Episode 52: Cross Company’s Blueprint for Successful Tech Integration
Show notes
Welcome to another exciting episode of Digitalization Tech Talks! Join your hosts, Jonas Norinder and Don Mack, as they dive into the latest trends and innovations in digital technology within the process industries. In our 52nd episode, we're thrilled to welcome Robbie Peoples, the Director of Engineering at Cross Company, to discuss a topic we've yet to explore: mitigating risks in large integration projects.
As the process industries strive to stay competitive, integrating cutting-edge technologies into existing systems is more crucial than ever. But with innovation comes challenges and risks. This episode will uncover strategies for implementing new technologies and navigating the complexities involved. Robbie will share insights on developing robust quality assurance plans tailored to various industries and highlight the importance of testing and simulation for seamless integration.
Don't miss out – hit play and join us for an enlightening conversation on Digitalization Tech Talks!
Show Notes:
Website (Cross): Legacy process control system migration (https://bit.ly/3XNmNCW)
Podcast: Process control system migration with Cross (https://bit.ly/4i6Bg4m)
Website (Cross): Design specification details (https://bit.ly/3G1eZaH)
Case study (Cross): Kemira converts reactors to new product line (https://bit.ly/4jrIhxC)
Website (Siemens): Accelerate Digital Transformation (https://bit.ly/4cmvYQV)
Event Link:
Shaping Tomorrow’s Semiconductor Plant – a Visionary Leadership Event (bit.ly/424kEnx)
Contact us:
Robbie Peoples (robbie.peoples@crossco.com)
Don Mack (mack.donald@siemens.com)
Jonas Norinder (jonas.norinder@siemens.com)
Transcript
Welcome to Digitalization TikToks, the podcast where we explore the latest trends and innovations in the world of digital technology as it relates to the process industries. Hi, Jonas Narinder, and my co-host, Don Mack. Welcome you to the fifty-second episode. And today, we will be discussing how to mitigate or minimize risk in large integration projects so that you can take full advantage of innovative digital technologies, a topic that we actually haven't covered yet in this podcast, which is pretty exciting. As chemical, pharmaceutical, hydrogen, and other process industries strive to stay competitive, integrating new and innovative technologies into existing systems become increasingly essential. This process, however, comes with its own set of challenges and also risks. So in this episode we'll Uncover strategies for new technology implementations and how to effectively navigate related complexities. We'll also discuss how to develop robust quality assurance plans tailored to different industries and the importance of testing and simulation to ensure seamless integration. That was a lot of stuff. Quite a mouthful, but we have a great episode lined up for you today. Really, whether you're an engineer, if you're a project manager or just a technology enthusiast, I think this episode is gonna have some valuable insights to help you stay ahead in the ever evolving landscape of digital technology which we are kinda trying to manage in this podcast. So now, let me ask you a question, Don. What are you looking forward to in today's episode? Hey, Ennis, uh, looking forward to another great episode. In those categories that you mentioned, I'm an engineer. I also consider myself to be a tech enthusiast. So it seems like I'm in the right space today to gain some valuable insights. Uh, it so happens that I've known our guest for a number of years and can attest to the wealth of experience he has working in the field process automation. I'm really looking forward to him sharing some of his expertise with the two of us as well as our audience, especially as it applies to best practices around new technology implementation. Awesome. I second that, Don. So let's get to the introduction of today's guest. Robbie Peeples is director of Engineering at Cross Company, Process Solutions Group. And in this role, Robbie is responsible for large project execution of both software and hardware development. It's a pleasure to have you on the show, Robbie. Welcome. Thank you. It's always a pleasure to discuss integration of process control projects. It's uh not only my job but it's a passion as well. That's awesome. So, Robbie, before we get into the topics of how to manage technology projects, how to add integration value, and how to mitigate the associated risk, I'd like to get your general thoughts on the use of new technologies and also any unique methods of developing projects because I'm assuming as someone who executes large projects for a living, I'm sure you are frequently involved in discussions like that. Yes, new technology is always prevalent in the discussions when you're migrating a larger process control system. You know, end users, they're not really just looking to replace the obsolete system, you know, they want to be able to execute the project efficiently. Um, in some cases they want to optimize their processes. Everybody wants an enhanced graphical view, and, you know, of course these days everybody wants to port data up to the management layer to be able to spread the amount of information on