#153 Smart buildings: A system of systems
Show notes
Tune in with Matthew Silvester from Meinhardt Thailand Ltd, and Jon Lester! In this episode we deep dive into different views on smart buildings and their contribution to a more sustainable world today and in the future. Learn what features really increase the value creation for building occupants, tenants, and landlords and what role certifications play, especially in the Asian market.
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name's John Lester, and in today's episode, we're talking about smart buildings, making real those smart building dreams and really what is behind it. What happens in the real world, what happens out there in the industry when we talk about smart buildings and actually trying to deliver them to our customers. I'm joined today by Matt Sylvester. He's a director at Mind Hutt in Thailand. I'm really excited about him joining us from this part of the world and to really give us some insight into the region. Matt, thanks so much for joining us. OK, thank you, John, pleasure to be here. Uh, it's a pleasure for us to have you as well. Uh, let's dive straight in. Like we, we're talking today about smart buildings. Smart buildings is somehow a term that means a million things to a million different people. So let's start there. What's a smart building and how do you define that? Smart build, it's a, it's a good question. It's probably my favorite one. exactly. It means, uh, if you ask 10 different people, um, in the industry, developers, designers, uh, consultants, they'll all give you a different answer what a, what a smart building is. Um, you know, I mean, uh, my, my favorite, uh, kind of engineering speak is that, uh, a smart building is a, a system of systems. Um, you know, you've got a, you've, in a typical building, you've got lighting systems, you've got access control systems, you've got ventilation, air conditioning systems. And um they don't really talk to each other. Um, you have, you have a controller or an operator that controls them individually but not as one. Um, so a system of systems would be when you have some kind of, uh, an AI or some kind of management system that would, that would allow these systems to talk to each other and, and optimize, optimize those systems and then bringing it one step forward to making a, a better user experience. So, uh, you know, making, making information available to people so they know the, the environment they're in. But I mean, that's a very, a very broad sort of view of what Smart might be. Um, some people think that smart buildings should be like the Starship Enterprise. Um, and some people think that having, uh, face recognition on their access control system is smart. So, um, really it's how long is a piece of string. Um, but, um, I mean, there, there's a new, there's a new system of, of certification coming out which, uh, here at Meinhardt Thailand, um, and in Thailand actually, in general, there's this new certification system coming out which is similar to, to like LEED or, or these other building certification systems which levels the playing field a bit. Um, so we're, we're excited to see that coming on stream. Um, and it, it brings into, it brings into, into question what is a smart building. Um, and smart is not just about the technology. It's about, um, how you, how user friendly is a building. Is it smart for people? Is it intuitive? And this, this new certification system is, is great for that. Um, yeah, I mean, should, should I plug them? Uh, WiredScore, SmartScore. Um, they're, they're doing this system as I say, we're, uh, we're quite excited about that because it really starts to put a framework on what's smart. Is and should be, yeah, absolutely, and, and in the end, if we take a step back and we, we talk about what are we trying to achieve, what, what's the, what's the point of a smart building in inverted commas, um, you know, it's not supposed to be smart for smart's sake, it's supposed to be smart so that we can operate it better, so it's better for the people that use it, so it's, it's more intuitive to deliver the, the expectations, the function that it's supposed to do, and, and that's exactly what you're talking about, and, and maybe give me a little insight because. Certification is, is one of those big steps as an industry whenever new technologies or new expectations come along, certification, regulation, whatever it might be, some way for us to, to take a step back and, and make a very complex, uh, and multifaceted topic, uh, easier to understand with a, you know, with a lead score, with a wide score, with a, a, a fit well score, something like this. So from your perspective, you say you're excited about that. How, how do you see that, uh, finding traction in the market? I, is that something that you and other, uh, colleagues across different companies across different parts of the industry are also getting their teeth into? Um, for sure, yeah. I mean, we're, we're, we're an early