#135 Fire Safety for E-House solutions
Show notes
Containerized solutions, such as E-Houses, have become more prevalent in the building industry. What does this solution entail and what benefits does it provide? Tune in with Jon Lester and Markus Lagler, Global Business Development Manager for fire safety at Siemens Smart Infrastructure, to find out!
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name is John Lester, and in today's episode, we are talking about fire safety solutions, specifically for containerized solutions like e-houses and the like. I'm joined today by Marcus Lugler. He is the global Business Development Manager for fire safety for containerized solutions and e-houses. Marcus, thank you so much for joining us. Thank you very much for the invitation, Sean. Happy to be here. Uh, it, it's an absolute pleasure to have you here, especially when you're going to talk about something which is, let's call it a little bit unique, but something that we're seeing more and more of in our industry, which is containerized solutions, you know, modular, uh, concepts to deliver, uh, different functionality in buildings. And, and, and let's start there. Uh, give us a quick, A quick definition, what, what is a containerized solution and what do we mean when we use this term? Well, mainly it's a building, but besides the traditional ways to build a building, it's made completely out of containers. Um, these containers are built on one end of the world, equipped with different kinds of equipment for different fields of application, and then going all over to another place on Earth to operate, to be distributing, to provide the services. And, uh, they're doing that, well, in a pretty fast way and, uh, in a pretty lean way compared to a traditional building, but maybe I'm jumping up a little bit ahead of in this. Um, let, let, let's go straight there because, because that's why I'm interested. It's something that we're seeing more and more of, uh, and, and more applications are delivered in this manner. What, what are the main benefits for, for, you know, taking this containerized approach? Yeah, when, when, when you say that, we are seeing that more and more, that's absolutely right. I mean, we did over 500 e-houses, and we've started just 10 years ago. Um, the different fields of application, they, they range from data centers, mining, petrochemical applications, uh, power distribution in a more classic way over to the newer battery energy storage systems that we are seeing now being installed all over the world at solar plants, at, uh, grid stabilization purposes in industries. So, in principle, eH is a part of, of the shift that we see in how the grids, in how countries are evolving in providing their, their energy. Um, The the trend, um, well, has it driven or why is it driven? He has really customized, and when we say customized, we mean that they are, that's, uh, during the outbuilt, meaning they're pre-built, pre-tested, pre-assembled, they're somehow tailored to the different needs for different applications for different customers, for different fields. And they're providing a great value and flexibility. So if you have, for example, interim solutions, which are only there in place for a few months, or if you do have hard to access, um, places, like, for example, we do have projects in Uganda, we do have them in Nigeria, we do have them in, in mining. applications where the, the whole site is really tricky to assess. It's often easier to ship a readily done house with a lot of equipment inside of it, compared to sending over a couple of people to, to build it up on site. So it's really this, this pre-assembly, this pre-testing that brings in great value. Perfect. So it's, it, it can be faster, it can help control the cost, but definitely also control those situations where flexibility is required or the situation on site, whatever it might be, accessibility, uh, this is a way for us to get around those challenges. It is, it is indeed. I mean, in the marketing material that we have, there's some great numbers shown with, with a lead time reduction of up to 50%, with a price reduction of up to 20%. But it's not so much that's why a customer decides or why an application is demanding an e-house. It's more really that's, that aehouse can be placed on places where traditional building simply can't bring in some great value in doing so. Yeah, perfect. And, and as you described, they are small buildings, aren't they? Uh, they're, they're not connected to the earth with, uh, with concrete footings like a, a, a normal building, but They still have the ability to deliver some of those services, uh, just from a, a, a modular perspective. Absolutely. In fact, from a technical point of view, you do have the same challenges that you have in the building. You do have a heating, you do have access control, you do have all of the different applications that, that we are having in a building protection or a building product wall. And of course, then there's the fire safety as well. Yeah, perfect. And, and before we jumped deeply into the fire safety, we talked a little bit about the benefits, but especially when we start talking about an industry like fire safety, which, uh, you know, we have, uh, global regulations, we have things that we have to ensure that we're adhering to to provide the best safety expected. What are some of the challenges when you start to take this containerized, uh, approach, that, when we talk about this global market, uh, and, and how things are deployed, manufactured, pre-tested, etc. Yeah, fire is a little bit, uh, uh, difficult topic. Let's say, let's start off with regulations. As the regulations are really strongly varying in the different countries or in the different, also in different states. For example, if you take a look over to, to America, there's the local AHAs as they're called. Local fire marshals do have pretty much an influence on how a local system is built and then set into operation. Um, this ranges strongly. So like, uh, if you cross, uh, a country border that's just 50 m apart, and the local authorities are thinking of fire completely different. And this, of course, multiplies if you want to build up a solution in a completely different country as where you want to use it, as you may have to use different cylinders of, of extinguishing agents. Which aren't allowed to be even transported in the country where you want to build your e-house. And this gets really, really tricky, especially if you, uh, take a look into what we're doing when we speak about e-houses in battery energy storage solutions or data centers, but, uh, solutions are strongly standardized and optimized, and are often produced