#151 The European Green Deal: Understanding the legislative framework for buildings

Buildings of Tomorrow ·

Show notes

In our previous episode with Leo Bivetti, Program Manager for the European Green Deal at Siemens Smart Infrastructure, we spoke about the overarching European Green Deal, its legislations, and the underlying directives found in the "Fit for 55" package. In this episode, we will dive into the pertinent directives and legislations for the building industry, such as the EPBD, and discuss how these vary for different types of buildings. Tune in!

Transcript

Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name is John Lester, and in today's episode we are talking about legislative frameworks for the building industry. Now this is a continuation and I'm joined again by Leo Bevetti, who is the, the program manager for the European Green Deal at Siemens Smart-Infrastructure. Leo, thanks for joining us. Hi, John, thanks for having me again. It's an absolute pleasure. Now, Leo, last time we caught up, we talked about the European Green Deal, and at a top level, the European Green Deal includes a huge amount of different legislations and regulatory expectations, all driving towards having this net zero EU. At 2050, and we also dived in a little bit into some of the specific packages which are relevant for the building industry, and here was the fit for 55 package, and some of the different pieces around energy efficiency, uh, building control and expectation, and uh and and some other pieces, uh e-mobility, EV charging within buildings, etc. And today I'd like to dive in a little bit more into some of these, these different, uh, pillars, let's call it as part of the European Green Deal. So, so let's do that, let's dive straight in. The European Green Deal is a collection of many, many different pieces of legislation, like we mentioned. What, what are the relevant pillars, what are the relevant pieces for the building industry? Yes, uh, it's an important topic here and maybe I just quickly recall to start with, with the building specific targets. So the EU must reduce greenhouse gas emissions from buildings by 60% and their energy consumption by 14%. And also there is an indicative target to really go for renewable energies for 49% in the building sector, and all this is of course set out to lead us to this net zero emission building stock. So the foundation to support these goals is basically built on five pillars I would say. Uh, 3, important, very important directives, then a newly proposed emissions trading system, but also, uh, so-called social climate fund. And let me quickly give an overview of these elements and uh I would start with the directives part here. So first there is uh this um uh Energy efficiency directive, uh, EED, the abbreviation of this. Under this directive, all EU countries are required to use energy more efficiently at all stages of the energy chain, so including energy generation, transmission, distribution, and and use consumption as well. The second directive I would like to mention is the Renewable Energy Directive, RED. Now this directive sets rules for the EU to achieve the currently valid or proposed 40% renewable targets by 2030, with this indicative target for buildings of 49% I was mentioning. And the Renewable Energy Directive is basically then the legal framework for the development of renewable energy across all sectors of the EU economy. Then the third pillar of this of this directive frameworks is the Energy Performance of Building Directive EPBD. Uh, so this aims to promote the improvement of the energy performance of buildings, as it says in the term, uh, within the European Union. So this takes into account the outdoor climatic and local conditions as well as indoor climate requirements and also takes into account cost effective effectiveness requirements. These are not the only directives, so you correctly mentioned that there is a huge set of directives or regulations that are being revised or even, even defined newly in the frame of the Fit for 55 package and maybe just to touch quickly on two other ones which I didn't know, did not include now in my five pillars, but there is also something called governance regulation which helps the EU reach the climate and energy targets. And this regulation on the governance sets common rules for planning, reporting and monitoring, which is also important because you need always to to monitor and to see where are you on your way there. So it ensures that the EU planning and reporting are synchronized with the ambition cycles under the Paris Agreement again. Another example that more comes up more and more prominently and also has a relation to Bs, even, even though maybe someone would not think about it in the first guess there is the sustainable product policy and ecodesign legislation or or and energy labeling, uh, which are basically effective tools for improving the energy efficiency and sustainability of products. Now this white products and buildings, so these products help to eliminate the least performing products from the market and support industrial competitiveness and innovation, basically by promoting a better environmental performance of these products. So the, the, the deal's push for circular economy will certainly encourage increased use of recycled materials. And improvements to energy efficiency in buildings, buildings, building design as well. Just to mention one example here, uh, maybe or likely some boiler types would no longer be allowed based on this, uh, this regulation. But let me come back to the next pillar, the fourth pillar, and this is why I want really to frame it around these 5 pillars because now we talked a little bit about directives. But there are also elements that are related to financial topics there. So one pillar is this newly coming up or proposed emission trading system for buildings and road transport. So this is to address the the growing emission from from these sectors I was just mentioning in a cost effective way, so it's, it's a financial instrument. And tied to this, there is also, and this will be then the basically the proposed 5th pillar here, this, uh, this is a new proposal for the Social Climate Fund. So this is to uh to address the social impact of carbon pricing in the uh in all the sectors, basically, uh, uh, uh, older sectors, meaning building and transport sectors. Uh, you must know that 25% of this revenue from this emissions trading system I was mentioning. Would be directed into this, this instrument, the Social Climate Fund, uh, with a target to support vulnerable groups and mitigate energy and mobility, poverty, and this is, uh, this is then usually also complemented with, uh, uh, with