#131 Fire Protection for Li-ion Battery Cell Production

Buildings of Tomorrow ·

Show notes

In this episode, Emelie Emanuelsson, Global Product Manager for fire safety applications at Siemens Smart Infrastructure, joins us together with Manuel Obert, expert for structures and seismology at TÜV SÜD, to explore the importance of fire protection strategies within giga factories. Find out what the process of battery cell production entails and which parts are inclined to high levels of risk for fire protection!

Transcript

Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name is John Lester, and in today's episode, we are talking about fire safety in gigafactories, in factories that we produce batteries and battery cells. Uh, I'm joined today by two guests, I'm very lucky to be joined by two guests today, uh, Emily Emmanuelsson, who is a global product manager for fire safety applications at Siemens Smart-Infrastructure. And Manuel Obert, who's an expert for structures, seismology, and fire safety at Tivoo. Uh, Emily and Manuel, thank you so much for joining us. Thank you. Thank you. And, uh, before we jump in, Manuel, could you give us a quick, uh, explanation on Tivoo, uh, where you're representing today? Uh, who are you and what do you do in our industry? Of course, I will. So let's start with uh my company Tsuit. Um, so Tsuit is a trusted partner of Choice for, for safety, security, and sustainability solutions. So, um, today, um, Tsuit is represented by more than 25,000 employees. Uh, located across over 1000 locations worldwide. Um, and I, as a person, work in the Department of Structures and seismology and fire protection. And as an example for, for this topic today, uh, I am also a project leader. I was a project leader of, uh, technical report. We were, we were talking later about. Perfect. Emily, a quick question for you. Uh, in the title I mentioned gigafactories. What does gigafactory mean? So gigafactory is a common name for large factories that nowadays are producing lithium ion batteries, and giga means basically big. And to give you an example, the new factory that Nofold is building in the north of Sweden equals the size of 70 soccer fields. So these are 70s. So we're talking about large factories, gigafactories. Wow, that's amazing. And you know this, as you say, this is something that is quite a common term now. We're starting to see this more and more in industry press, in, in, in normal press as well. Why are we starting to see gigafactories so much more today than we did in the past years? So especially here in Europe, we're seeing them popping up almost in every country right now. It is basically to be able to have production close by for the automotive industry and providing renewable, clean and green energy as well for the power generation and I would say it's also a consequence of trying to meet the Paris Agreement that we see right now that Europe is investing a lot into gigafactories and the possibility to have green energy close by. So e-mobility, those consumer electronics that you mentioned, all leverage this technology and that really. Driving factor of the localization that we see is, is that requirement to, to have manufacturing close to where, you know, where the usage is and, and to push, push this, perfect, and, and maybe quickly before we dive into a little bit more depth of the fire safety applications, you mentioned before that, that these factories are huge, um, what else is special about them, um, you know, that make these gigafactories a bit different from some of the more traditional industries we know? Well, I would definitely say that the most remarkable thing when you build such a huge factory like 70 soccer fields right now is that they try to be powered by green energy. Um, so located at places where you have green energy close by, that's, that's one thing. And the other part of it, uh, and now I'm primarily talking about the European ones, is that they also want to have them recycling facilities for the materials and the use batteries close by. So like closing the ecosystem of the whole chain here of batteries. Um, this is maybe a bit different from what we have seen, um, seen in, in other areas of the world. Um, that is, that is special. The size, the clear focus on sustainability, um, the clear focus on, on providing green energy and, and renewable, um, recycled, like a recycled whole ecosystem. Amazing. I thank you for that because I think it's, as you say, that's something that's relatively unique when we look back into the past rather than this sort of global supply chain approach, they're, they're changing this cyclical approach into a local supply chain. Which is a big shift, especially for this kind of industry when we talk about mobility and things like that. Yeah, and I think for example, there are also the, it's driven all by the automotive industry and they are also committing themselves to have green policies. So if you buy a car in a couple of years, the consumer might want to know that the whole vehicle is certified green and that every part of it was recyclable. So it's a, it's a shift here. Yeah, absolutely. Um, let's dive into the process itself a little bit. Um, Manuel, how, uh, or what is the process that is used to create these, these battery cells, and, and which parts of it kind of highlight the or deliver the highest levels of risk from a fire safety perspective? Yeah, well, um, a lithium-ion battery or shortly lips cell. Uh, can be produced in 3 different variants to start with some basics. Um, there are cylindrical, prismatic, or pouch cells, but independent of the type of the cell or, um, of the production process, this, uh, production process is divided into 3 high-level process steps. So first, there is the robe manufacturing. Afterwards, it's going on with the cell assembly, and at the end there is the cell finishing. And um from a safety-oriented point of view, um, the three high-level process steps can be divided into two hazard zones. So the first one is all the process steps during the electrode manufacturing and cellar assembly. In these steps and process steps, there are no electrochemical hazards active. The hazards only exist due to process steps itself or the intrinsic material properties. The second hazard zone, it's the most important one, it's the self-finishing. All of the process steps during the self-finishing. So as soon as the cell, the battery cell is filled with electrolyte, a potential of electrochemical hazard is given. And, and therefore the self-finishing is allocated to the highest risk potential during the whole production process. Yeah, perfect. Let's take the chance to dive in a little bit deeper than in this self-finishing process, as you mentioned, this is the, the, the part of the process which is the highest