Unlocking the potential of Battery Management Systems (BMS)

The Battery Podcast ·

Show notes

In this episode, we continue our conversation on battery developments and the automotive market with our host Nick Finberg and Puneet Sinha, Senior Director - Battery Industry at Siemens Digital Industries Software as they delve into the intriguing world of standardization, modularity, and battery management systems (BMS) with Dr. Cecile Pera - Battery & Automotive Industry Influencer.

Discover the complexities of the electric vehicle landscape, the challenges in standardizing components, and the evolving role of BMS in shaping the future of battery technology.

What you’ll learn:

[1:02] How are companies looking at standardization in the market?

[3:50] Modularity in the battery pack design

[11:20] What development is going into the battery management systems?

[17:07] The influence of software on batteries, with OTA updates

Interested in learning more about our battery solutions? Visit siemens.com/battery

Transcript

Hello and welcome to the battery podcast from Siemens Digital-Industries. This is a continuation of our discussion from last time with Cecile Perra talking about battery developments and the automotive market. I'm your moderator, Nick Finberg, and I'm joined by Penet Senna, senior director and head of battery industry at Siemens Digital-Industries Software. For anyone that missed part one with Cecile, she has a background in traditional automotive powertrains, but switched gears when she saw the rise of electrification and has kept up to date with the industry since. We'll start off today's discussion. What are your thoughts on maybe the shift towards commodification of specific components within the industry? Um, so if you're standardizing to certain form factors or voltages or even standard pack sizes, do you see a shift in maybe how the automotive industry might function when there are fewer people creating these items or it's a smaller market? So it's a very, very common question I receive very often, like, and what if all the industry could sit together and decide on some standardization, because in terms of recycling, in terms of refurbishing and so on, it would really help, I'm going to say humanity to get everything simple and maybe agree on something. Everyone would get some standard about this, but I don't believe this can happen for the reason. That OEM need to differentiate themselves because internal combustion engine adds a specificity that you add some character, some specificity. So here again, you really need to get your specificity as an OEM and this is one of the key points in terms of. It's still difficult for many people to see emotion and still difficult to see how they sell their image, but you can see some OM trying to do that and some better than others, like Tesla gets a certain personality, and for sure Tesla is not going to adapt, for example, the standard of someone else. Or for example, Porsche, they have the unicity to get, uh, it's not very common, as you know, to get two gear for an electric vehicle. And they keep that also in the sense that it makes them or at least the Titan slightly different from other pack makers or there is like the last Maserati Gran Turismo that gets a battery pack with definitelyly not a flat floor battery because they need this for their personality and their way to drive, so. In terms of strategy, if the OEM would agree altogether on some standard like say everyone using prismatic or everyone using cylindrical or whatever, then it will remove a certain competition and plus the fact that there are so many things happening all the time because Cells, just the cells, there are new cells formats, cell factor are slightly a little bit more increased here, and this increasement in power density may be enhanced because you have this sort of cooling here, so. I don't believe OEM get an interest to sit all together to agree first. Secondly, I also do not believe in terms of the best of the technology, it would be. It it would cut the possibility to develop further in my opinion, but I do agree that if we could get something like some kind of standard, then in terms of future problems like recycling, dismantling, and so on, of course it would help, but I don't believe it's, I don't believe it's going to happen. I don't believe so. Let, let me add some color to it as well. I agree that industry right now is far away from standardization for many, many reasons. Uh, those reasons include, but not, are not limited to the shape and size of the cells they're using in their pack, the size of the pack, and the technology elements, and those technology elements can be. Not just about the, the cell hardware, but also even about battery management system. A lot of the companies are are using wired battery management systems. Some companies are looking to move to a wireless, uh, battery management system architecture as well. But then there are additional issues also start coming. As you know, right now, most of the companies are working on. And on. Delivering battery packs that can be charged quickly and when I say quickly means, you know, uh, less than 30 minutes. So that, that's where some companies are delivering solutions. A lot more companies are looking to build those battery packs and integrate in their vehicles to achieve that. But in the pursuit of reducing charging time, some of the companies are also reinvigorating, uh, the concept that has been tried, let's say 1015 years back, that is battery swapping. And, and now that the electrification has become a mainstream element of transportation industry, I think there are certain benefits of re-looking at it. NEEO in China, for example, is one such company that is strongly looking into it and also rolling out some of their battery swapping stations. So when you look at all of these elements of not just technology, but the customer experience, uh, companies are looking to deliver, deliver standardization. It is not possible. Having said that. For a given company. Which is looking to build electric vehicles for different purposes for passenger, uh, vehicle