what's going on in production. But you also want to maintain cyber secure practices while doing that. And then also, you know, have the tools to really maintain the system well moving forward. It's really the main concept behind it. Robbie, I'm guessing that along the way, there are probably some challenges that are encountered when you're trying to achieve those objectives. In, in your experiences, what are some common challenges or pitfalls companies face when they're integrating new technologies, and how can they be avoided? That's a great question. You know, I've, I've spent my entire career in the industrial process control area, um, first as an instrumentation tech for 6 years at a large chemical facility. That was prior to completing my education. And then I went back and, and completed my studies. And since then, you know, I've been migrating, developing, and upgrading industrial process control systems across many different verticals for the last 24+ years. And during this time, you can, you you end up witnessing a good bit of pitfalls, obstacles, challenging projects, and you're, you're always on the continual improvement plan, trying to improve how we operate, how we execute, and make it better for the end user. And you can take all of those, those pitfalls, if you will, and kind of put them into kind of four different categories. The first one really is the, the lack of, of really thoroughly planning a project. And that, that really means that, you know, upfront, you really didn't do a good job or even execute a functional design specification, um, and define all the end user requirements, meaning halfway through somebody adds an additional requirement and oh, I didn't know that was a requirement. And a lot of times they'll oversimplify things and that's why they, we won't go through the thorough planning process. And then users having a lack of, of training on to be able to operate that system and setting them up for success. The, the, the second part of that, um, silo really is not having a cross-functional, and no pun intended there, accountable team, meaning you need somebody from production to be able to support the project. From maintenance, site engineering, maybe there's an engineering firm involved, systems integrator, there's gonna be OEM packages involved, and you also want that upper-level management commitment to the project upfront. It skipping steps is another silo that you could, you could look through and, you know, that could be not following a really, a, a, a tried and true, and proven process to execute or having possibly unrealistic timelines, um, or making hasty decisions at increased risk. And, you know, taking shortcuts is never a good thing when there's a lot of, a lot of things at risk during a, during a process control upgrade. And then the last silo, if you will, is not having a robust test plan. And that really means fully staging the entire system off-site to identify any issues and, and really running through that simulation. Wow, that, that's really where a seasoned production leader is worth their weight in gold. And I'll, I'll speak more about that as we go through this as well. But you want to take advantage of, of simulation. And and to remove as much risk as possible, and there's different levels of that, of course, that we can talk through. Digital twin is, is, is a buzzword that we've been using here for a while. We've been doing simulation for a long time, but the digital twin is, is a great concept, but it's not always cost effective for every end user. And so with that being said, we kind of offer three different levels of simulation to make sure that we can reduce the amount of risk that's needed for the project. One level, a simple level of that is called Simplex. It's just mimics equipment functions, but it allows you to rapidly do a cost-effective testing method to ensure your software functions do exactly what the spec says they're supposed to do. The medium fidelity section is the next level, and that incorporates, you know, a number of dynamic interactions. But it's not a real world mass balance, if you will, of your process, but it does give you a feel from an operation standpoint to make sure some automation functions are actually working properly. And then there's the last one I call the high fidelity, which really truly is the, the digital twin that integrates the real world process interactions. And this level, it's not really used just for software testing, but to really capitalize or have a good return on investment. The end user. can take that digital twin and use that from a training program to train operators, uh, moving forward, and that's really a, a very beneficial tool for them moving forward. We're taking a very short break here to promote an event that's coming up on May 7th in San Jose, California. So if you reside within that area, please listen closely. We have a thought leadership event coming up called Shaping Tomorrow's Semiconductor Plan, a visionary leadership event. We will have a keynote presentation by Intel followed by a panel discussion. Additional experts from Excite, EW Design Group, Eccentec, and Collabrach. So if you're interested in hearing about the future of semiconductor manufacturing and you reside