Grappling with the evolving battery production landscape around the world

The Battery Podcast ·

Show notes

The Battery Podcast is back for another two-part discussion. This time we have a special guest to give us a wider view of what is happening in the world of batteries. From the geopolitical pressures of manufacturing to the work that goes into developing batteries from raw material. I’m your moderator Nick Finberg and I’m joined by our host and expert Puneet Sinha. The two of us sat down with Roger Aktins of Electric Vehicles Outlook.

In this first half of our discussion, we’ll dive into the changing role of government in the battery manufacturing space as well as some of the hurdles OEMs are dealing with in terms of the supply chain. Let’s listen in and answer some questions about the battery industry.

What you’ll learn:

The pressure on OEMs globally to compete with Chinese automakers and battery manufacturers

The value of multiple battery chemistries

The impact of state-level investment in emerging technologies

Transcript

We're back for another episode of the battery podcast from Siemens Digital-Industries. I'm your moderator, Nick Finberg, and I'm joined by our host and battery expert, Puneet Sinha. Today we have a very interesting guest, a self-described storyteller for the world of batteries, Roger Atkins of Electric Vehicles Outlook in the UK. We split our conversation into two parts, and in this first half, we'll be covering the evolving battery markets around the world, particularly in Europe and Asia. Welcome to the podcast, Roger. It's great to have you here. But maybe for the people who don't know what you do, would you mind talking a little bit about your background and what brought you to immerse yourself in the world of battery? Yeah, sure, absolutely, you know, delighted to do that. Nick, thanks for inviting me. Well, I've been in automotive for 40 years, 20 years in and around electric vehicles, 10 years working for myself, and since a moment, which perhaps we'll come onto in February 2019, I knew nothing really about batteries, mining, critical minerals. But there was a moment in time that, that suddenly arrived unexpectedly, and it's changed my narrative, changed my storytelling. And uh given me a very strong and keen focus on what I think is the fundamental part of both the electric vehicle revolution and the energy revolution. Awesome, thank you, Roger. Um, Pune, you're the one that kind of asked to have Roger come onto the show. Would you mind talking a little bit about what brought the two of you together and why you thought he'd be such an interesting guest for our audience? Absolutely. So, first of all, Roger is a person I've been, um, I've been connected to on LinkedIn for for some time. I've, I've been, uh, gaining insights into some of the commentary he has been doing on LinkedIn. Uh, but in person, I had a chance to meet with him and we both of us were at Battery Show Asia. We both were part of the advisory board and, and part of of the preliminary session that happened. And, um, I, I was immediately struck by the, um, the passion and that that Roger brings and, and the, the worldview that he's bringing, connecting the world of battery looking in the, in the larger arc of things. So, um, yeah, and, and he, he, he's an awesome person to talk to. So I thought it, it would be a great, great opportunity for the audience of Siemens Battery podcast to listen to Roger, for us to have a dialogue, understand his perspective, what, what views he's gathering, collecting as he is going and, and talking to executives and, and, and decision makers and influencers across the whole battery value chain. And, and one thing that definitely, Um, impressed me the most. One of the things about Roger is that for him, he's looking at battery, which is a value chain, which is very much the way we are thinking about battery in Siemens. It's not about cell or pack or which system it goes into. He has a very holistic view of from the materials. Um, and chemistries to sell and pack engineering, manufacturing, a system that needs to go and become part of, supply chain traceability, recycling. So a great, uh, perspective he's bringing for the industry. And I'm, I'm very excited, uh, Uh, for our audience and personally for myself to, to be engaging with Roger on this platform. Well, to that end, we just had IAA recently. Um, would you mind talking a little bit about what happened out there? Any interesting conversations you had, Roger? Yeah, but can I, before I say anything about what happened in Munich last week, just, just thank Puni. You've, you've really, uh, yeah, I've got a lot to live up to now, given what you've very kindly said. So I hope I'm not gonna disappoint anybody. Um. Uh, OK, yes, last week, IAA Mobility. Let's remember why it's called that and what it is. It is a mobility show. It was the 3rd 1 they've had, and it used to be the German car show, the German Auto Show. It was in Frankfurt for many, many years. And then some, I think, visionary people. Uh, 6 years ago, decided that it should be more embracing, more holistic, more about where particularly cities are going, and it's not just about cars. So, it's, it's rebranded, rechristened