Working in a global industry while building out local capacity

The Battery Podcast ·

Show notes

We are back for another episode of The Battery Podcast, wrapping up our conversation with Roger Aktins of Electric Vehicles Outlook. In part one we discussed some of the challenges impacting automotive OEMs in the transition to electric vehicle manufacturing as well as some of the interesting business models the transition has let emerge. Whether it is automotive companies becoming battery companies or battery companies becoming energy providers at a grid-scale.

But in part two we are delving into the coming requirements for the industry as well as how businesses are already adjusting to a new status quo. China may have a head start on battery development and EVs, but as you’ll hear there are some opportunities for European and North American automakers to get back some of this ground.

What you’ll learn:

The industry-wide impact of battery passport regulations

Finding value by adding value in a global supply network

Why investing locally will be critical in finding a foothold in a market increasingly dominated by Chinese manufacturers

Transcript

Welcome back for another episode of the battery podcast from Siemens Digital-Industries. In the last episode, we left off with Roger Atkins of Electric Vehicles Outlook, talking about the investments being made in the world of battery. I'm your moderator, Nick Finberg, joined by our host and battery expert Pet Sinha. In wrapping up our conversation with Roger, we'll be diving into the impact of regulation on the market and what some businesses or even governments are doing to stay competitive. In the last episode, we brought up battery passports in relation to government intervention in the market and the rollout for Europe is fast approaching for that. What's going on at battery manufacturers and OEMs to tackle this new requirement? Yeah, uh, battery passport regulation is Little less than 2 years away. OK, the, the way it is for our audience, come February 2027. Any company that is looking to sell a system, uh, that has a battery of more than 2 kilowatt-hour, they won't be able to sell it unless it has a QR code, uh, that, that documents, hey, what chemistry and, and what is the supply chain, carbon footprint, and certain level of information that, that comes with it, right? So what it does is, again, um, and again, going back to the point that Roger made, I think it, it is an effort from EU perspective to bring, um, More supply chain traceability, uh, in terms of where various minerals and materials are coming from, but also encouraging, uh, companies, uh, to, to have, um, control over the overall carbon footprint and, and other like a wastewater and everything that, that comes with it, especially with battery manufacturing. And why it is, I mean, I, I, I mean, this is a conversation that has happened many times in, in, uh, in, in news and and many other outlets. People have talked about, you know, uh, that, hey, is battery is really clean, or are electric vehicles going to be cleaner than ICA vehicles? And, um, Uh, the, the crux of that conversation comes from the fact that if you look at the battery production, it's extremely energy intensive process. Although when you put that that same battery in a vehicle, of course, there is no toilpipe emissions. So overall, if you look at the complete, um, life cycle of electric vehicle, the emissions are much, much lower than IC engine. There is no comparison. But if we just look at the battery production, the, the, the it's extremely energy intensive. Some of the studies that I've seen is that say that, Uh, in some of the worst-case scenarios, around 30 to 40 units of energy you have to consume to create one unit of battery, uh, energy, right? So the point is, it's extremely energy intensive. So how, um, how companies are looking to optimize their, you know, overall energy consumption, what energy makes, clean energy or, or, or, or, or the, the traditional. Resources they're using, uh, to, to power that large scale manufacturing, your factories, that all are part of this, right? How much scrap rate they're having, you know, the wastewater. So all of that, EU is of providing that, looking to bring that perspective so that companies have, uh, visibility and onto all of those elements. And also, what it also is, will help is when the batteries are coming to end of life, as those batteries are getting utilized. There is a a consumer can understand what is the remaining value of their batteries. Can it, if they have to sell those cars in the, in, in the market, what, what is the real value they can get out of it, or how the companies, uh, automakers, or, or a system integra like energy storage company, whosever, what are, are they supposed to take it for the second usage, which are possible? What's the recycling and make a data-driven decision based on. The data that is getting collected and shared on how that battery is being utilized. So it is a major piece of regulation that is, that will come into effect in February, and a lot of details are getting figured out. But the important thing is that battery passport is, although it is coming from the EU, there are similar efforts that are being made in Asia as