#105 UL and NFPA Standards in Fire Detection
Show notes
In today's episode we are talking about fire detection. Our expert Dan Finnegan, Industry Affairs Head at Siemens Smart Infrastructures, tells everything about these standards that are the foundations for the safety of the buildings of today and tomorrow.
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name is John Lester and in today's episode we are talking about UL and NFPAE standards in fire detection. Uh, I'm joined today by Dan Finnegan. He is the industry affairs head for Siemens Smart-Infrastructure. Dan, thank you so much for joining us today. John, it really is my pleasure to be here to talk about a topic that is important to all of us. Uh, there, there's nothing more important than safety, and there aren't many, uh, topics within safety that are more important than fire and smoke detection, so I'm excited to have you here. Uh, first question, industry affairs sounds fun, sounds exciting. Could you give me a bit of an insight in what you do? Thanks, John. I love talking about what I do because yes, it is fun and exciting. But you know, the fact of the matter is, John, that the fire safety industry, the fire safety business is driven by codes and standards. So there's a couple of important points here. You know, Siemens invests people to make sure that we're involved in the UL standards, the NFPA standards, the building and the fire codes, primarily in North. America and those UL and NFPA standards do cross across the globe in many areas, but we're involved to make sure that things are going in a positive and correct direction. You know, Siemens has a very rich history of being an innovator in early warning detection and moving forward with technology. All of this is a perfect match, so we sit and we help guide the direction of where. The standards are going because they are the foundation for safety in not only our homes that we sleep and live in, but the new buildings that are going up around us. All right, beautiful. It couldn't be more important, which I like to hear. And maybe a very quick disclaimer, as you mentioned, we're talking about UL and NFPA standards. There are different standards across the globe depending on which country or which region you're in. Obviously the conversation we have today is really specific to those those areas or those countries where the UL and the NFPA standards apply. Uh, Amazing. You mentioned their history, and I'd like to touch on that first because obviously we have standards today. We have a current, you know, we have a current expectation from an industry perspective. How do we get to where we are today? What's the history look like for these, for these codes and standards? You know, I'll start out, John, with the focus on smoke detection, and that is the fact that smoke detection has been saving lives now since about the 19. 60s and it's become a requirement in codes in all areas that we sleep. That's a simple way of putting it. They're required in every bedroom in our homes. They're required in commercial buildings in areas that we sleep, dormitories, hotels, and the like. And so there, that is the foundation of early warning so that we can get awoken, so we can get out before the fire becomes too great to prevent us from escaping. And it also smoke detection plays a very important role in valuable properties where that extra notification is important, such as in data centers, which are a growing market today with, you know, we say the cloud, but we really know the cloud is a 2 million square foot underground data center that no one knows where it's at, but that's a very valuable property, and those are heavily protected by early warning. Uh, smoke detection so that fire is detected in the very, very early stages. And uh, and yes, and today we can chat about the, the UL standards and how NFPA interacts with that. And, uh, you know, as we bring those things forward because back in 1960 or even going back into the 1950s, you know, in the United States, I can quote, you know, there was close to over 15,000 people a year dying in Fires and through the advancement of smoke detection in our codes, you know, in other aspects, we've reduced that number now to about 3000 people a year. But in that, the majority of that 3000 are still dying in our single family homes, which is where we sleep, and that really, uh, you know, really kind of, uh, you know, highlights that whole aspect of things. So, you know, that's kind of where we're at at this point in time. Yeah, beautiful, thank you, because that's a really important thing. Firstly, to recognize it is such a recent thing, you know, OK, the 1960s might feel a long time ago when we talk about music and fashion, but it's not really that long when we start talking about buildings and, you know, the, the, the infrastructure around us. So that, that's, it's a good thing for us to remember. We talk about fashion or I talked about fashion, I talked about music. I can imagine our buildings have changed a lot as well in that time. Well, we've had a huge impact. We've gone from 15,000 in the US down to about 3000. Still a lot of people, but a huge improvement. I can imagine there's challenges that make that more difficult and that have driven some of the changes also within that smoke detection industry, right? Yes, there is, John, and you know, I'll take that step back and talk about that death rate of around 3000, 2800 in our homes. That's been flat for the last five years now. So we have been making improvements. So, about eight years ago now, research was started by the uh the nation. Leaders in fire safety research in both the United States and in Canada, and they were studying this whole situation of, you know, what's changed? Why are we not continuing to save lives? And you know, the biggest piece that research, actual fire testing has shown is the fact that the available safe escape time, it's sometimes known as ASSET, in our homes has been reduced. It used to be. 15 to 18 minutes we had when that first detector went off, you had about 15 minutes to get out of your home while the space was still what they considered to be tenable. You can get out on your own without being overcome by smoke, heat, and poisonous gasses. Today, research today. you're showing that that escape time is down to 3 to 5 minutes. Wow, big difference, and that's why we're still losing people's lives in homes sometimes even when they have a smoke detector because things have changed and we go, well, what exactly has changed? And here's the real interesting fact that once again solid research has shown, and that is it's the furnishings in our homes. Now I'm a mature individual. When I visited my grandmother, her