adopter. Um, it's, uh, the, the, the, the certification system in Thailand is, is being rolled out. It's the, it's being launched in February or March of next year. Um, I believe that's the launch date. I mean, it's been up and running in, in the UK, in the US, um, maybe in Australia, I'm not sure. Um, but it's been up and running in, in several, um, other, other geographies for, for quite a while and they've got several 100 buildings certified and so on. Um. I mean, here in, in Thailand, I mean, a couple of our key clients have expressed interest in this, um, particularly, uh, office landlords. Um, you know, it's, it's, it's a, it's another way to differentiate their buildings. Uh, you know, 10 years ago, um, 10 years ago in Thailand, about 1012 years ago in Thailand, LED was a new thing. Um, everybody wanted a sustainable building. But no one knew exactly what it was. Um, you know, because it was a new thing and you know, people like, oh, solar panels, that makes a sustainable building. Well, not really. That's a, a small, this is one piece of the puzzle. It's a small part of it. Um, and similarly, yeah, it's, um, it, it's good here for landlords to be able to benchmark their property and be able to say we've got a gold standard smart building. Um, and it, it kind of a, it, it, it sorts the wheat from the chaff. So, um, it, it will encourage, it will encourage landlords to actually invest a bit in the, in the smart tech and in the systems so they can get some recognition and, and, in a, in an indirect way, they can then monetize what they've, what they've invested in. Um, you know, the, the office market's very, uh, very competitive, especially in the, in the wake of COVID. Um, you know, lots of, uh, lots of big firms are downsizing and doing work from home on a part-time basis or on a full-time basis, and, you know, lots of our, lots of our blue chip clients are, are reducing their, their leasable space from 6000, 8000, 10,000 square meters and they're trimming it down to 2000 square meters. Um, you know, the, the workplace is becoming a, uh, a place of culture rather than a place of work, um, for, for many industries, maybe not for engineering. Um, we're still a very Um, hands-on integrated type of, type business. We need, we need that face to face contact, but many industries don't, you don't, you don't need us to perform your work, but you do need to form bonds and you do need to have a, a cultural, uh, uh, like a company culture. So I think smart buildings is a way to, it's, it's about attracting tenants. Um, but these days I think it's more about, um, attracting the tenant's staff. Um, because, you know, a, a tenant will only take a, a leasable space as big as he sees it. And if none of his staff want to come to work, well then there's no point in having a big office space. But um, if they can say, well, you know, we've got 200 people that want to come to work every day because they like the office culture, because they like, you know, this wonderful smart building that we, that we work out of, um, that attracts the staff to come in, which in turn means the, the tenant wants to, to take more space, which makes the landlord happy. Um, so it's, um, I think that's, that's, that's the way things are going. Yeah, absolutely, and, and I, I like that you brought in the, the conversation and the aspect there from the tenants and the tenants, the tenants staff, because that's where I'd like to go with the next question is. It is it's easy to say smart building and, and it's also easy for your clients, for developers, for builders out there to say, hey, I want a smart building, but if we peel back the phrase smart building, what do they actually want from your experience, what is it that they really need and they're actually going for when they say I want a smart building? Yeah, so I think that's the, the difficult thing that they actually don't know what they want. Um, I think, um, a, a lot of people aim a bit too high, um, and then there's, there's failure to launch or failure to deliver, um, or failure to operate and that kind of is perhaps putting a bit of a, a negative slant on the whole thing. Um, you know, we, we get, we get people. Expecting or asking things like, can you have, you know, in a, I'm referring to an office, an open plan office, we get people saying, can we have individual climate control for every person at their desk. Um, well, you could, but I would ask the question, do you really want that? Um, because, you know, you have an open plan area with 10 people sitting in, in close proximity and Suddenly, one guy wants to turn off the air con. um, and then the guy next to him says, no, it's too cold for me. I want to turn it down. And then one of the girls chimes in and says it was fine just as it was. Um, so instead of creating a more comfort, you, you might have increased thermal comfort for somebody, but then you've, you've created some Some sort of a micro conflict between employees because I don't want to sit next to that person. They, they