#147 The future of district heating
Show notes
This week, Buildings of Tomorrow has a special guest from Cetetherm. Join Roger Dahlstrand, Sales & Distribution Manager Nordic & Baltic, and Jon Lester on how digitalization is making district heating more sustainable. The Swedish company has developed a smart solution to save power costs for property owners and help heating suppliers optimize their networks. Tune in!
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name is John Lester, and in today's episode we are talking about the decarbonisation of district heating. I'm really happy and excited to be joined today by Roger Dahlstrand. He is the sales director at Ctatherm. Roger, thanks for joining us. Thank you. Uh, so, today we're talking about district heating and we're talking about decarbonizing district heating. Before we jump into the, the energy efficiency, the sustainability aspect, uh, could you give us a quick summary? What's district heating? What does it mean? What do we refer to when we talk about district heating? And why is it important for us? Where, where do we see it? Well, uh, district heating, um, I, I would say that is one of our, uh, most, uh, our biggest, most unknown, heating sources we have, uh, all, all over the world, mainly in Europe. Uh, it is a grid, uh, similarity to, to the electrical grid we have it, but, uh, it's uh pipes and, uh, some, somewhere in the cities we have a central heat source. Uh, could be, uh, everything from wood to, to, uh, waste garbage. We can use a lot of. Um, different terms of energy, um, so, so I always say that, um, people who don't know what kind of heating source they have, they usually have district heating. Uh, for me that is, uh, some, some of, uh, good recipe of this, yes. Understand. So, so we're talking here about cities, we're talking about urban areas, we're talking, uh, but is it always the cities, or is it sometimes in, in, in more communities, into, into smaller towns? How, how does that look from a, a scope perspective? Yeah, and it variates. Uh, I would say a normal, even a small town has some sort of district heating because, uh, it has been during, I would say the last, uh, 25 years, uh, a lot of political decisions taken, uh, in order to get district heating. So I would say that we have communities from 5000 people, uh, up to 5 million people are using district heating. It is quite politically driven. Uh, we see that now as well during the situation we have. It variates. The trend now is that also, um, even smaller areas are coming with very, very local, um, uh, district heating network in combinations than with other heat source, uh, than, than normal waste or burn facilities, uh, so, so. The development of of the district heating and and the direction it's taken, it's, it's really interesting because we are changing from one energy source to to a various number of energy sources. Understand. Hey, before we jump into those energy sources themselves, uh, maybe a quick question about why, why, why is there this political push, why is there this, this push towards district heating rather than more localized or more incremental, uh, heat creation? I think it is mainly a cost cost issue, I would say district heating, creating a new district heating network is extremely expensive. It takes a heavy investment. I mean, basically you start from scratch. You have to build the fuel center. You have to build the grid and also connecting all of these houses. Uh, and the matureness among the end customers also is important because, uh, normally I'm, I'm just looking at myself. I already have a heat pump in my house. Uh, why should I invest in a heat pump? Uh, so there are a number of small facts which is taken into consideration, which makes it fairly complicated, yeah. And, and once we have it, so, so as you mentioned before, it's one of the, the largest sources of heating that we have globally in many different centers, large cities down to smaller communities, and, and it's there driven, it's centralized, it's uh, there, there is a, there is, let's say a cost hurdle to get there, but once we have it, what are some of the benefits, once we have district heating installed, what are the core benefits of district heating itself and, and the technology as it stands today? I would say for those people who have uh district heating, as I said earlier in this session here, um, the, how to say the, the, the comfort is enormously high with district heating. You always have a safe supply of uh hot water, tap water, uh, heating is, um, yeah, I would, I would be, if you have a problem, uh, it's a major breakdown which is very rare. Uh, so, so. It's also very cost efficient for a facility owner, for example, compared to other heat sources. The maintenance cost on a on a substation locally in a in a building is, is extremely low compared to other different heat heat sources where you have much more expensive both parts and also maintenance costs. So yeah, so yeah. Understand. So, so we have a lot of these district heating plants, there's a, there's