financing from, from member, member states as well. Uh, and maybe a last point around this that I would like to mention, and it's also important to know there is always kind of a principle as a guiding principle in place. The guiding principle is energy efficiency first. So this is the acknowledge that Europe's biggest domestic energy source is energy efficiency. And this principle really says also we must remove barriers that prevent somehow energy efficiency improvements. We must develop and enforce concrete policies really to prioritize energy efficiency. Uh, topics. OK, but what we have seen now with this summary is that the one goes not without the other. These policies, these instruments, these pillars, they must really work hand in hand and must complement each other really to commonly support the overall objectives towards a net zero building stock. I understand, and, and, and here's where I'd like to dive in a little bit more detail there, because as you mentioned, you, you just had your five pillars, um, 3 different directives, some financial approaches as well, some financial vehicles to help support and and drive the investment in this space. What are some of the common objectives or what are some of the common guiding, uh, guiding topics across these different directives that really push us towards that guiding principle that you mentioned of energy efficiency? Where, where are some of the areas where, where people can focus so that they know that they're pushing in the right direction? Yeah, sure, uh, this is, uh, I was mentioning about the different directives, and in each of these directives you have, uh, supporting means that, that, that will, will drive towards this common direction. So, uh, we talked a little bit in our first episode, uh, Green Deal overall already about some elements. So let, let me just, uh, come back to the, to the main objectives that that are required to, to, to be pushed to achieve the net zero building stock in, in 2050. So in a nutshell, this is basically one is increase the rate of energy renovations. We talked a little bit about this already. Increase not only the rate, but this will be the second one, not only the rate, but also the depth of energy renovation, so bigger renovations, not just touching the surface somehow. The third point is, uh, and this is not coming as a surprise, is decarbonization at all stages of the building life cycle. Then we also talked, I think it was in the first episode already about the kind of the exemplary role of the public sector. So it's always, uh, I mentioned there are different, different flavors on on this legislation also for public sector versus residential buildings, for instance. So there is an exemplary role to be taken by the public sector. Then we need to support better planning and information on buildings, so we need to act and to measure as well. We need to drive investments in energy efficiency in buildings. With the Social Climate Fund that was mentioned before, we need to fight energy poverty and deliver all the decent living conditions for everyone. And an important next point would be also a digitalization of smart buildings for energy system integration, and all this is not not working if we are not driving gearing towards the next step or the last objective I want to mention is the upscale of the of the workforce also in the building sector. Understand, so lots of areas to work, um, lots of spaces also for improvement, recognizing the, the, the large proportion specifically in existing buildings which aren't, aren't driven, aren't operated in an efficient way, an efficient way, sorry, and here's where I'd like to also understand a little bit, within these different directives, within these different legislations, how do they differentiate and what are some of the, the differences as an example between new buildings? That are being planned now today are going through the construction and delivery process, and existing buildings that need to be part of this renovation, I think it was one of your first points, or first couple of points, increasing the rate of renovation and and increasing the, the depth of that renovation. Yeah, yeah, I'm, I'm happy to, to, to talk about some points, uh, as you can imagine, there are many, many bullet points in all this, uh, legislative work which usually are different, uh, or many, many pages to read, right, and not, not everything, really digestible reading, but anyway, uh, some distinctions are mainly made regarding requirements for new construction for existing buildings and uh for renovation of buildings. Then additionally, there are also partially different requirements set out and defined in terms of of timelines uh also regarding the residential versus non-residential buildings, and all these elements need to be considered and be evaluated alongside with the particular use case we we aren't talking about. But let me make an example on the. On how requirements from the different pillars I was mentioning would would contribute or are supposed to contribute to certain objectives, and I take now as an example, I take the objective towards digitalization and smart buildings for energy system integration. Now we have learned a little bit about these different pillars here. So if you look, uh, we'll just read a bit more insight or give a bit more insight in the Energy efficiency directive, then there is a requirement that says, There is a is a is a need for implementation of energy management systems in high energy intensive enterprises, so this comes from that part as a requirement. Then there are other requirements coming from the renewable Energy Directive would also support this overall objective, and this requirement would say, so transmission system operators, so-called TSOs, and distribution system operators, so-called DSOs, they need to communicate the share of renewable electricity in a transparent way to end users. So, so that you have free transparency here which already per se is is something that is beneficial. And then I would say probably the most important contribution comes then in this case here from the EPBD, so the Energy Performance of Building Directive, and this one says in this context, buildings need to have measuring and control devices for monitoring and regulation of indoor air quality and separate control of temperature in each room. It says also there is a need for installation of a recharging point in buildings, at least 1 recharging point per bigger than 5 parking spaces, buildings. There are of course more flavors in it, but I might just just some examples here. The EPBD also says there is a need for or a mandatory need for a smart readiness indicator indicator. Which is kind of a, of a, of a scheme