and recreated as um IAA mobility. And this was the 3rd 1 in Munich, it was tremendous. Why? There was Just evidence, clear evidence of not just ambition, but product. Product, services, business models, especially from the Germans, or from the Europeans to be. More accurate, but after the German auto industry looking like a boxer in the ring that's been punched in the face over and over, punched in the face with COVID, punched in the face with uh tariffs, punched in the face with the Chinese growth of EVs, punched in the face with the 2035 deadline, it looked like a boxer about to fall down on the ground and be knocked out for the count. But this event had a bit more of something unexpected. The, the boxer went back to the corner over the last couple of years, got toweled down, a little bit of a pep talk with the team, and he's now back up in the ring. Still got a big adversary, still got, when it comes to batteries, especially, the might and power and dominance, particularly of China, but let's not forget Japan and Korea. Because when we talk about batteries, it's so tempting to talk about CATL and BYD and Eve and a few others. But you know, there are tremendous companies in Japan, and likewise in Korea. So, yeah, what did I see? Well, the marriage, I've, I would like to announce a marriage. The marriage between mobility and uh energy. And the, the person conducting that marriage is the battery. The battery is bringing those two parties together like never before. And we've seen that by BMW showing bi-directional charging proposition, Volkswagen, bi-directional charging proposition, Porsche showing wireless charging, and You know, we didn't see, and maybe they were there and I missed them, I'm not sure. We didn't see NEEO, we didn't see the battery swap side of things. But, um, you know, that's another part of the architecture that's now being assembled to increasingly manage renewable energy stock, to balance and manage uh energy, renewable energy particularly, but energy wherever, and learn some pretty important lessons from the recent past. Um, particularly from the scenario as to what happened when Russia invaded Ukraine. Um, so yeah, really exciting and plenty of energy. That's the one word I came away with in my mind, energy, that you now see, uh, a bit more ambition, lots of collaboration, um, but a sense that there is a purpose to this. We're not just going to give up and get bashed in the face again and fall down and be knocked out. That, uh, yeah, we're, we're, there's a, there's a bit of a fight back going on. And if, if, if I can just add, I mean, what, what Rogers, what you just said, marriage between energy and mobility, that's awesome. That, that, that's a, that's a perfect sentence to, to say, to, to describe. Not only the present, but also the future of where this thing is going, right? And as you said, that it's the battery that is the, that is bringing the two sides together. Um, and you mentioned things in the, in the automotive world, but also if you look at it, The other side of the story is all the energy storage, right? So when you look at the, if you look at the equation of energy, right? In the equation of energy, uh, as renewable quotient is growing, That is demanding a lot more need for batteries to be part of that energy mix, to part of that battery equations, uh, sorry, the energy equations. And then with all this advent and demand that is exploding for AI data centers, Yes, it is, it is going to need a lot more electricity because those AI data centers are power hungry, right? But one thing that that is less talked about, but is very critical in everybody who is engaging in the world of data centers, is not just the amount of joules and watts, and also the quality because, um, of, of that ener energy or, or the, the transient nature of it. For example, Uh, if you look at data centers, and you think one job is finished and another job is going to come after a fraction of a second, in a, in a simple way, um, it can cause up to 40, 50%, uh, reduction in, in, in the energy demand for a fraction of a second because how the jobs are switching, because that AI demand is that power hungry. So a lot of the companies which with what they are also dealing with is not only that they need a lot more electricity, but also the quality of electricity when they need it. And to, to, to, uh, minimize that implications of this switching off 50% of electricity in a fraction of a second, that can brown a whole grid. And, and, um, that's where batteries are needed more than ever to, to, to, to, to, you know, make that, uh, the energy remain smooth. And, um, So, and that is an area, uh, you know, if you look at Tesla, and Tesla with their Tesla Energy business unit, they have been pioneering this whole thing around how will they take the same battery architecture more or less, that is going in a vehicle. How can they bring it for energy storage, be it at the, at the residential scale or at a commercial or grid scale. And that is a direction. That I'm seeing a lot more companies moving in that. And that is also the same part of the, the, uh, statement you said, marriage of energy and mobility. In the past, we've always seen, you know, batteries or other