furniture was made out of oak wood. It was cotton fibers. It was all real stuff. And when that stuff burns, it burns more slowly. When I go into my nephew's home today, who's a firefighter in his own right. Everything is polyester. It's all synthetics. It's plastics. And what is the basic chemical foundation of everything I just mentioned? That's all petroleum-based materials. Yes, you're sitting on a chair made of solidified gasoline, so that when a fire does occur in the new home today, which by the way, it is the majority of our homes, the fire ignition happens much quicker and the fire. Fred is just significant and the amount of toxic black smoke that comes out of this petroleum-based materials is just overcoming. Therefore, that is why we're down to just the 3 to 5 minute escape time as compared to Grandma's house with wood and natural fibers. That is a huge change, as you said, from 15 minutes, which when you compare 15 minutes to 3 minutes, there's time to pack a bag almost when you when you look at that difference. And I guess that explains, as you described, where we were making such great improvements as innovation and technology improved. Everything was coming down in these last years as we've kind of hit the, you know, maybe it's unfair, but the flat pack generation where nothing is made of oak wood anymore, our homes are full of stuff that makes it more dangerous for us in the event of a fire. Uh, for me that's a really interesting one because it's, it's hard to get to that point. Considering those changes, there must be, or has there been a shift also from a code and standards perspective to start to absorb this new, this new effect, this new consideration. Yes, thanks, John. There absolutely has been, and as I referenced that research that started 8 years ago by the nation and global leading fire researchers, um, what they Started to focus on was two key areas that we felt they felt that early warning detection needed to address. First was we needed to respond faster to the polyurethane fire. It burns differently than wood and cotton, so there's a need to increase the sensitivity or have that detector respond faster when a polyurethane fire starts up. At the same time. Facts and research has been showing that yes, sometimes when we cook in our kitchens and we broil a steak or I know John, you certainly never would burn a hamburger, but sometimes if we burn a hamburger or overcook something, the smoke alarms in our homes have been going off and there's a percentage of deaths that are attributed to the smoke alarm we shut off or somebody pulled out the battery. So we also knew that cooking hazards have been a challenge to the. Operation of smoke alarms. So the industry is taking two giant steps forward. They're doing 2 new tests within the certification process of of smoke detection in general. First is it has to respond within a predetermined measure for polyurethane fires. And the second is it has to be able to survive what they're actually calling the frozen hamburger test. They actually have a room and they cook and they fry a frozen hamburger. Why is it a frozen hamburger? Because the frozen meat has actually been shown to produce the most products of combustion and materials that we're simulating and most of the fires that we're studied. So there is a frozen hamburger test and a polyurethane foam test that all new detectors are going to need to pass here in the very near future. OK, so those tests make sure, as you described, they react faster. When there is a real fire, when there's polyurethane involved, you have to be faster. You have to be very reactive from a technology point of view. You have to have a real level of of of accuracy with that. But then at the same time be able to recognize when someone's trying to get a bit of char on a burger and, and driving for a bit of caramelization to not go off every day because as you say, human, human nature is that if every time I try and cook a burger, my alarm goes off, I'll just pull it off the wall and leave myself in a situation. Yeah. But those two tests, like there's got to be a lot of challenge from a technical perspective to be able to achieve success in those two tests. Is that reasonable to assume? Yeah, there, there clearly is. And first I'm going to do for the benefit of our audience, I want to share with them the exact UL standard numbers so that they can possibly look this up themselves. In UL 268, the 8th edition is the standard for smoke detection. That's your system connected using commercial buildings. UL 217, the 7th edition, is the new standard for the smoke alarms that are going to comply with the 2. We just talked about and the smoke alarm, of course, is what we generally find in our homes and where we sleep. That's the self-contained unit. It goes off, it beeps, it makes noise. So, so that's the, that's just the technical reference points for our audience. But you're absolutely right, you know, the manufacturers were challenged. This has been a paradigm shift in the manufacturer design and the application of smoke detection. That we haven't seen in over 40 years. Maybe it's sad that we haven't changed detection technology in 40 years. I'm speaking in very broad terms, not from Siemen's perspective, but in broad terms. But this has brought about that paradigm shift that's saying, you know what, to save lives, we have to do A, B, and C, and that's what going forward on. And you touched on it, you know, here we have to now take a sensor or sensors and increase sensitivity on one. which sometimes could cause an unwanted alarm if you're not careful. And at the same time, we have to slow it down from other types of fire. So it's back to this looking at the signature or some people call the fire print of a fire. And I only say that because actually Siemens sash are Cerberus days, we actually came out with the first multi-criteria smoke detector back in the late 90s that actually does already. You have a detector that actually has a couple of different sensors in there, so you're monitoring and looking at obscuration and temperature, and you're looking at different things in order to form algorithms that will help you determine is that a piece of hamburger burning or is it A drape in the kitchen that's burning, you know, you get those differentiations out so that these detectors can work faster. And that's really what the entire manufacturing world, say maybe one manufacturer, everyone is going to a multi-criteria or multi-sensor type of an approach. So these detectors are going to have a couple of different 3, sometimes 2 or 3 sensors in there. There's going to be an onboard computer sitting in that device. That's going to be checking algorithms and making