#94 What does Commissioning mean to the industry?

Buildings of Tomorrow ·

Show notes

In this week’s episode we’re joined by James Dice, professional engineer, energy efficiency innovator and the brains behind "Nexus" (https://nexus.substack.com/). In today's episode James discusses what does Commissioning mean to the industry. Check it out!

Transcript

Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name is John Lester, and in today's episode, we're talking about commissioning. What does that word mean to us today and what does it differ, uh, today from what we understand of this process yesterday and into the past? I'm joined today by James Dice from Nexus. James, thank you very much for joining us. Thanks for having me again, John. Appreciate it. Absolute pleasure. Uh, let's jump quickly into Nexus. Please give us an idea of, uh, of who you are and what Nexus is. Yeah, Nexus is a media company, a consultancy, and now an online school. We just launched our first online course that launches this fall. The media portion is a newsletter. I send that out on Tuesdays. It's just my thoughts on the industry this week. And the podcast is every Thursday, so I interview thought leaders and CEOs about how the industry is changing and how I'm trying to understand it just like everyone else. Nice, perfect for those out there, if you're interested in this conversation or Even if you've heard some of the conversations that James and I have had in the past, please head to nexus.substack.com, check out the newsletter, check out the podcast like James just described. Find him on LinkedIn. It's really also a great place to get a little bit of a snapshot of some of the content that he's creating and, and helping us as an industry to understand some of these topics better. Um, so today we're talking about commissioning, and that could be commissioning for new builds or retrofits, but also retro commissioning, you know, looking at buildings that have already existed and bringing the way that they're administered, the way that they're controlled up to our modern standards. What, what has changed for us as an industry from the traditional view of what this word means, what commissioning is? What's changed from yesterday to today from your perspective? I think there's two big things that I would point out. One is the, you know, 800 pound gorilla, and that we're in a pandemic, and it's, it's become very hard to put yourself in the same room as the thing you're trying to commission, whether that be an air handler or a pump or a chiller. It's, it's very difficult to get on site these days and it's been that way obviously since the pandemic began. And so the thing that's changing there is that we need to figure out a way to verify performance remotely, right? So the whole process of commissioning is being thought, thought about and reimagined from the beginning. And then that kind of leads into the other major change which has really been happening for several years before the pandemic even began, which is the advent of analytics software and how it really plays very nicely into the commissioning process and not so much new building commissioning but also retro commissioning, so the ability to use analytic software and specifically fault detection diagnostics to Really uncover the issues in the building, which is really the purpose of commissioning anyway. So what, what, what are the issues that need to be fixed and that are keeping this building from being optimized? Yeah, definitely. So let's jump into those one at a time, and I think probably the best place to start is with your first point that today it's more difficult, as you describe it, to get into a room with the thing that you're commissioning and We now have technology, we have capabilities, remote access, remote control capabilities, engineering that enables this process, but what are the biggest challenges that maybe have stopped us using this effectively in the past and what has changed today so that we can do this sustainably and we can do this effectively as an industry? Yeah, totally. The first obstacle that you know in the past has kind of held back, you know, the use of analytics in the commissioning process is that the systems aren't necessarily ready to set up, say, analytics or set up remote monitoring. You know, often the last thing that gets installed in a building is the supervisory layer, the layer that allows you to Collect data basically and use it in an analytic software and then probably the very last piece is the actual internet connection, right, so enabling the remote access in the first place. Those things happen pretty late in the construction process. So with a new building it can be difficult to get that set up and also like Analytics like we talked about in the last couple of episodes, analytics is kind of a new thing. It's not necessarily understood well and it's not deployed. And so especially in an industry like construction, it's going to take a while for everyone to really understand the power of it and how it can sort of fit into these existing processes. Yeah, one of the things that you mentioned there, you know, often the last thing they do is turn the power on, the last thing they do is make this internet connection, you know, this. Every construction project, whether it's retrofits or whether it's a greenfield site, this is a ballet of 1000 different people with 1000 different functions and stakeholders. It's quite, it's very difficult to try and change some of those really fundamental workflows and the order of things getting done to enable some of this technology that you're talking about. How How is it, has it changed leading up to this? Are we now able to leverage different technology? Are we able to, to do this now that we couldn't do last year? What, what, what has been the effect that you think makes this enabled for us? Yeah, I just had a CEO of a smart building company on, on my podcast recently, and what she said was that COVID is really accelerating what would have happened anyway, so these changes were happening already. And if you look at leading commissioning agents, leading energy engineers, leading design firms even across the world, they were already on this path, and I think what COVID has done is basically dragged forward all that change to today, and a lot of companies say. You say you're a commissioning agent and you realize that