well. I mean, China is, is looking to, they, they have said that they want to, all the battery manufacturing and what are they, they want, you know, Mimic or or aligned with some of those EU battery passport regulation and other countries are doing that. So, yes, it is starting with the EU come in less than 2 years, but it is very likely that the similar regulations are, uh, that, that enforce certain supply chain traceabilities are, are in effect in other parts of the world. And, and, and, and because of that. The challenges for any company, for example, any automaker, they, right now, they are engaging with, let's say, cell supplier, getting certain cells for, for their vehicles. Now, they have to be more mindful of where those materials are coming from, how much, you know, carbon footprint they're dealing with, and not only in in the production, but also transport of those batteries that that are crossing borders and everything that come with it. Um, so it, it, it is going to pose a challenge for everybody in the supply chain to meet those regulations and have the right data, uh, to, to, to have that traceability and, and have that visibility that in, in future can help consumers drive certain demand for what kind of battery they want to use in terms of the overall emissions. Raja, what kind of conversation you are seeing in that aspect? Well, you summed it up very well, and you've gone through it all in detail, and, and you're right, and you mentioned their transport, uh, Pune. I think that's, to me, apart from the geopolitical challenge, the the over-reliance on, on Asia for Europe, when you think about it, so the, the, the mining takes place all over the world. But then if all of that material, heavy material, almost always, is shipped all the way to China to be processed, and then made into batteries, and then those batteries shipped all the way to Europe, I mean, why can't you cut those two big bits out? Why can't we ship more or have more minerals closer to home, and more battery factories closer to home? Because otherwise, it seems to me when we have this battery passport, If you look at the weighting of the different items in it, so let's say, you know, how clean is the graphite? Is the graphite manufactured using hydrochloric and hydrochloric acids or something else, and so on and so forth. If you look at the weighting of value in terms of uh the, the, the clean factor, the, the reduction of carbon footprint. Uh, I'd argue, surely that the shipping is, is the biggest weighted part, is, is the biggest issue. So, localizing this stuff isn't just about security of supply and not being over reliant on China and Asia here in Europe. Um, it's equally about doing what we're supposed to be doing with all of this, which is tackling climate change and reduce CO2 levels, otherwise we're kidding ourselves. Or even a a half step, um, say you're mining a critical resource in Brazil, why not at the very least refine that material before sending it off to the global supply chain, um, only a fraction of the extracted mass is gonna be used, so why not add value locally while, while also reducing the shipped mass. Nick, you are spot on, and there are now countries, particularly countries and their leaders saying, hang on a second, why are we shipping this raw material somewhere when we could be adding value to it by processing it ourselves? They're saying that in Australia, they're saying that in South America, and I suspect they'll be saying that more than more in Africa too. So you, you raise a very good point there in that intervention, so speak up anytime you like, um. You know, because, yeah, this, the battery passport is, I was pleased to hear Robin Zheng, the boss of CATL, the most significant battery company in the world, reference it in detail during a recent, I think it was at Davos, maybe not this year, last year. So they're well aware of it. So we shouldn't be complacent in Europe and think, oh, they just make dirty batteries in China. So, yeah, as long as we fulfill the battery passport, we're sorted, you know, we won't be able to import their batteries. Don't rest on your laurels, don't think, don't think that's the case. But your, your point there about adding value, and localizing, uh, localizing, um, the processing is really important, and go back to why don't we? Well, because in the past, we didn't think it was significant. In the past, processing graphite, which is traditionally, not now, there are better processes, but dirty, labor intensive, low value, why should we do that? Let the Chinese do it. You know, it's very easy, you can look through a lens at the Chinese in one of a number of ways, but, but one of them is to say, You know, they just did what opportunity we gave them. You know, there there's, there's no kind of sinister motivation to this. Some of this stuff we should be doing, we didn't want to do, and they just put their hand up. That's it. Yeah. One point I want to add on battery passport, and this is, um, without naming the company. So I, I was in, Uh, Korea and I, I was having a conversation with one of the company's executives, and the conversation went to battery passport. Um, and this company, they are, they, they are pack integrators. And what this person said, this