all this high tech analysis and then sending out the alarm at the right time. And what underwriters Laboratories, a nationally recognized testing laboratory, does is as a manufacturer, we create this design. We send them off to them. They conduct these tests that we just talked about in addition to all the tests from the past, and we have to pass them, and it has to work and meet these criteria that's been set forth and The good news is we sit here today, the, um, the original date for this, as I mentioned, this has been going on for 7 or 8 years. The original due date for a manufacturer to be able to make product um was May of 2020. By May of 2020, which is now in the past, we had all manufacturers complying with these standards. Um. That did get extended, I think out of respect to COVID and just the nature that this was such a big change. That has now been extended to June of 2021. And now, let me try to explain that just a little bit, um, because It does not affect all of those smoke detectors, smoke alarms that are already installed in our homes, our businesses, and places we sleep. Those are still perfectly good to use. They're perfectly fine. It's just that as a manufacturer, we cannot make anything after, in this case, June of 2021 unless it complies with these standards, you know, somebody can still install some of the older ones, you know, a couple of months later, as long as they were made before June of 2020. So we're working with the fire code officials, the consulting engineers, and explaining once again this is a change that hasn't taken place in 40 years. It's a new educational process, but underwriters Laboratories, NFPA, and many others are on a major education campaign to help this whole formula for this new concept forward. Now, from a seamless's perspective, we have got our products are all ready to go. We have, uh, you know, we've met the date of Of May of 2020. And there are a number of other manufacturers, both system and smoke alarms for your homes that are out there. That's why I gave you those numbers before, you know, if you're gonna go to, you know, the, the big box store or the Home Depot, and you want to get the new device for your home, look for UL 217, 7th edition on the thing. And believe me, they're gonna be advertising this, you know, feature now that they have, but, you know, that's just for our own knowledge and regards. But that, that's a good point because as you say, you know, obviously every manufacturer up until that day will have to go through the process, get certified, get listed, and, and right now today when you do have the choice, if you are making the decision for your, for your family home, you know, make, make the right one, make the one that that is highlighting and leveraging and reaching the highest expectations that will be those expectations moving forward. So I think that's good. And it's also a really good point from what you mentioned that. You don't have to go and rip everything out that's that's in your building today, but with fire safety being an industry where we do have, you know, really stringent maintenance standards and testing standards, this will over the process of the coming years become something that we'll see in every building in the medium term. Sure, John, I'd like to bring up one other point of good clarification, and it's a good fire life safety message because we're talking about don't worry about what's existing, keep it going. But there is a code requirement through NFPA that says the smoke alarm, those are the units in our homes once again, need to be replaced every 10 years. So, you know, there's studies were made that these things start to wear out. Got to remember that thing is on working 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. So it's electronic. They're figuring in 10 years, you need to replace it. So, you know, in my home, I replaced all mine 3 years ago because my house is now 13 years old. So I'm. Compliance, but, you know, and soon I'll have to replace them all again to put in the new edition, you know, a device, but that's just me. But you know, everyone's home to protect your home, to make sure things are going well, you need to replace your smoke alarms in your homes every 10 years. Those who live in a commercial building, see, that's a little different. Those smoke detectors don't have an end of life. Why? Because the code requires that we test them every year. Those devices in a commercial building are tested. Sensitivity check every single year and we replace the ones that are failing. We don't have a requirement to go to a person's home and do a formal sensitivity test. That is not part of our culture here in North America. So we just say every 10 years, take the right action and replace it. That's right, yep. No, but I like that because it's a good message. In the end, while, while here generally on this podcast, we're talking about our industry, we're talking about topics and themes that affect our industry. When we talk about fire safety, when we talk about fire and smoke detection, it's a huge part of our industry, but it's also a huge part of our daily lives. And when we're protecting our family and our friends, uh, you know, it's just as important, if not more important from a personal perspective. So I really like that highlight because, you know, in the end, safety has to touch every aspect of our lives. And if, if every 10 years we spend a few dollars and we make a change and that can save our lives, then, you know, this is, this is the easiest thing for us to do. Gotcha. Dan, thank you so much for joining us. It was an absolute pleasure. John, I'm always here to help in every way I can. I love uh this industry. I'm very passionate about helping to save lives and uh I appreciate you taking the time to be able to produce this, uh, excellent communication and, uh, hopefully it will save some more lives. Appreciate it. Bring it on, Dan. Thank you, and, and I get the feeling this is not the last time we're gonna have a chat. It was great fun. Uh, so I'm sure that in the near future, we'll have a couple more of these conversations and we'll get them out there for the people to listen to as well. Always here to help. Beautiful. So thank you very much to you, Dan, again, uh, but also thank you to everyone that's listening. Please feel free to share, like or comment on this episode, subscribe wherever you're listening or watching to us. Share it with your friends, share it with your colleagues, especially when we talk about a message like this, it, it can't be important or more important, it can't be important enough. So, get it out there, have fun and look out for new episodes coming soon, and we'll talk shortly. Thank you.