to pickup trucks to even, even to semis or, uh, you know, um, mass transportation. There is significant benefit if they can, within a company can standardize on a battery pack platform, which is modular, they can add to that, but keep the structure or, or the layout same. And we are seeing many companies are looking to move in that direction. For example, GM has come up with their RTM, uh, battery architecture. So, of course, you know, as they, as they look to electrify. Their complete vehicle, uh, line, they're not gonna use the same battery pack, but they're looking to leverage the same architecture and the same goes for many other companies. So a lot of companies are looking to do that to bring more efficiency in their design, engineering, manufacturing, service of their electric vehicles, and that is a welcome move because that definitely makes it a lot more easy for. One company's vehicle to be serviced, better, to be, uh, you know, to be manufactured a lot more easily, that brings down the cost and also then, um, The use of, the, the issues of reuse and recycling becomes relatively easy for a set of vehicles that are coming from one company. So that, that is great and I, I believe. More and more companies. are looking and moving in the direction of standardizing their electric vehicle battery architecture. Which may differ from other companies' architecture. I would like to to add something here. It's true what you say. It's completely true, and modularity is really one of the key trends we see in battery pack design, but it still depends on the strategy of the OEM. Like for example, Volkswagen gets this platform which you've got your battery pack which can be. I think 79, or 12 modules. So it's relatively easy because the modules are easy to integrate and they are the same, so you can plug and play in the sense, depending on the size of your pack. So it's relatively modular and with one architecture they can fit a lot of different cars inside the Volkswagen Group, but That works because most of their cars are not that much different. If you take a group like Stelantis, for example, this is slightly different because if you take an OEM like Maserati, they cannot, if they would use the same platform as I don't know. Just a Nopel or whatever, this would not allow them to differentiate themselves inside the brand. So in the case of Stelentis, the Maserati would get a very different battery pack if you are talking about the Gran Turismo or if you are talking the Grecale, which is the SUV, because you still need to get this identity and this differentiation because otherwise you have no purpose. So. It's true modularity is key and it reduces costs, obviously, but at the same time it also reduces the personality you can add inside your own group or within different worldwide OEM, so. It's a difficult game between what you try to standardize in terms of simplification and cost reduction and where you try to be able to be more flexible or get more high performance technology or very on purpose development. Again, to for certain purpose of application like slightly motor sport I would say, but still it's, it's a difficult choice to do for NOM to know where they want to to get something very, very modular or more specific. So, Cecile, uh, I have a question. I would love to understand your perspective. As both you and I know, battery pack is more than assembly of cells. There is a battery management system, which is actually the brain of battery, and there is a lot of activities happening in the industry to build a robust battery management system that can help avoid a lot of recall issues. I'll be very interested to understand your perspective on what is happening in the industry for battery management system development. And some of the challenges that come with it. So again, BMS is a full part of the technology on itself with BMS getting different sub technologies that are trying to be developed in part by many people. So there are many, many different things I can talk about BMS. You mentioned wireless BMS is one of them. I think another very key trend is also to use. Coupling the BMS with the cloud, so you also store a part of the energy, then enter here a lot of different strategies. So some people want to put a part of the computation directly on the chip on the BMS and then just exchange a part with the cloud. Some people want to exchange more in the cloud. There are here also on the topic about digital twin because in order to save a little bit of data, there are a lot of strategy to construct. Highly complex digital twin, which it's one of the key trends. There are also a lot of things about aging of the cell. We have not talked about that, but warranty and life of the battery is very key. So for now the standard is 8 years, but we have people pushing for 10 years and some lobby pushing for 12, if I have even 15 years possible in the future. So balancing of the cell. Being able to target the aging is very key. Also, another point is when we have developed internal combustion engine, we have been through discovering problems that happen. Like, for example, a very famous example in the internal combustion engine is what we call the anti-mini cycle. So it means like I'm an old woman. I'm not old, but let's imagine I'm old on this example. And I just want to take my car to buy some bread daily. I take my car, make a cold start each morning, drive my car 1 kilometer, come back. We have discovered with aging of automotives that this sort of behavior is very bad for internal combustion engine because you are running cold start constantly. What I want to say is that. I'm sure, I'm 100% sure that in the future we will discover that some behavior may not be that good for aging of the battery. I don't know what it is for now, and I guess people would like to know, but I don't know. Maybe if you live close to the sea and get a lot of corrosion, or I don't know, maybe if you park your car and you are on. Uh, on the mountain and do not regenerate correctly when you start, I don't know, we probably are going to discover that there are some behaviors better than