turn the air con on too low. So I mean I think a lot of this, um, smart stuff that gets touted is, is unnecessary and it's probably counterproductive. Um, I mean, good things, uh, again, referring back to the idea of making the workplace attractive, um, you know, there's, there's some buildings emerging here in Bangkok. One of our, one of our recent projects is, is quite smart, should we say. Um, You, it's, it's the, it's the whole journey experience, the arrival experience. You, you arrive at the, at the building reception, um, and the, the receptionist will ask you, um, you know, who are you meeting today? Uh, what time is your meeting? and then she takes your photograph. And once, once your photograph is on the system, then they know who you are. They know where you are in the building and the system is fully automated from there on in. So you, you go To a turnstile and the turnstile tells you proceed to elevator F. You go to elevator F and it automatically sends you to the 10th floor and you get out of the elevator on the 10th floor and there's a big LCD screen and it says, Welcome, Matt. You're here to meet John. Um, you're at meeting room 4 on the left and it's like, oh wow. So it's all this kind of um virtual future, uh, futuristic experience. Um, You know, I mean, there's, there's an element there of do you really want to be greeted by a machine. Um, but nonetheless, it is a bit, uh, it is a bit wild for people. It is impressive when you, when you walk into that kind of building. You feel like you're in a, you feel like you're in a modern building. Um, so those kind of, I think those audio visual experience, access control, experience, journey management, I think they're, they're the low lying fruit and they're the most, um, the most Immediately recognizable features. Um, I mean, there are other features as well. I mean, uh, I think actually, uh, one of the, I spoke to a, to a guy at Siemens and he, he was explaining how in, in Singapore they've, they've linked up one of their, uh, one of the buildings has linked up the, the access control system to, to count how many staff are in a building at any given time. Um, and they share that information with the, the, the F&B vendors. Um, so the F&B vendor can then start to forecast, right, today is going to be a busy day. I need to prepare 50 ham sandwiches. Um, and then when people come to get their food, the food is there and ready. Um, otherwise he's wondering how many should I prepare today? 1020, and he makes 10 sandwiches and then 50 people come and they're disappointed or conversely he makes 50 and only 10 people come and there's high wastage. So, um, there's, there's that second level of, of smart which is more on the analytics side which is less um less glamorous. So, um, typically when, when clients are coming in that's, that's not what they're asking for. Maybe less glamorous, but it, it comes back to what you mentioned at the start, what's a smart building, and it's a system of systems, and it's sharing information between them and trying to find good ways to make decisions with the information that's already available. And, and maybe one of the good things, and, and, and one of the interesting things that I also often have when we have these conversations is that That information's been available for a long time. It's just we haven't been very good at using it. So it's, it's taking that next step and getting connected and, and going through and, and, and then you do get to that kind of the more future experience like you described, that this guided experience that, that recognizes who you are, what you're doing, where you're going, and uses the building to, to improve that process compared to someone who would normally walk around, you know, a little bit lost, a little bit confused and have to ask people and stop people along the way. That's, that's a great example, and, and maybe I'll, I'll trouble you for a few more because I think the use case is a really interesting one. when you're having these conversations, when you're, when you're planning and, and designing these, these smart buildings, what are some of the other applications that you see regularly, that you see as, as the really valuable ones, the, the, the clear demonstrations, let's call it, of why a smart building has value, why it's, why it's useful for us. Yeah, I mean I think um my, my, I suppose uh that's, that's one of those questions, different, different opinions, but my uh my opinion on things, I think um CCTV access control, um there's a lot of smarts can be uh attached to that. Um whether it's crowd management, um, you know, we're all coming out of the, the COVID era. Uh, when there was a You know, panic and hysteria that, oh, there's too many people clustered in this area. And you know, you can use smart CCTV cameras to alert security guards, um, to say, look, you know, there's a, there's a crowd forming, um, near the Starbucks and you know, that's, that's not healthy. It's not in line with our COVID