a huge amount of, of energy that's consumed, that's, that's also provided to, to, to different urban centers, to, to businesses, to residential homes via district heating. What, what's a little bit of a snapshotshot of where we are today? Um, if you were to, to summarize our, our current situation as a, as a district heating industry, how would you, how would you summarize that for us? It's a really good question, uh. I would say that uh I'm not basically from the district heating business. I joined, uh, 5-6 years ago into this as a sales director and I, from a sales perspective, I, I'm, I'm very surprised that we are not selling more district heating actually as an energy source because it is brilliant. Um, I'm not sure if it's due to political decisions or this, um, history we have with district heating, um. Uh, it's not to, to, to be too brave, but, but it's really conservative and it's, it's a little bit not market driven, uh, it's driven from the inside, uh, towards the outside, not from the outside towards the inside, which sales is normally all about, uh, I think that is our biggest challenge, uh, because. Customer, when you speak about district heating, it's very few people actually know what district heating is, and I'm quite sure if they knew what it was, they would really put a demand on it. So, so we are working, CTA, uh, as a company, really heavy to work so that we get this, uh, pull force from the outside and in. Um, please ask, ask your energy company, uh, could, could I have a district heating? I, I would like to connect. Uh, create the opportunity. Uh, so, so I think now with the, with the recent, I would say since, since, since start of this year, the discussion are changing, but you know I would say too slow phase. We have now in an energy situation which is, which is terrible. Um, we could offload, uh, some of the electrical issues, for example, just by putting on more power from, uh, towards the district heating and, and releasing the electrical grid. Uh, but then decisions is extremely important. Yeah, I understand, and, and you, you raised a really good point there, and that was one of my next questions. Uh, knowing where we stand today, knowing that not only do we have an energy challenge, let's call it, especially here in Europe as an example, but, but also looking at the, the, the big drivers behind our society at the moment around sustainability, around, around decarbonisation, and one of the topics that we highlighted at the start of this, uh, let's connect to that a little bit. How, how is district heating, um, placed within this conversation around energy efficiency and, and sustainability, and, and maybe after where it's placed, uh, where are still some areas that we need to work and where are some, some, some parts of the industry where there are still opportunities for us to improve? There is a huge part of of um possibilities in order to connect both facilities like houses and also industrial estate. Um, one of the big benefits we have in, in, uh, in this decarbonization is, is that we can quite easily control and access and I think developing the new trend now which we are talking a lot with, with Siemens about is this digitalization. Because it gives us not only just a substation, we are aiming to have a substation to be smart and intelligent and connectable. We are using artificial intelligence. We are using the latest control systems because it's all about the balance in the system. Uh, District heating is, is in order to have a low CO22 footprint, we need to have low return temperatures and CT as a company has, I would say that is our number one priority to perform. Um, this gives the, the energy companies a perfect possibility to, to, to be really, uh, CO2 neutral in the production. Um, unfortunately, um, I would say legislations and, and, um. In terms of or towards performance are a little bit also um how to say old. I'm a little bit honest now and and it's direct. You could be that uh because, because uh we see this combination, uh, I think also the, the, um. The ownership of the product, not, not only the, the this heating as a product, uh, has to move even forward. Maybe it should be so in the future that the energy companies, the producers owns also the substations locally in, in, in the houses so that they have a product which they are in total control over. They can do the load balancing, uh, uh, on their system in order to, yeah, achieve the lowest CO2 footprints, uh, all, all those features which we are aiming for. Use the optimal amount of fuels and so on and so on, so there are a lot of benefits. Understand I'm not sure if that was the answer to the question. It's, it's a, it's a tricky, it's a very long answer. It's a tough one, but, but let's dive in just to, to split it up a little bit because I think, I think, um, you know, for those out there listening as well, as you mentioned, not everyone understands district heating, and I think from your description already. Uh, you know, this is a central energy source that's then distributed, and this