your revenue is based on being able to go on site. Well, that's going to be a pretty motivating change for you to say how can I do my process remotely. So I think it is changing and the technology is there and obviously we have a lot of smart people in the industry. They're going to figure out, hey, I can actually do this without going on site, which is a win-win for everyone. Oh, absolutely, because in the end, no matter how we go about the process, the idea and the function like you described before is getting something, is finding the issues, getting up and running as optimally as possible, and it's the outcome that we're focused on. And if we can do that better and more effectively and in a more flexible and and time. Critical manner than happy days, you know, for us and all those included, you know, a risk here of introducing another whole buzzword, but you know, one of the things that we talk about in the industry and we see a lot of change or a shift into this technology when we talk about IoT and we talk about some of these components that we're talking about. Being directly connected to cloud spaces, to cloud infrastructures where some of this information can be collected without the supervisory layer existing as an example, are those changes also enabling us to be a little more effective in this approach? Yeah, exactly, yeah, you have technologies that kind of in the commissioning stage, you know, I think there are a lot of people that are realizing that maybe we don't need to wait for these core pieces of building infrastructure to come online for lack of a better word, but we have things like cellular modems that allow a controller to become online pretty pretty quickly. So yeah, there are tools right now that Available off the shelf and they can be temporary, so they can be used just during the testing process to allow that data to flow. Maybe you're shipping something on site and you're not needing to go on site and the critical staff that are already there are able to plug it in for you and now you're off and running in your commissioning process rather than waiting until everything gets online from an infrastructure perspective, which has so many benefits apart from reducing risk, apart from You know, upbringing additional productivity and saving time and getting on site and, and, you know, going through, if any, anyone there, when you try and get on site, it's not like you turn up, you park your car and you, and you walk on site. There's, there's inductions, there's, there's processes that need to be taken, so there's time involved in getting there physically, which you can save. Um, one of the other things which would be interesting to discuss would be once Does, does that enable us also to, to improve the way that we deploy our skills, because, you know, depending on the company, depending on, on what work you're doing, the skill sets that are required throughout this commissioning process because it's not a, it's not a one hour thing, it's not a one day thing. Does that remote access, does that that offsite flexibility also enable us to deploy our skills more effectively? Yeah, I mean, I think, I think one thing to point out is that we're not replacing the technical skills required in the commissioning process, right? So someone still needs to understand everything that goes into optimizing that thing, whatever it is, and we can't overlook all the mechanical engineers out there that are extremely good at doing what they're doing, but I think we also have to point out that part of their traditional process is something that Can be automated and can be made a lot more efficient so that then they can focus on what they are probably more passionate about, which is fixing the issues so that detection and diagnosis of the issue they don't necessarily need to do that manually and I think that's something to overcome that that's a very important skill set but also the piece that I think everyone would be more excited about like I said is The fun part, we've discovered this issue and how do we decide who should fix it, what should be done, and really use that human ingenuity on the solution rather than detecting the problem. Yeah, perfect. And I think that that's a good point to make about analytics in general. In the previous discussion we've talked about this, Diagnosis is the first step, and anything you can automate in that process is a huge step forward. You, you still need that expertise. You still need that skill set to be able to prioritize, to decide what's, what is scalable, what can be implemented, and the effect that that could have. So that it's an important, I think, point to make that that is, that is not a replacement, but an augmentation, you know, an improvement in the process so they can apply their skills even better. Uh, so that was the first point we talked about. Let's talk about the second point you made where, where, um, Analytics, whether it's in a new build, but even more importantly sometimes within a retro commissioning, can start to add even additional functionality or additional capabilities, and the end goal, or sorry, the end result can even be improved by using this technologies. Can you give us a bit of insight into that? Yeah, so we were just basically talking about the commissioning process, right? So that would be for a new building or an existing building that's going through some sort of renovation or upgrade of some of some sort. So I think that's a pretty well understood concept. So then the retro commissioning process would be, I have an existing building. It's been several years since it was commissioned. If it was commissioned at all, so the retro commission process is really a tune up. So getting the building back to its optimal state or if it's changed in operation, getting it to its new optimal state, right? And I think what most people have found is that when they do either of those traditional processes of commissioning, you know, you get the building into an optimal state, and then what happens next is like the infamous drift, right? So It's entropy. Things are going to change and things are going to degrade and Stuff gets overridden and valves get stuck and a number of things happen in a building over time that causes the performance to degrade and so where monitoring based commissioning comes in is the ability to take those one-time processes of commissioning and