in a quite large scale and at the moment of production, you don't really know to where this is going to be shipped as soon as it's done. Um, so that's, that's, uh, the main requirement when we speak about fire safety in an e-house is not protecting the e-house by itself. It's protecting the e-house to the standard that is needed to be protected to. And this is really, uh, where you need a lot of experience. We need a, a big network. So we do have, uh, competence centers in over 25 countries spread around the globe, and, we do need a lot of them to somehow identify the different standards and to somehow define into which products to use or how the protection should work. And, uh, the combination of that, that's, that's really specific fire safety know-how with that, uh, local reg local regulations. And then with the logistic competences to get a container which is filled in some cases with, with, uh, extinguishing equipment with dangerous goods, uh, over to the other side of the planet. This is really what the e-house or the containerized solution, uh, as itself, uh, makes an interesting challenge or, uh, uh, Special application. Yeah, absolutely. And, and let's dive into that in a little bit more detail, because as you mentioned there, um, whether it's a, an e-house, a containerized solution, or a normal building, there are some similarities, so we have to adhere to the local regulation, uh, etc. you know, we have to be able to, to maintain the expectations of, of wherever this containerized solution ends up eventually. What are some of the differences from a normal building to, to a containerized solution or an e-house, so, and how does that affect, The, the approach you take and the solution that you bring into that from a fire safety perspective. Uh, on the one hand side, it's, of course, the, the fact that traditional buildings often aren't shipped, shipped after they are built. So that there's a little bit, uh, the challenge that comes in there. So you do have other, uh, other, um, Other requirements in, in regards to modularity, in regards to transportation, in regards to commissioning. You can't have a single person, for example, build up the whole system as you do in a traditional building. And, uh, on the other hand, of course, there's, there's the applications of the e-houses somehow or sometime differ quite a bit. For example, lithium-ion batteries, which are, I think you've already had a podcast about it, John, um, which, which are kind of different to protect than everything else that we know. And, uh, this again is, is uh, Bringing two completely new approaches to technology, to buildings, to, to grid stabilization, and yet together that, uh, have never been combined before. And, uh, the combination of that. Including that, that, uh, let's say, local varying standards and local varying challenges, and for example, the different products, uh, is quite critical. If you take a look at the fire safety world, if you have two big worlds, which is the, the American guided UL world, and then there's the IUC world, which is based around the European EN standards. And mixing them together in terms of operation and producing of the e-houses is quite a challenge. Yeah. No, I understand. So the, so not only do we have the, the, the challenge when we're in the manufacturing process of ensuring that what's being installed, what's being commissioned, and the way it's being done suits the end, the end geographical target, let's call it, or the destination. Uh, then you have the differing, uh, applications within that. So, you mentioned lithium-ion battery, and as you say, we, we've, we've talked about this before on, on this show. Where lithium-ion batteries really do present quite a unique challenge. Um, so you have a, you, you have a containerized solution, which may be the same physical size, uh, but has a, a completely different requirement from a detection and extinguishing and alarming, uh, and an event handling perspective. Um, and then, of course, you have this, you have this disconnect, or maybe it's not a disconnect, but it's an additional challenge where in a traditional building, uh, there's a contractor or there's someone responsible for running the wires, installing the components, designing the system, commissioning the system, and maybe even running and servicing the system, where that's not really feasible for a containerized solution, because, uh, you know, one company, 11, stakeholder may do. The, the construction side and do the commissioning side or whatever it might be, uh sorry, the pre-commissioning and the pre-testing, and then someone else on the other side of the world goes through, the, the processes that have to happen at the other end, and, and, you know, this is a, a, a connection that maybe we don't see on a normal, uh, construction site or a more traditional approach to building, um. So, so we have within those applications, you mentioned quite a few, you know, the, the energy distribution, uh, lithium-ion battery, or just general battery storage, data centers, uh, you know, modular functionality, uh, and, and different things. What, what are some of the examples? So we talked about lithium-ion battery, when we start to talk about other applications, How does that start to affect, uh, you know, the, that final solution, you know, the, the combination between the detection and the alarming and, and the, the extinguishing, uh, if you have an example in the back of your mind. Um, so if we, maybe one thing that I should have mentioned a little bit early on, if we speak about containerized solutions that are not to be, um, not to be confused with traditional shipping containers. And in some cases, or in most cases, they are really just one container. In other cases, these containerized solutions get as big as 2500, even we have a project with 4500, uh, square meters. So they are really not of buildings that get built together. And, uh, if we don't go a step, uh, away from, for example, lithium-ion protection, you do have all of the different applications that you would have in a traditional traditional building split up over this huge, uh, amounts of space in these containers. And, uh, if you, you know, take a look into, for example, pre-manfactured data centers, you do have in these data centers different rooms with different equipments and different requirements. And then you do have, for example, of course, the power distribution for a data center, which can be quite, um, impressive. You do have something like the meeting rooms where all the external wiring, the internal wirings gets together, and then you do have the Cellarex, which is standing next to each other, side by side for the rest of the, of