executive said that they remained with me and that that gave me, helped me appreciate the, the power of battery passport, uh, And, and, and what, what it is going to do. So again, if, if you look at right now what's happening, um, somebody makes a sale, right? And then let's say those cells are taken by an automaker and just simplifying it. They, they put it in a pack, and, and they, they are, that automaker is collecting data on how that battery is being utilized as that vehicle is being run through, through the, you know, um, you know, all that, through the telemetics and all. So it's the automaker who, uh, in, in the EV world, who has, A lot more information about how is that battery being utilized in their vehicle, in their systems. But if you are a little bit upstream, be it a cell manufacturer, or, or somebody who's in the middle who's being maybe pack integrated or offering some other solutions, they don't get that data. They do not get that information on how is that battery being utilized, and, and what does it mean for that company to engineer, manufacture, uh, the next generation of batteries based on how consumers are using it, right? So, in this company, this executive said, what he was most excited about with battery passport is as the data will be collected about the usage of battery, because the battery passport is not just going to have static data of what it is made of, what kind of materials going in there, it's also going to have how that battery, that specific battery is utilized by that particular, you know, in that particular system, how many times it is charged, when it is a charged, so a certain amount of dynamic data. And, um, if it, when it is made available, that's something that is very powerful and very enriching for the upstream companies to get better insights on how exactly battery is being utilized. So they, perhaps they don't have to over-engineer by 20, 30%, it's making it up, right? Um, that much, or they don't have to design for 900th percentile all the time, because they have a better insights into how exactly batteries are being utilized in, in a given region for a given, You know, target persona or or consumer. And that is very powerful to improve the cost, improve the life, uh, minimize the usage of extra material or, you know, the, and again, all of that also feeds back into sustainability, feeds back into the, you know, uh, reduction of material that that you are utilizing and or wasting in, in, in, in creation of batteries and whatnot. So, I found it very powerful. Yeah, Nick, do you mind if I jump in and just ask Punit where he was finishing there in particular, the recycling sustainability recycling. Um, I perhaps shouldn't understand this, but I don't. So, increasingly seeing cell to pack, and increasingly seeing batteries, battery packs, uh, integrated into vehicle architecture and vehicle bodies, what does that mean for recycling going forward, if the whole thing is, you know, one lump? Yeah, this is, I mean, there's definitely a challenge, right? I mean, this is where like the two, the way I look at it, the two priorities start to collide. One side is if, if you are a system integrator, let's say, a vehicle maker. When I was working for a vehicle maker, I mean, you know, we always said, the biggest currency for a vehicle is volume, not the weight. It's the volume. You have to fit in, fit that battery in a certain amount of volume, and any volume that is not a battery in the battery pack is wastage, right? So, every company, the design criteria is maximize the number of cells you can pack in that volume. So, but if you look at the battery pack, traditional battery pack, what it has, is going to have certain structural beams. And it's going to have certain volume that will be taken away by, you know, coolant, uh, lines that are going through that and other things, right? So, every company, every battery engineer, uh, needs, looks to minimize those things, right? How can you minimize that? Some of that is absolutely necessary, like a thermal management, you have to do that. So increasingly, companies are looking into, can they remove some of those structural elements instead of having 6 beams, can they have 2 beams, or maybe no beams, right? Uh, so can they remove those things so they can pack more number of cells in the same pack? And, and it can be like approved like 15% in higher energy density of the same chemistry because you are packing more cells in the given volume. So that is the ambition, uh, companies, automakers. You know, battery guys want to go out to the cell to pack architecture, because now you don't have to, traditionally, you take cells, you make, make modules, you take those modules, you put them in those modules like a Lego bricks in, in the battery pack, right? So that, that is to improve the energy density. But if you look from the other side of the equation, which is somebody has to service, sometimes servicing are needed. Somebody has to take care of the end of life, what happens after recycling, reuse. And what are the implications for that? And, of course, cell to pack in engineering can have challenges. I'm not, I'm not going to say it's always as challenging, but it can have challenges in removing, you know, some of those cells