has a lot of benefits, uh, managing costs at the, at the consumer, let's call it, but also is, is quite an efficient technology, uh, because we have a, a lot less, uh, or we, we can have a lot less energy loss, etc. but you just, uh, mentioned there something which I think's important for us to touch on, um, when you mentioned to be the most efficient, to, to ensure that we're really, Delivering the right amount of energy and reducing or minimizing waste, it's that return temperature is a good indicator to, and, and maybe to, to summarize for me, that means that we're, If, if we have a low return temperature, this means that we're sending out the right amount of, of energy and we're not getting too much back, let's say, and, and losing a lot in the, in the call. So, so if I understand correctly, that, that's where I'd like to dive in a little bit because you mentioned digitalization, and you mentioned the, the energy providers and, and I think the electricity grid is a really good analogy. Because a district heating grid is, is like an electricity grid, uh, you, you, or at least traditional electricity grids where we, we generate energy centrally and then we distribute, uh, and the perfect situation is that we're generating and sending exactly the right amount of energy that the, the consumer needs at the other end. Uh, you mentioned digitalization, how does that help us? How can digitalization help us get the balance right, to not create too little energy, but also not create too much and send, send it away, uh, to be wasted and just sent back for loss. Uh, uh, it's, uh, digitalization is a, uh, excellent tool in many perspectives. I, I, I, um, to start with just easy features with digitalization, it's, it's when you go, for example, um, uh, overview and, and, uh, analysis and getting statistics and, and values, then we can use the, the, the digital digitalized, digitalized products, um, in many ways, and, and that is. Basic digitalization, it's been going on for 30, 40 years. Everyone, there is some sort of electronic components in more or less everything right now. But, but the thing now with, with the, the next level of digitalization is that we can also connect this artificial intelligence, for example, we can learn. From the data we previously have collected a lot of data and we have put them somewhere and maybe in some sort of Excel sheet or made some smaller analysis. Now with the new artificial tools which we are getting more and more into our products as well, we can. Optimize this data and, and we can see behaviors, uh, we can prevent behaviors and by doing that we we we can add so much more. We're talking about energy reductions, consumptions, maybe 10 to 20% if we use these tools in the correct way. So, so digitalization. With that tool created and now we can add the next level of tools, we, we can do enormously on, on, on the whole situation with the CO2 reduction. Like uh you just mentioned that that evolution and it's, and it's such a similar story that we see in, in other infrastructure, in other uh heating and cooling applications where, Transparency or, or understanding what's happening where is something that somehow we've done for some time. We've always, and, and, and also over the last years and sometimes decades, we've collected a lot of information, but really using that has been the challenge. um, so that's a great, uh, a great insight, let's call it into district heating, whereas, where this is maybe some, not so different from other parts of the industry, but at the same time, because you're talking really about a network, The impacts that you can, you can have by finding those savings and implementing these new tools can be so big. You mentioned their energy savings, 15 to 20%, that's a great one, maybe, have you got some other, uh, some other examples, some other benefits, uh, if we really do take this direction, if we start making, uh, district heating networks more digital, uh, more connected, uh, and more transparent, what are some of the other benefits that you see from your perspective and, and what are you already, uh, experiencing as Cedartherm out there in the market? I think um If you go back and, and when we use, if, if, when we, when we are using this artificial intelligence, one of the strongest tool is actually going back to the production. How much heat do we need to produce? Um, do we need to produce 10 megawatts or 100 megawatts, or can we actually live with half or 70, 80% by using these tools we can actually Schedule the behavior among the users and uh for example uh in the morning everyone wakes up more or less somewhere around 6 o'clock you have storage of already produced heat in your house let's say you have 22 degrees of course you want to maintain those 22 degrees, but. For, for the producers, this challenge in the morning is immense because you want to maintain those 22 degrees and in parallel, you want to create tap water for could be hundreds or thousands or so many people uh just by doing this load balancing between let's say 6 and 8 in the