the space that you have available. And each of these rooms needs another protection concept. They needs, uh, for example, An air sampling device to get the earliest response possible. Uh, you do need, for example, different extinguishing solutions, as some rooms will be, uh, all of the time, uh, a person will be in there and working in there, and other rooms will have mainly technical equipment or, uh, life safety is a different topic, or you do need a different extinguishing agents to provide the best protection possible for the application. This is, um, the principle that the complexity of a normal building can be within one e-house as well. And then again, these, these big solutions, uh, with, with thousands of square meter, uh, space. It gets transported, of course, in, in small modules. So you do have to think about linkages. You do have to think about connections. You do have to, to think all of that in the engineering phase. When you're doing the conduits, you're doing the wiring, when you're speaking, thinking about something like flow calculations for the, for the agents, for the extinguishing agents. It can get pretty complex, pretty fast. Yeah, and I wanted to ask you about that, because thank you so much for that, that clarification, because I think it's a really important one. you know, when we talk about these e-Hus or containerized solutions, they don't always mean 11 small container that stand-alone, or even 10 of the same application that stand next to each other, but they can be. Any modular building concept that is, that is trying to build, uh, you know, deploy one single module or deploy a, a really large building just in this manner, in this approach. You mentioned there really quickly, the impact on the planning process. How, how do you go about if we take the Example of these larger projects where you do have, you know, a meeting room, a kitchen, uh, you know, a server room, um, you know, all of these different applications that you would see in a building in, in one process. How, how does that, that planning process differ from a more traditional construction approach? Well, on the one side, it's, uh, if you're speaking about eha or if you speak about reassembling in general, you do have the possibility to go down two parallel paths. The one with the designing and pre-assembling of the equipment, the other one with the on-site work. And of course, you do have, for example, in the e-house world, it's often quite usual that the e-house builder itself is another one who is building the containers. You do have container builders, you do have e-house builders, they need to work together. And, uh, this, this architectural design phase, and, uh, this is, this parallelization of this design comes down to in principle, one stop for the end customer at the beginning to define all that. After that, you get to the, the, the manufacturing phase, so you do have, uh, principle, a lot of benefits there as if you have, uh, well, an efficient factory where this is built compared to a really, um, let's say, on-site environment, which is, uh, has to deal with some, some local effects and, uh, another resource availability. And, uh, with that, there's, there's a lot of time saved. And then also the, the main goal of all of these e-houses is to get as close to a, a plug and play solution as possible. So when you really ship the goods to the, to the sites, the principal to a certain extent finished building to the site. It's just about sending over an engineering team, a commissioning team for a couple of weeks compared to having them there for years and years to pull something up. You do shift work completely from one end to the other end, but besides that, we're again pretty close to the planning of a traditional building, as it more or less is one. So, you have to go through the same process. It's just that effort has shifted a little bit earlier in the phase, uh, and then that, you know, the, the process that we all, where we all get excited in a more traditional building where you break ground and you, and you get down to the basement, and then you reach back up to, to ground level and you start to go up, um, is a little bit different, because this happens in, this happens in a much shorter time frame, because all of the work, or so much of the work has been done. In the factory, in this controlled environment, uh, in a more productive and, and a more, uh, manufacturing style approach. Absolutely. I mean, what, what really enables us to do e-house business in the first instance is the development that we've seen in the last years going from a digital swim or building information management. This is really, uh, These are trends that are key to, to providing successfully that level of project management and alignment upfront that you need to successfully build uh a pre-assembled solution and pre-task that of that size. Yeah, because you need that level of detail, don't you? You need to be able to, like you, you talked about before about the, the joins and the, and the terminations, and the connections. Uh, you know, they can't be, can't be half a meter off or 1 ft off, or even, even 10 mils off in some cases. Yeah, could be. Absolutely. Perfect. Uh, Marcus, thank you so much. It's been a really interesting conversation. I get the feeling that we can dive a little bit deeper at some point into this containerized solution, because as, as we discussed, We're seeing more and more of it. And And, and I think, uh, you know, just the, the example that you have of, of, of a building that's 104,000 square meters, but that has been built in this manner. You know, this is something that's, that maybe we've only seen as, as one-offs and exceptions to the rule in the past to really test, but we're starting to see this more and more in the industry. And, and it's really exciting to, to see what, what we're capable of. And And what we're able to, to achieve with this approach, and how we manage some of the challenges that come with it. So, thank you so much for your time, it was a real pleasure. My pleasure, John. Thank you. Thank you. And thanks to everyone who is listening or watching us here today. Remember to subscribe, like, comment on this episode, uh, share it, uh, and ensure that, uh, you, you let us know, uh, whether it might be on with the channel where you're watching, or via LinkedIn or whatever it might be on any other topics you're interested in, or any additional questions. Uh, we'll force Marcus to come back and have a chat with us and to talk in a little bit more detail into some of, uh, of the different topics. But until then, please look out for our, our episodes that come out regularly, and, uh, yeah, we'll see you very soon.