or how you recycle that or the ease of that. Um, so absolutely, there, there are some of those priorities are colliding. And, and the question is how are there incentives to reuse or, uh, or those packs as is, or are there incentives to recycle, extract the material out? And what is the economics, um, an equation around it? And also, uh, can the sell to pack architectures be developed in a way that they can be, um, optimized or, or, or, you know, um, Service better. And a great example of that is if you look at CATL, right? CATL has talked a lot about the Shielle battery, which is set to pack architecture, but they are also talking about what they call, um, and Roger and I, we, we saw that when we were in battery in, in Asia, uh, what they call, um, choco swap. So what that means is like a chocolate, um, bar, you, you can take certain fraction of the battery pack away or, or add to it, right? Uh, so to increase the range, if you're going for a long drive, you can just plug it in, in another, you know, block and go forward. So again, so if you look at those designs are companies like, and I'm, I'm not saying CRL is the only one. Every company, CATL, BYD, LG, uh, a lot of, all of them are working through those. How can they match? Maximize the energy density, but make sure, do it in a way that can be flexible, be it for a servicing, or, you know, some plug and play later on. Um, so I, I think those are, those are active areas of engineering and optimization, the way I see it. I don't think anybody has the, uh, absolute right answer at this time. Hm. By the way, that, that, that noise wasn't me coughing, that was Presley the dog barking by the door of my office. Just so, just so in case anybody wondered. I'd like to make a suggestion to a company, hopefully, the maintenance of the 2035 um deadline in Europe for stopping making um internal combustion engines. And it's this, we should have a strategy called Made in Europe 2035. And to accompany that, I would recommend having a program a bit like, well, a lot like they've had in China for many years, an annual program called um EV 100. I don't know, maybe Punit's been to one of these. I, I've only been to one, a long time ago, 2017. And what it does is brings together the politicians, the OEMs, the supply chain tier ones, investors, all the, all the, all the interested parties to basically, um, To basically build a plan and deliver on the plan, you know, it's an action-orientated plan, and because they do, they have this meeting, this rendezvous every year, once a year, it's, it's, it is progressively building up the ambition of, you know, as was made in China 2025. Um, so we can't just in Europe snap our fingers and let the politicians simply say, you've got to do this, you've got to do that. What we've got to do is have, yeah, an industrial strategy that is anchored in detail, and that a forum in which we bring together the interested parties, the key players. We don't have that. We have events, we have things like, OK, I've just been at one, you know, IAA, we have, you know, battery show, we have all these things, but they, they never put all the right people in the room at the same time to talk about policy and progress. They have, you know, lots of great panels, they're all good, don't get me wrong. But if we really want to get serious about this, we need to have a 10 year vision that is a plan that can be executed on, and it's managed and calibrated year on year. So my suggestion, Made in Europe 2035 and have an annual forum to deliver it. Very well said. I, I fully agree that, you know, these things need to go, I mean, for, for. To to be a major player in, in this rapidly changing battery industry, right? It's, it's a, the, the, it's a great opportunity. It's an economy-wise, geopolitical consideration in the 21st century and and what it means for all of us. Uh, but, but the challenge is, it is not, as, as Roger, you said, it's it, A country, any country, or, uh, any company is not going to solve all these elements by themselves. It requires a collaboration across industry, but also with policymakers and customers to make sure, hey, the, the, we have the right ecosystem. And, and you said it very well, Roger. It's like, uh, you know, for every zone, every country needs to have. That framework, and, and again, China and countries in Asia like Korea, Japan, they have shown the way, how they have invested it with a strategy and vision in a longer term to drive the progress. Uh, and again, the, just, just to add to Roger, uh, perspective, the, I mean if you, if you look at it, CATL did not exist as a company before 2011. So in 10 years' time, Uh, it came to dominate the world of battery. They, they are the, the movers and shakers. And it's, it's, it's, of course, a tremendous credit, uh, you know, um, credit to what the company has done, but also it's a, it's a reminder that a company, be it in a new company in the US, a new company in, in Europe, can also become the next. CHL, uh, a, a country can become what China has become in the world of battery in the last 15 years. US and Europe can get there, but that requires the focused collaboration, and, and, and as you said, a strategy, a policy and strategy driven execution. …

Full transcript (WebVTT)