85, "body": "So now mastering algorithms doing things on their own, who would not embrace this?", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2462.449, "endTime": 2475.129, "body": "So, I, I simply would say engineers are exactly the right drivers for this, and they should build their tools or use the tools to build both things have have its value.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2475.199, "endTime": 2475.3, "body": "That's", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2475.3, "endTime": 2475.31, "body": "it?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2475.32, "endTime": 2475.33, "body": "Yeah,", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2477.61, "endTime": 2485.669, "body": "yeah, and maybe, maybe to add to that, so this is I guess like already a piece of advice that you're sharing here that they should go out there and build their own stuff and use it and embrace it.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2485.889, "endTime": 2488.36, "body": "And like there's like no questions asked, like, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2488.55, "endTime": 2495.57, "body": "But is there anything else that you would like to like leave as a message maybe to the to to the audience that is listening in today?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2495.79, "endTime": 2499.649, "body": "Like, what is another like piece of advice that you'd like to share or?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2500.189, "endTime": 2505.8, "body": "Yeah, so I, I can just confirm that building is more than consuming.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2506.199, "endTime": 2515.659, "body": "So we sometimes see AI as coming out of space and and we use it, that's like how we use chat GBT large language models.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2516.0, "endTime": 2532.5, "body": "I would encourage everyone to look on it as I use the technology for, for my own unique creativity or or processes and that's, I think, no news for engineers, but that could scale to to everyone and therefore.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2532.87, "endTime": 2539.189, "body": "Yes, that's, that's the positive thing uh compared to having fear of someone, some AI takes over.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2539.31, "endTime": 2540.61, "body": "I, I don't believe this at all.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2540.79, "endTime": 2542.57, "body": "So how can we shape the world?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2542.83, "endTime": 2546.209, "body": "How can we build something and not what is AI going to do to us?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2546.879, "endTime": 2553.189, "body": "Yes, because we at Siemens, we are a technology company, so we will shape and build technology.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2553.27, "endTime": 2555.469, "body": "We've done this and we will do this in the digital.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2555.8, "endTime": 2555.81, "body": "as", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2562.87, "endTime": 2562.889, "body": "we go.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2562.899, "endTime": 2572.229, "body": "We've done at the end of our podcastiemen", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2582.85, "endTime": 2583.129, "body": "Siemens you're awesome, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2583.139, "endTime": 2583.229, "body": "Yeah, we have our final game.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2583.239, "endTime": 2584.989, "body": "It's called Authentic autocomplete.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2585.429, "endTime": 2595.04, "body": "And we would like to wrap it up and play the signature game and uh we'll throw out some sentence starters and we'd love for you to complete them.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2595.949, "endTime": 2599.59, "body": "Are you ready for the final challenge of 2025?", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2601.07, "endTime": 2604.719, "body": "And, so, starting off with physics AI is.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2605.439, "endTime": 2609.61, "body": "A a rapidly growing software product from Altair now Siemens.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2614.82, "endTime": 2616.52, "body": "We, we're not spoiler, right?", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2616.879, "endTime": 2619.36, "body": "We try to try to invent it, but maybe it's a go.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2619.439, "endTime": 2620.02, "body": "OK.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2621.379, "endTime": 2622.32, "body": "Uh, simulation is.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2624.139, "endTime": 2630.56, "body": "A great way to explore and drive decision making, and I'm happy if it is digital.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2631.659, "endTime": 2632.36, "body": "OK.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2633.04, "endTime": 2635.08, "body": "Technology with purpose is.", "speaker": "Speaker 3"}, {"startTime": 2636.06, "endTime": 2638.26, "body": "A great claim for leading enterprises.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2639.08, "endTime": 2642.159, "body": "Oh, let, let that sink.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2642.679, "endTime": 2644.939, "body": "Um, easy one, last one.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2645.479, "endTime": 2650.0, "body": "If I could invent one rule for everyone to follow in the world, it would be.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2652.36, "endTime": 2653.3, "body": "Stay curious.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2654.28, "endTime": 2667.919, "body": "And if you will the, the, the like my personal model would be more like uh this uh quote from Abraham Lincoln, so if I had 6 hours to chop down a tree, I'd spend the 1st 4 of them sharpening the ax.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2668.439, "endTime": 2678.32, "body": "So still, you know, think about what you want to achieve and not take the easiest way.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2679.02, "endTime": 2708.31, "body": "I just thought about what I want to achieve and I think I hope guys out there in the market and on LinkedIn and on Spotify, Amazon, Apple Music, and all the platforms that you listen to there, I hope you had a great experience talking about with Moritz as a fantastic guest and Aubrey as my My uh trusted partners, uh, partner in Grime and co-host podcast, uh, chief, chief boss, um, you know, and, on this Insights on the Human AI podcast.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2708.419, "endTime": 2718.06, "body": "Maury, thanks so much for, you know, spending time with us, recording a cool session and Downtown in Munich, downtown in the Siemens, and thanks for being part of the game here.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2718.189, "endTime": 2718.32, "body": "It's", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2718.32, "endTime": 2720.01, "body": "a great pleasure and hope to do this again.", "speaker": "Moritz Frenzel"}, {"startTime": 2721.129, "endTime": 2728.31, "body": "And folks out there, stay tuned, stay humble, stay bold, stay committed, stay open-minded and hear us at the next Siemens A Live podcast.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}, {"startTime": 2728.649, "endTime": 2729.09, "body": "Cheers.", "speaker": "Speaker 2"}], "language": "en-US"}