in the San Jose, California area, please look at the registration link in the show notes. In relation to the, the training the operator, we've had an episode on that specific topic and that always seems to have a great value for, for companies in training their operators more efficiently and making them better equipped to start using the equipment a lot faster than they could ordinelly. And I really like the way you also break in. Assimilation into these three distinct offerings that offer the various benefits in terms of speed to market and size of the investment for sure. So, so that was a really good overview. Thank you for that, Robby. It also sounds like simulation is a very important aspect to minimizing risk, at least it can be, and ensuring a successful project integration. Are there any other best practices that you can share in that regard? Absolutely There are multiple tools and practices over the years that we've developed to help reduce risk. The key for the end user is really to identify an acceptable level of risk, and you can evaluate that based on production downtime and the potential loss of revenue. So that means that the overall project cost must be balanced, right, with the extensive risk reduction practices such as the level of simulation like we just talked about. One of our tools that we found very beneficial and a lot of our customers have really taken to it is, is the method of developing the detailed design specification. Where it's written in layman's terms. So a DDS document defines exactly how a control system is going to behave, and it details all of the automation functions. This document is reviewed and approved by all parties, but more importantly, you have that, that person in production that fully comprehends that specific process operation. And in most cases, you know, that seasoned operations specialist is not really a programmer. They don't know how to, how to do any coding, more than likely, and they probably don't know any of the five IEC supported languages such as, you know, ladder diagrams, functional function blocks, sequential function charts, uh, structured text, instruction lists. Therefore, this document really outlines exactly how the functions are going to work. And that that operation specialist can fully comprehend every function without knowing how to code. And several customers have even taken that tool and have adopted it as their own practice. And there's been a few cases where customers write that document for us and give it to us, which gives us a, an easy target for success when they know exactly what they want. Yeah, Robbie, that seems to make a lot of sense, uh, gained from a lot of experience, I'm sure over the years. And I guess going along with that experience, I'd like to talk a little bit about the testing that goes along with deployment of a new system or a system upgrade. How important is testing and simulation in the integration process of new technologies? Is there an element of risk mitigation associated with it? Yes, there is. You know, system testing is really not an option. It's a requirement. However, the level of testing that's performed, you know, kind of like we discussed earlier, the different levels of simplex, medium fidelity, high fidelity, or digital twinning has to be balanced with the reduction of risk for the particular site. And let me explain a little bit. Our quality assurance program. Governs the methods of how we execute a project and all of the testing that's performed around it. So an internal acceptance test is something that we perform prior to a factory acceptance test, which is the end user, um, executing. This allows us to consistently provide quality solutions to our customers, and the minimal level of testing that we perform on that for the IAT, FAT, and SAT is the minimal requirements. Now there are, there are additional testing and functions that, that you have to do outside of that as well, but we've witnessed multiple advantages to really implementing stimulation, um, such as it, you know, reduces the human error. Yeah, we've seen multiple cases where it improves operations. Because we're able to identify advanced control functions. Um, and there's been cases where we've witnessed that seasoned operator going through that digital twin, and we noticed the standard operating procedures he was doing and we asked additional questions and we identified additional efficiencies to, to augment that SOP. So there, there's, there's lots of benefits around it, and the obvious improvement is, is the reduction of on-site time, right? We're going to execute all of this testing functions off-site with seasoned operation professionals, and it really produces that, it reduces that on-site time significantly. It's good to hear that there are some, some tangible benefits to, to digital twins. I think a lot of people see it, as you mentioned earlier too, as kind of a, kind of a big all-encompassing thing that requires a big investment and, and while it does to some extent, it needs to have some tangible benefits to justify the investment, of course. So it's good to hear that you're also seeing that with your customers. So I just want to stay with the testing and simulation topic for a bit, but I want to focus