protocols. Um, similarly, uh, you know, if there's a, a protest or some kind of, um, some kind of disturbance gathering, um, the cameras will notice that there's an unusually high number of people in this area and alert the building managers. Um, I think the, the whole contactless, um, contactless entry to buildings, facial recognition, um, and journey management, again, I think that's, that's one of the, the good things. Um, I mean, again, I may I think COVID is, is one of the things that's fresh in our mind. Um, so it's a, you know, and before COVID there was something else and there was something else. There will be something in the future. Um, so having, having a building wired to be able to adapt and uh be able to be somewhat responsive to, to various situations is always going to be a, a positive thing. Um, you know, I mean you can, you can, you can use it as well from an energy efficiency point of view. Um, you know, there's, there's CO2, CO2 sensors is the, is, is now almost an old fashioned way of, of, of monitoring air quality. Um, but you can see, you can, you can plug that into a Smart. Um, you can cross link that with again with CCTV and with, uh, with, you know, visual, visual crowd counting, that type of thing to, to, to not just understand how many people you have now, but to, you, you, you can use smart analytics to, to forecast, um, you know, typically on Tuesdays, the building is more busy than Wednesdays. So the chillers will come on 10 minutes earlier to get ready for the cooling load. Um, it won't be right all the time, but it's right most of the time. Um, and then conversely, I mean, lots of people are concerned about, uh, monitoring when people arrive. Um, if you're talking about energy efficiency, you should be more concerned about when they leave. Um, you know, when someone leaves, when someone leaves their desk or someone shuts down their retail stand or whatever, um, if the, if the, if the building system can recognize that, OK, people are gone, let's turn the systems off. Let's turn down the air conditioning. Let's turn off the lights. That's where you're going to start getting energy savings. Um, Yeah, I mean there's, there's, there's lots of ways you can, you can optimize things. Car parking spaces, you know, AI systems can learn when they're busy directing people. I mean, the car park management system is quite a, it's quite a, it's a well-worn path that's been in place for God, 1520 years maybe. Um, you know, little, little lights over the car parking spaces and um and uh a little screen as you drive in to say go to level 4. that's a, that's part of it. But I mean you can take it one step further and, and book apps. You can try and get apps on your phone. Uh, you know, booking a car parking space and that type of thing. Um, I think that's probably Go again create a bit of conflict when two people say they've booked the same space. But um you know, at the same time it's not, I want to go to the office this afternoon. I wonder um I wonder should I drive or should I take the, should I take the bus or should I take the train? And you can have a look and say, oh look, it's really busy. I'm not going to park so I'll take the train. Um, that kind of information is, is very useful to people. It's tangible information and it's not um it's not technology for technology's sake. It's actually useful. Yeah, and, and, and I think that's a great way to summarize, you know, it, it's, it's technology and information put in the hands of people when they can use it to make simple decisions. And sometimes those simple decisions have, have large impact, like you mentioned, if a restaurant shuts down, turning off the lights, turning off the air conditioning, turning off the mechanical services, uh, whether it's a public holiday and maybe something, somebody hasn't programmed it into the system, uh, knowing who is where and what, and, and still saving that energy, or like you mentioned. Jumping in the car or deciding to jump in the car when you're gonna pop to the office and having an understanding of how busy is it. Or nowadays, like you mentioned, a lot of officers are going from 10,000, 8000 square meters to 2000, uh, making, having an idea is there even gonna be a desk for me if I show up into the office, and, and then does that help me make the decision whether I, I make the trip to the office or not. Just having that information is, is an interesting one. Um, when we talk about, when we talk about energy saving, because in the end, especially when we're talking about mechanical services, lighting, uh, talking about sustainability, uh, a lot of these pieces of information, sharing the knowledge, the insight across different systems helps us be more sustainable. Heaps, helps us to, to not invest energy into things that are not required, helps us to turn things on, turn things off at the right times, um. And this links back to this, this environmental drive, the sustainability drive, the governments and regulation drive, this ESG world. …