energy sources powering mobility, but what I'm seeing and very excited about is how these mobility companies. Um, auto automakers, how are they gonna go and say, can they go and be part of the solution of the energy world, especially as the data center, AI data center exploding. So it's, it's, and again, as you said, the, the, the, the, The element that is making this marriage happen is bad, so it's exciting times ahead. Yeah, it, it is, and I'll give you some examples. BYD and Octopus Energy here in the UK. You've now got BMW and Eon in Germany. You've got the Volkswagen Group uh with Ottovo, which is a solar company in Scandinavia. So you're, it's beginning to make you think, at what point, if ever, maybe not, the auto companies can become energy companies. And it also starts to make you think, well, who owns the battery? If the battery becomes an asset rather than a liability, You want to own an asset, because an asset typically, you know, an asset class proposition, enables you to trigger and create recurring revenue. Now, the fascinating thing about the BYD and Octopus Energy thing is that they're leasing uh an EV. And therefore, you, you don't own the battery, and you as the, the lessor, the customer of that BYD car through this system, you won't enjoy or get any of the direct benefit of the energy trading, but what you will get is a period of free mileage, that's part of the package, um, and it's particularly generous with BYD and, uh, an Octopus because you get a free bidirectional charger as well. And the cost of those, from what I can tell, from what I heard in Munich, uh, don't, I mean, you can't quote me because of what I heard, but is anything between 1500 and 2000 pounds. Now, you're gonna have to save quite a lot of energy value to get that payback to work. So, how this all shakes down over time, I'm not sure. But I kind of think the octopus and BYD model looks most interesting because they're subsidizing the cost of the car by capturing the value, potential value of the energy transit, of the energy management, arbitrage, and, and so therefore, octopus win, BYD win, and the customer wins. That, that, that's a, that's a, that's a good, good setup. Um, and so, And we think about it again, without going too much on it all, Nick, but these are two industries that haven't changed for well over 100 years. The energy industry, the mobility industry. For 100 years, they've kind of been the same. So the reason why they're changing now is because there is a different value proposition to be had. There is a different, um, yeah, business model, a different cake, and people want a slice of that cake. So, I would even be as bold as to say, this isn't about climate change anymore, just, this isn't about air quality, just. This is now about a new cake and people wanting a slice of it. Because it's a new business model, and it could be, and I think will be very lucrative. Well, to that, let's cut into the cake a little bit. My next question, I'm kind of curious about what's happening in the world of battery chemistries. What's changing to kind of be able to um harness these things we're talking about, whether it's grid storage or mobility. Um, do you want me to answer Pene, or do you want to go ahead, go ahead, Roger. OK, um, as I think I've mentioned, it may be in the notes, etc. probably clear to people already to be, to be honest, uh, Nick. I'm not an engineer, I'm not a chemist, I'm not a specialist, I am a collector of people, storyteller, etc. etc. Um, there are two words I learned at Ricardo, where I worked for a number of years amongst brilliant engineers. Um, and those two words are the answer to the question, what works best? So when it comes to what battery chemistry, what, you know, what's Cell format, whatever, life cycle, so on and so forth. Um, the two word answer is always, it depends. So it depends on the application, it depends on the environment, it depends on the cost, it depends on what you need it to do, excuse me, it depends on the business model, in other words. So when people talk about, you know, a bit like people used to talk with, Alternatives to Tesla, oh this is the killer Tesla model. I mean, it's rubbish, because it, it just, it depends. Um, for, I think a lot of vehicles now around the world, increasingly so in Europe, interestingly, wasn't the case for a while, LFP is the battery of choice. Why? Because it delivers a good enough energy density, it didn't in the past, a good enough energy density now, because we've got better charging proposition. You know, the beginning of the electric revolution was biggest battery possible, longest range possible, because charging isn't very good. I'm nervous, I get range anxiety. But, but there is a, a, a, a migration, a maturity of, of, um, the, the charging infrastructure getting better, and that being able to benefit batteries to be less energy dense and smaller. But the other benefit, of course, of LFP in particular, is there's no nickel and there's no cobalt. And both of those have challenges, not insurmountable, but they do have challenges, particularly in the popular storytelling of all of this, particularly cobalt, that um has put people off and has worried people and concerned people. So