more on the control system side of things. In your experience, what are the most efficient methods for testing and stimulating the control system, would you say? For a new control system, um, in a greenfield process, meaning like new construction, whether it's stick build or whether it's, you know, putting together OEM packages together. The obvious choice is to reduce as much risk as possible by building a digital twin without a doubt. However, there are existing processes that run efficiently and have been running for years, and the end user fully understands how that process functions. So digital twinning may not have as much as an impact from an ROI standpoint. Using simplex methods, which is the minimal amount of simulation, that that can reduce the amount of risk to fully test all the software functions, and the site already has successful methods of training an operator. So then the cost may not be adequately balanced with the reduction of risk in those cases. Hey, Robbie, that makes a lot of sense. Um, I guess to some extent you have to kind of look at each case individually and see where they've, they've come from, particularly for upgrades. Um, I guess related to this topic, what, what advice would you give to companies that are looking to leverage new technologies while at the same time minimizing risks? Mhm. Yeah, great question. You know, everybody wants to be on the cutting edge of technology, right? And have the latest and greatest, but no one wants to be on the bleeding edge. And let me provide some, some additional color to that phrase. I'm not a fan of being serial number one, right, for new products. Being the first means that you're going to be beta testing, you know, for the manufacturer in certain cases, and it will absolutely require a full test method to ensure that you remove as much risk as possible. This means that you need a direct hotline to the manufacturer, um, as well as a flexible schedule when, when you're on the, on the, on the bleeding edge. Alternatively, let's assume that a product is solid and it's a new technology for the facility to deploy. In that particular case, you just need to consider partnering with an integrator that can develop standards, allowing for the site team to work alongside during the development of those stages to allow them to fully learn the system and be able to maintain that system long term. In addition to engineering training, production training will be needed as well. And we have witnessed a lot of success by encouraging the site to include a production champion as a part of the site project team. This person should have a seasoned experience to operate that facility, and they will serve as the production lead to help train the new operators. Essentially train the trainer, if you will. Yeah, it definitely does, Robbie, and that's some sound advice for sure. So we've covered a lot of different ideas and thoughts today. What we usually like to do is try, try to pick out some key points and some key takeaways. Could you summarize a few key takeaways that you can leave with the audience? My recommendation for listeners, um, that are planning to upgrade or develop an industrial control system, I recommend the following. Do not look for a systems integrator to execute a project. Alternatively, Look for a systems integrator to partner with, to share common values and encompass the following. Have a well-defined process and a proven success model. Have references of partners that have been doing business with for years. Committed to being part of a solution and not too rigid to be flexible on the delivery. And has a high ethical standard and committed to making you successful. That was some great advice, Robbie. Thank you very much and I'm sure that our listeners will find it useful if they're involved in any project execution, whether that's large or small. And with that, I really wanna thank you for being on the podcast. Uh, there was a lot of great information relative to project execution, implementation of digital technologies, how to minimize risk. It's been a pleasure to hear you share your thoughts and your experience with all those topics. So I really appreciate you taking the time to be on the podcast here today. Well, thank you. It's always a pleasure to discuss topics that I'm passionate about. I appreciate the opportunity. If any listeners have any questions or comments, please do not hesitate to contact me. And that's a good point, Robbie. We will definitely include your email address in the show notes so you can go look at that and to send an email to Robbie if you have any questions. And with that, we are at the end of the episode. If you have any general questions to the episode, to Dawn or myself, or perhaps have any good ideas for any future episodes, you can of course also reach out to the two of us. Our email addresses are also included in the show notes, and we would really love to hear from you. If you liked what you heard today, please help spread the words by rating the show, and if you're not already a subscriber and would like to be notified when new episodes are released, which happens last Thursday of the month, please subscribe to the series. Thank you for listening to this episode of Digitalization TED Talks.