that really does what it says, so it tells you about the readiness uh in in terms of smartness of a building, also in terms of interaction with other things here and uh this is a, this is a scheme that is is required for non-residential buildings in this case. So again, a difference here, residential, non-residential. Then also related to non-residential buildings, the EPBD mandates a box, an automation system for non-residential buildings with HVAC capacity over 290 kilowatts, and all the things that come along with the, from the EPBD side is also digital tools in inspection schemes and effective control and monitoring functionalities in buildings. And this starting from 2025 onwards. So you see a bit uh different uh packages or different directives contribute each one to a specific objective here, uh, and, uh, and so therefore you cannot just um deal with one of these directives, you really need to, to, to oversee a bit the picture uh because uh I was saying it probably earlier that it's crucial that these directives work hand in hand. Uh, but, uh, it's still not one thing only, so it's different elements and, and so you need to, to do a bit of relation between different things. Yeah, that's a great example, Leo, because it, it really highlights exactly what you're saying, but if you really look at the holistic view, there are so many different elements across the different stakeholders within, uh, you know, the flow of the generation, the transmission, the, the, the delivery, let's call it, and also the, the consumption of energy in this space. Um, maybe another quick example because I think examples are a great way to really demonstrate that, that complexity, let's call it, or, or at least the consideration that you mentioned. You have to think about this, uh, holistically rather than in an isolated view. Do you have another quick example for us? Sure, I can make another example and, and let's call it somehow a challenge, uh, not, not to, to, to call too much complexity, even though you're absolutely right. I mean, it's not, not an easy thing to, to find the relation. But let me pick maybe a different example with different elements contributing in this case, and let's give a look at the objective to increase the rate of energy renovations. So here we have the Energy efficiency directive that has really concrete requirements set down. So one of which is on a yearly basis, so year per year, the reduction. Of total energy consumptions of all public bodies must be 1.7%. So this, this shows you the yearly pathway towards the target there. So this is, this is a firm requirement in there. Also in this energy efficiency directive, you have this requirement of at least 3% of publicly owned buildings need to be renovated. Yearly to reach or to get the status net zero energy buildings, so this is also a firm requirement coming out of the Energy efficiency Directive, but The Energy performance of building directive also contributes to this to this increased rate of energy renovations. One element, which is an important one is the so-called MEPs, so minimum Energy performance standards, MEPS, and this defines basically what it says, right? So minimum, minimal energy performance standards and Uh, Buildings are classified in in standards or in, in, in a scale from G to A, A being the best one, and this requirement out of the EPBD says basically the G and F, so the worst performing buildings, they need to become E. So the next level here or, or the next, the over next level in case of the, of the last level here, uh, they need to become a better performing building by 2030 for non-residential buildings. And by 2033 for residential buildings. So again here we see a bit of difference, residential, non-residential, but both of them need to definitely to improve. And then the further down the road there are further requirements to, to, to scale up to become even more efficient. But in this example, uh, before I talked a little bit about different directives. Now we have here in this example two directives, but here an important role is all of this, what I introduced to you as, as the Social Climate Fund. So it, it plays really a crucial role here as well by providing financial support for energy efficiency and renovation of buildings. Mitigating basically the, the cases where we talk about energy poverty, and you must know that about 7% of European households fall into this category. So these are cases, cases where, People or bodies are not able to, to not able or struggling to pay the electricity bills or are obligated to renovate but do not have the financial means, so putting them into serious troubles. So this means really that in this case also the financial aspect becomes really an important factor in the complete story to contribute to this energy renovation topic. So you see, uh, again, uh, really topics or the sources are interlinked, but all of them contribute really to a target toward towards this 2030 respectively, 2050 objective. Understand. Leo, thanks so much for those two examples, because I think no better, no better explanation and way to demonstrate how interlinked these different directives are and the financial vehicles that, that go along as part of the European Green Deal. Uh, really great examples, and, and I still, I still feel like we have more conversations to have, but, but thank you so much for that deep dive into a handful of, of these different pillars, these 5 different pillars that really relate directly to, or more directly to the building industry. Um, and, and hey, thanks again for sharing your time and your expertise because it is a, let's say, a landscape with many different moving parts, and, and as you've mentioned in previous discussions, Many of these directives and many of the details are still being worked out and different socioeconomic or or or governmental situations are also driving change at different times in these spaces, so really much more for us to discover and much more for us to learn as an industry in this space. So thank you for joining us again and and uh sharing your insight. Sure, thank you for the interesting questions, John. Uh, it's an absolute pleasure, and I look forward to, to more conversations in the future, Leo. And, uh, a very quick thank you also to everyone listening. Thanks again. Please remember to share, like, comment on this episode. Subscribe to us, uh, wherever you are listening to us for this episode and look out for new episodes that could be around this energy efficiency and the European Green Deal or other interesting topics for the building and energy industry. So look out for those every other week. But until we see you then, uh, enjoy and we'll see you soon.

Full transcript (WebVTT)