risk. Uh, within that high level process, what are some of the steps that uh that really deliver this high risk from a fire safety perspective? So if in this self-finishing process, the high-level process step, let's say, there are two key processes that represent the highest risks. It's, the first is the formation and the second one is the aging. Um, let's start with the formation first, and to explain a bit more about the process that. Um, during the battery formation, um, this is the process where the initial charge and discharge of a battery cell is occurring. So let's say it's kind of when the cell comes to life. And this can take several days, up to 1 or 2 weeks. Um, when you're talking about, about the hazards within this formation process step, um, with the start of the, of the first charging cycle, so the production errors from previous process steps can have potentially very dangerous consequences. Um, and as several cells are charged and discharged at the same time, And there's also an increased risk of fire due to the large quantity of cells. So that's again, considering all the production process steps, the formation process is the one with the highest risk potential. As I said before, it's the first. the cell is charged and discharged and checked for the first time if there is a current or not a current active. So that is related to a very high risk and electrochemical hazard is available. And in addition to this, the arrangement of the cells, they are like stored during the formation process in formation tower or in wrecks in close proximity that also contributes to, uh, to this risk classification. Um, the second, um, process that that is allocated to a high risk potential is the aging process. And this process presents the, the final or represents the final step in the cell production. And it's used for quality assurance. And again, also during this process, a huge number of cells, we're talking about 10,000, 100,000 of cells are stored for a long, long time. This could be up to 3 or 4 weeks in a high base storage area. And within this process, step, the cells undergo different phases which are separated by temperature, so the cells undergo high temperature aging and normal temperature aging. Now we're coming to the hazards during this aging process. During this process, there is no real-time voltage and impedance measurement carried out, so a so-called thermal runaway might be difficult to detect. And obviously cells with previous damage may subsequently become conspicuous during the formation process, but there is still a low probability that a cell which has survived the formation process before will become conspicuous during the aging process step. And however, due to the very large quantity of cells, which I said before could be 100,000 and more. Uh, in the aging process, it still exists a considerable high fire risk in, in, in this step. So there is also appropriate actions needed to be taken. OK. So within this, this self-finishing process, you described then, um, two specific steps, and thank you for that, that deep dive because I think it's an important step of this conversation. Uh, there's the the battery formation, and I, I like your description. This is when the battery first comes to life. And it's the first time that battery is charged and discharged, uh, higher space of risk, uh, because this is really the first time that any manufacturing issues could come up. Um, and then you have the aging process where, uh, after a cell has gone through this formation process, it's then stored over a certain amount of time, and, and in both these stages like you described, we have a lot of cells in close proximity, so if we have a challenge with one, we, we risk that issue. Moving forward, uh, whatever it might be, uh, you mentioned a phrase there, thermal runaway, uh, what does thermal runaway mean? Um, thermal runaway is a very common expression, uh, in this kind of field. Battery cell production, um, and it's, uh, also, uh, the most fundamental and most important, let's say, most critical, uh, hazard. So thermal runaway, um, is, uh, an exothermic chain reaction. That starts when the heat generated within a battery or battery cell exceeds the amount of heat that is dissipated to its surroundings. So if the cause of excessive heat duration is not remedied, the condition will worsen and worsen and worsen. So in general, battery temperature will continue to rise, causing battery current to rise, causing temperature to rise. That's why it's called a kind of a domino effect. Which can at the end lead to catastrophic results such as fire, explosion, sudden system failure, costly damage to equipment, and possibly personal injury. So the rise in temperature in a single battery cell will begin to affect other cells in close proximity, and this, let's say, pattern will continue. Um, that's the term runaway. So, the expression term will runaway. Perfect. Thank you, thank you for that, because I think, uh, anyhow, very shortly, Emily, we'll talk in a little bit more detail about, about what we can then do about this if we ever find ourselves in that situation. But I think it's an important one, as you say, because it is relatively unique to this, to this industry, uh, and the, and the, the chemical reactions and, and risks that are synonymous with it. Um, Manuel, if, if I was someone in the industry looking to build one of these gigafactories, so I, I would, I had the goal to go and, go ahead and do this, you just described some really significant risks that, that not just risk the quality of the product which is then finally delivered, but actually, you know, the whole production process and the safety of those people involved in that. How do I go about this? If I was building one of these factories, how would I go about addressing these risks? Yeah, well, let's start first with the conventional, let's say, fire safety, um, existing, there are existing a lot of generally very clear regulations to ensure the safe and, and qualified fire protection. But for the lip cell production, there are currently no codes and standards available or protection concepts. Uh, in regards of the fire protection measures. Uh, for this reason, we, we were collaborating or we collaborated, uh, on a technical report together. Uh, it was us as to suit and, and you, um, S Siemens, uh, with co-production of the University of Aachen. And this technical report. Should be um seen as a general guideline for uh fire protection strategies uh in the field of lips cell production. So, based on, let's deep dive a little bit into the, the topics or the content of the technical report, um, based on a generic description of the different production process steps which I mentioned just before or highlighted the two steps during the self-finishing. We