morning. Uh, you can maybe cut your production with, I don't know, 15, 20%. Uh, you will still have 22 degrees in your house, maybe 21.5 until 8 o'clock, but after 8 o'clock everything is back to normal. People have gone to work, they have taken their showers. Um, yeah, you have heating on. When you come back in the evening, uh, still 22 degrees. But just by doing this on every spot all over the globe, reducing, let's say if it's only 5 or 10%, every city which can reduce the production by let's say 5%, you can do the math. It's an enormous amount of energy which could actually, uh, yeah, we could stop the production. We, we don't, we don't use it. And that is just by utilizing these digital digital digital side. Digital tools, it's a tough word to say, digitalization. It's an impossible word to say, even for me, it is, but using that tool, uh, gives you an enormous power to actually make an impact in, in a positive way on the, on the environmental situation. And I think um I'm quite convinced that the new generations, I'm, I'm born late 60s. But when I talk to people who are born late 80s, early 90s, you see a change in their way of thinking, uh, and they really feel for these kind of arguments. Why, why should we do this? Uh, now, 2022, we are actually creating the tools, setting the platforms, and we as a company together with Siemens really struggling hard to sell them and, and make people understand that. This is just you, you buy this product, it's all integrated. It's just like buying a car. You, you, it's fully loaded, you have lights, you have a steering wheel, you have a gearbox. It's the same with the district heating now. We, we actually give our customer substations fully loaded, connectable with all these features as we are discussing, so yeah. I, like I, I love the example that you use because for me, um, this highlights a little bit the challenge you just, you just mentioned, it's, This is not a closed system. This is not a, a stand-alone system that you think just about, you know, I, I have a, I have a, an, a, a, a heat generation, and then I have a heat, heat consumption. I just need to know these two things. There are so many other functions that happen within a house, within a, a, a building, and then also the users themselves, these are us. We do things differently. Some people like an early shower, some people like a late shower, some people like a long. Uh, you know, that, that, that behavior plus all the other systems around, uh, that, that can leverage this heat or have an effect on the consumption of this heat, then create this system which is so complex and as you describe, uh, it, it can really only be tackled and we can only find these, these additional efficiencies leveraging this new technology. What I also liked you mentioned is that the generation now are, are really that generation that understands, uh, I think we're, and, and are also willing to make the, some of these small changes or some of these small sacrifices, half a degree, uh, for 2 hours in the morning, uh, for, for 10% saving, of course, is maybe something, uh, that, uh, 30 years ago would not be an OK thing, but today it, it's, it's the trade-off and, and the benefit is so strong. So we, you described a little bit some of the complexities. And you described here that you now have a solution, uh, you now have, have this fully loaded substation that, that has this transparency, that has this technology, the connectivity. What are some of the other challenges or what are some of the things that, that get in our way today? Uh, knowing that we, we know some things that we can do, we have the technology to do so. What are some of the hurdles that we need to overcome as an industry to really start to, to scale this and see it in every city and, and, and every community like you described? I would say that the biggest challenges we have right now is is behavior. We have a very old behavior since, since, um, yeah, 30, 40 years old behavior, which is um. I would say the biggest challenge when, when we start talking about this digital, digital, digital platforms uh with our customers, uh I would say that the people I mentioned earlier, the people late 80s, early 90s, they understand. Uh I'm, I'm not seeing myself as an old man, although I'm born in 1967. But, but I, I feel sometimes when I discuss with people in my age, um, a slightly resistant position. Because, uh, what's the, what's the, what's the problem with the things we already have? And I said there is no problem, but it's not good enough anymore. We need to upgrade and we need to do it fast. Uh, so, so, and then I think, uh, also district heating is, uh, extremely engineered. Um, I'm myself is a salesperson. I'm, I'm an engineer in, in, in the bottom, but, but still I'm, I'm really focused on safe. Um. The, the, the curiousness and, and the willingness to invent something new and, and I always say that the wheels is already invite uh created and we don't need to do that again, but we can use it as, as a maybe a different way. Uh, so, so there are some. …