retro commissioning and make them continuous, so continue to do that same thing. Thing over and over and over again in a way that uncovers the issues as they occur and really get into being able to then prevent issues from happening in the first place. So the example I like to give is if a valve gets stuck somewhere. Usually a building operator is not going to know about it until a comfort complaint happens, right, so you can't see that from happening. But with monitoring-based commissioning, you know when the valve gets stuck and you're able to then maybe act on it before the comfort actually comforts the complaint actually happens in the space. So it's almost extending that commissioning phase, our traditional view of it, and And almost having this, this review process or this cycle that that applies the same, the same expectations, applies the same process and the same workflow on a regular basis to try and find not only things that that may have been missed or maybe the requirements have changed, but also uncover some of these faults, some of these, these, you know, diagnose some of these issues as they come along. I'm not even sure if this question is worthwhile, but, but, and maybe I'm going to step on, on, step in, in a puddle right here, but normally when we talk about data-based, um, sciences, when we talk about analytics, the more information, the better, you know, as a broad term. Does that mean that the, the impact or the effectiveness of this, of what we describe here, this retro. Commissioning can actually be more or more important than applying it on day one. I'm not sure I understand your question. Sorry. So, so my question, yeah, I completely understand. So my question is that, you know, with more information and when we talk about an existing building and we're going through this retrocommissioning process and we're revisiting buildings at a later date, does the, does the historical data that gives us more information, that gives us more insight enable us to do an even better job? Further down the line than we would on day one with the greenfield sites going through the initial process. Oh absolutely, yeah, I think from the standpoint of like many different standpoints, so one is just the analytics software has more of a baseline to understand what's normal and the team does too, so if they see a fault in the first day they might not, you know, they might. Realize whether it's out of calibration or not, but 6 months in, 1 year in, 2 years in, the normal operation of the building, the building has had a long time to run and for everyone to realize what's normal and what's not, and that helps the human and helps the algorithms. So yes, and then when you get into the diagnosis stage where analytic software has come up with something that someone needs to address, the ability to look at Last season or a year ago when you know this weather was happening that allows you to get easy it makes it easier to get into what's the root cause of this problem, what's the action that needs to happen a lot quicker exactly last question um. The world has gone through quite a challenge at the moment, as we mentioned before. We're in the middle of a pandemic, and like you described from one of the guests on your podcast, it's talking about how the current situation has really accelerated the adoption of some of the technologies that we see was inevitable as part of, you know, the smart buildings of the future. And from our conversation today, I think that what we've really described, if we boil it down to a picture, is that commissioning, you know, from what we imagined to commissioning today, there's less ladders, there's less switchboards, there's, there's less site visits, there's less hard hats, there's, there's leveraging technology to be able to do and go through this process and achieve the ultimate goal more effectively. Is this sustainable? Is this some, is the changes that we've gone through from your perspective in the last six months, driven by the pandemic, is this what commissioning is from now on? Is this the, the picture that we have in our heads, and is this what we do as an industry in general moving forward? Yeah, I think, I think the way to answer that is to look at how you can get better results, and I think the way to get better results is to use these modern tools, and I think that it being beneficial for the pandemic is just like one way that it shows how it's better, so that commissioning process is more resilient if it's being able to be done remotely. But that's just one way in which a modern commissioning process using analytics is better. The other way in which it's better is you're able to do things like instead of just manually testing 10% of VAV boxes in the building, for instance, you're able to test them all at once across the whole building and do that at scale and see. System level effects and things like that. So the commissioning process is actually improved in many different ways, and I think once everyone sees that, I think that that change will be sustainable. Exactly. That's why from my perspective anyway, when we look at our industry, that's a great, that's a great situation for us to be in because the When the technology is better, whatever inspires us to, to, to adopt that technology, whatever inspires us to make those changes, if the results are better, then it's, then, you know, it's a positive shift for us as an industry. So that's great. James, thank you so much. Another great conversation. It was really great to have you here. So thank you so much for your time. Thanks, John. Glad to be here. And, and thank you to everyone listening. Please remember not just to subscribe, comment, or share the episode here at Buildings of Tomorrow, but go and check out nexus.substack.com, uh, subscribe to the newsletter, check out the podcast, uh, think about subscribing and get some really, um, some really top quality and in-depth conversations and information about some of the topics we've talked about. And, uh, James, I get the feeling that, uh, hopefully we'll have a chance to chat again in the future. Yeah, we've kind of scratched the surface on a couple of these different topics, so no doubt we'll find the time to go into a bit more detail and find a couple of other exciting things to talk about. Yeah, I can't wait. Perfect. Thank you all, and uh we'll talk to you soon.

Full transcript (WebVTT)