when you see the rise of LFP as a particular chemistry, LIFEPO4, when you see that, this is a positive story for everybody, you know, consumer. Uh, manufacturer, and, and everybody, quite honestly. So, that would be my initial comment on, on chemistry. Now, Pune, you know more because I've heard you talk about it more. And by the way, when I saw Pune on stage amongst many really, really good presenters with lots of knowledge and information, what I liked about Puneet was his ability to come to the point. And he was, yeah, wonderfully succinct, and I've never met him in my life, but You know, and I don't want to be disrespectful to other speakers, but Pune definitely stood out for me, um, because it's hard to explain complex things without just talking like a boffin. Um, so, yeah, that being said, Pune, you know a lot about battery chemistry. Thanks for your kind words, Roger. Say it. Uh, let me start with telling a story. So, you know, whenever I hear the conversation or think about the conversation about materials and chemistries for battery, automatically my mind goes back to 2009 time frame. That was the time I was working for GM in General Motors R&D and on a daily basis, um, R&D at GM and R&D team, we were thinking about, you know, this 300 mile vehicle, right? What, how is it going to be possible, right? Um, because that time, batteries roughly cost around $1000 per kilowatt hour. And to make it 3, you know, 300 mile EVs, we always, uh, scratch our heads. How's that ever going to happen? Because the battery itself is going to cost more than the car was costing that time. And that, that's, that's where we started, right? I mean, I, I don't want, uh, people to, to forget that, that in those 15 years, the battery energy density, that means how much charge you get per kilo per kg of battery has gone up by 3 times, and the cost has come down by 90%. I mean, things that we could not imagine, even in our wildest dream back in 2008, 2009 is happening today. You know, and people are not even breaking the sweat for that. So this is all happening for many, many reasons, but one of the reasons is all the work that electrochemists and all kinds of R&D folks, and engineering folks and manufacturing folks across all the companies have done to mature the technology, to mature the chemistries and everything. Um, so again, uh, so the fact that they have done it, I have no doubt that that, that, that, that track will continue. But if, if you look back at why, why we are looking for new chemistries, at the end of the day, you know, if in the context of an electric vehicle, if you're looking to give, you know, take away range anxiety, there are 3 things that are needed. You need a battery that has a lot of energy, um, You, you, you want that battery to be charged fast. So, and then, and then you want those charges to be available. Easily. So if you have those three things, then the over the whole conversation about, hey, how will I charge? We can, if you can be my first car or second car, that conversation goes away if those three things are, are, are addressed, right? Uh, I'm gonna leave the, uh, frequency of chargers available aside because that is a critical part of it, right? You, you can have best battery chemistry that, that can be charged very fast, but if you don't have chargers, you still have the same problem. So that, that is something that that's, again, that's where the energy companies come into play. That's where a lot of, a lot of companies who are following Tesla model by putting their own superchargers and, and increasing those availability of chargers is an important part. But now if you come back to the two things, which is, hey, can I pack in more energy in, in the same volume of battery? And can I do that in a way that not only I pack a lot of energy, I, I, I can charge it fast as well. And those are the two key areas. In addition to the life and safety of the battery, those are the three dimensions upon which all the new chemistries need to be evaluated and, and the, the, the need for them coming. So, as Roger said, right now, LFP chemistry is, is most used chemistry in terms of vehicles because a lot of that data is coming from China. China is predominantly based on LFP, uh, or China EVs are based a lot more on the LFP chemistry because LFP chemistry is much cheaper, uh, per kilo because of the materials are a lot more cheaper that that goes in there, iron, um, and it, it can be charged fast. And, and it has a reasonable amount of energy density. It's not the most energy dense chemistry, but reasonable enough that that it can work in a practical, uh, scenario. But if you look, um, the, the new need of chemistry, those are the dimension every company is working on. Can you pack more energy while making sure this is safe, right? If you look at the solid-state chemistry, what quantum scape is working, many other companies are working on, they are looking to change those chemistries so that you can put more energy density. And charge fast without putting, jeopardizing the safety or the life of battery. If you look at the other dimension is sodium-ion battery, which, which is, again, instead of using lithium, they want to use sodium. …

Full transcript (WebVTT)