others, and then the BMS here starts to be key because it's not only monitoring the cell, I mean, like the brain you have discovered, you have described before, but it also monitoring and gathering information to give this access to the OEM so they can also analyze in the future. And again, I think the OEMs that are the most advanced like Tesla, they benefit from the fact that they have data and collection of data for many, many years, so they know better than others some of this behavior probably than others, which in my opinion also participate to the fact that Tesla batteries seem to age. Better than some other, I would say. So, and again here CMMs would have a lot of things to do because data management as a software, a very expert software company, of course you have tons of things to play here. That that's great, Cecil. This is very insightful, and some of the things that we are also seeing in our engagement with the industry. All the issues that you mentioned are coming to the fore. Uh, recently, my team was talking with, uh, an OEM and they were talking about usage-driven engineering. It's pretty much taking a similar example that you said, hey, there is a person who is charging their vehicle every time they find a charger. versus a person who is more adventurous and only gonna charge their vehicle when the battery is pretty much at zero? What are the implications of that on, on battery aging, how the battery management system can help guide. Certain control strategies and learn from the usage of vehicle depending on, depending on driver persona. So they are definitely some of the areas companies are looking into and again, uh, we are more and more in our daily lives getting used to getting a customized experience, be it with our cell phones, be it, you know, the e-retail shopping experiences and those technologies, AI and, and the machine learning and, and, and the behavior mapping. I believe they are very rapidly going to make their way in the world of battery because at the end, Today's generation is that of experience. So a lot of that parallels what's happening in the automotive industry, whether it's ICE or electric vehicles in figuring out what is the usage of these cars by the customers um and even to a large extent with electrification, not just in the battery or the propulsion systems, but in the accessory and entertainment systems, and you can update them automatically or once they have left the lot. Is there any way currently or a pathway in the future to begin to update BMS systems after they leave the shop floor, uh, to either prioritize the charging schedules, um, for someone who goes all the way to zero every time, or if they're topping up to create, uh, more of a, a padding at the end or top of the battery to help with longevity, um, are there any things happening in that space? Over the air, so what we call autota over the air, is again one of the key trends for electric vehicles in general because Aar can be used in two ways, or at least two ways I know. The first one is to make update of the software, so maybe there is one thing you want to update about the software or whatever. The second one is to, as I say, push the data from the OEM so you. At Battery show, for example, you could see some people explaining to you how OEM could maybe in the future get fleet management or at least statistics of data where they received information from the BMS with this OA. Then I would say also to complete the BMS discussion in this, there are also BMS that are able to adapt the behavior of the driver by some artificial intelligence. So there is a company called Etronic Technologies, at least I know this one, in the UK where they have a BMS. Well, their BMS will take into account aging, which can be slightly different depending on the way you are using your electric vehicle, like, as you say, if you are charging it daily or if you are driving super sporty or like an old woman or whatever. So depending on this, the way the BMS will Control the aging of the of the cell will start to adapt individually, if I would say that thanks to some kind of artificial intelligence and discussion to the cloud and modeling store in the cloud and so on. They will start to get a better BMS and better hygiene depending on people like of this exchange. So again, Ota is one of the. Yeah, over the air and all this is really, really key. There are also people who want to use this over the air application also potentially to store what is the state of health of your battery. Also, if you would like, for example, to do. If you want to sell your electric vehicle secondhand, we also can imagine the future that with this, um, knowledge, I'm going to say coming from exchange with the BMS and and so on. With the QR code on the battery pack, you could have an estimation of what is the state of health of your battery pack. So it would, for example, help people purchasing a secondhand car to know if they if the battery is at risk or not, for example. Thank you, Cecile for joining us for the discussion and bringing your insight on the automotive market for battery, um, and thank you to the audience. We hope to have you back again soon. If you haven't listened to part one of our discussion with Cecile, it covers some of the design and manufacturing challenges OEMs and manufacturers are facing in the battery industry, um, as well as how a system view is critical to understand these hurdles, um, or you can listen to Mark Dia's interview from the battery show Europe and you can check out, uh, the episode description for where to find us and more information on the battery industry. This podcast contains the personal views and opinions of the speakers. It is important to note that these opinions are solely those of the speakers and do not reflect the views or positions of Siemens, its management, its employees, or any entities the speakers may be affiliated with. Siemens as a company does not endorse any of these statements made in the podcast. Siemens bears no responsibility for ensuring the content's accuracy or verifying the statements made in this podcast.

Full transcript (WebVTT)