just described the hazards and allocated the hazards to each of the process steps. So we identified 16 process steps, um, and then with the help of an appropriate risk assessment, the risks are allocated to the hazards described before or the hazard to the risks. These two words are linked to each other. So, um, and then on the basis of this risk evaluation, the, the best fitting fire protection measures for mitigating this risks are defined and described to present a thorough and generic solution with respect to the structural, um, technical, and organizational fire protection. Understand, so. So for normal fire protection we have a lot of regulations, we have a lot of expectations that are set by the industry on how to best protect. We're not quite to that point yet for for this specific industry, and this is why you described this this technical paper which, which we'll look into in a little bit in some more detail. What are the benefits of taking this approach, of taking a risk-based fire protection approach? Yeah. So, generally, the codes and standards which are implemented for, for fire protection measures, they, they cannot be applied entirely case or plant specifically, uh, which means there is always a potential of over fulfilling the fire protection measures in regards of the specific plant. And by using a, a risk-based fire protection strategy, um, the costs during planning and implementation of, of fire protection measures can be minimized considerably, um, as is, this is the most efficient and effective tool in, uh, so-called performance-based environment. Wonderful. Thank you very much for that. And Emily, thanks for sticking with us because we, um, Emily just took us on a great deep dive into Into the process, the specific steps within the, the manufacturing process that, that provide the, the, the most hazards, and then, you know, how those hazards are then, um, you know, connected together with the situation to create a bit of a risk assessment and the process that you've gone together also together, uh so your team and, and his team and the University of Aachen uh to create this report. Let, let's talk a little bit about um our reaction once, uh, you know, if we found ourselves in the situation of, uh, of a thermal runaway like we talked about before, um, you know, what can we do about it, what can we do from an extinguishing perspective to really manage a thermal runaway situation in a lithium-ion battery cell or in a manufacturing situation like this? So first of all, I, I hope that we have so good detectors installed that we would never end up in a thermal runaway to start with. But if we would end up having a, a problem, we on our side, we are proposing to use an inert gas solution because there is no extinguishing agent really that can stop a thermal runaway in this kind of applications. So you have to imagine like huge racks and there are quite big openings and it's, it's really about suppressing. Uh, the fire as much as possible and as Manuel talked about to remove the faulty cell or the burning cell away from that and put it into a safe zone with water and so on. But what we propose on our side is a nitrogen system. We know in the market right now that a lot of OEMs in this field are proposing a Norvi system with like a Norvic 1230 system, which is a chemical. We do not do that because it will have a lot of residues on the battery cells themselves. So we propose to suppress as much as possible with with a nitrogen system that will create an inertization and stopping the thermal one way to spread at least. And I'd like to, and thank you for that first point. Like, of course, detection is that first step, and and as best we can do this, this is, this is our first line of defense, let's call it, um. And then reaching, if we do reach the point where we do have a thermal runaway, keeping it as much contained as possible until we have the chance to physically distance, you know, the cells where this is occurring and get them away from the thousands of other cells that are in the racks in the, in the towers like Manuel described for us before. Is there things like a uniform approach, a standard approach, a standard methodology for fire safety being being created, at least here in Europe as an example, to address this kind of gap that we have in the current regulations and expectations? No, not really. The European, there's an industry association called Euro Alarm, and they're working on guidelines for this protection, but there is no formal legislation from the European Commission yet. OK. You can look at the EU directive, the machinery directive, if you consider these as machines, of course, and it needs to be safely operated, but I would, for example, propose a water extinguishing system. They're not so so for the machines, yes, but not for the safe operation and the process which we are aiming at. Understand, which, which brings me back again to the report and one of the main reasons we're having this conversation is, you know, that we have an industry that's expanding so quickly. We have an application which is, is in huge demand but is 100%. Going from something we didn't hear about or wasn't really part of what we were doing here in Europe, at least on a scale 10 years ago, and now one of the biggest things which is happening in the industry, that we need to ensure that as an industry we have the awareness and we have some understandings and we share that best practice so that we can build the most futureproof and safe and and capable factories moving forward. And this is one of the main reasons, or one of the many reasons I'm sure that Tifsud, Siemens and the University of Aachen worked on this technical paper and the white paper that goes along with the technical report, sorry. Where can we find these, Emily, if we were looking, you know, a listener here wants to know more, and there's a huge amount of detail and technical information like Manuel mentioned before in the technical reports and some, some information also in that white paper. How, how would I go and find this? Where would I search and what would I search for to find these, this technical report in the white paper? So, um, I think Manuel needs to answer for TISI, but from Siemens side, I think the easiest way is to go to Siemens.com/battery, and they will get to, uh, um, page gathering information about everything that Siemens do when it comes to battery production, and they just type, contact me and write, I want the report. That's the absolute easiest way. Yeah, the same for the suit. Uh, we also created a landing page, uh, where you can find the report and the, um, white paper. And also, uh, you can listen to a virtual conference that, uh, took place in June. Um, so, where also a Siemens was involved. …

Full transcript (WebVTT)