#111 What is the Grid Edge?

Buildings of Tomorrow ยท

Show notes

This week, Buildings of Tomorrow gives you all the information you need to know what the Grid Edge is and the impact it can have on energy transition. Tune in!

Transcript

Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name is John Lester, and in today's episode we are talking about the grid edge. I'm joined today by Sabina Ellinghagen. She is the CEO of Digital Grid at Siemens Smart-Infrastructure. Sabina, thank you for joining us. Thank you, John, for having me. It's an absolute pleasure. So we're talking about Grid Edge, uh, we're talking about the impact that Grid Edge can have on our energy transition. Uh, let's start at the very beginning. What is the grid Edge? Good question. Um, the grid edge in our terminology is in traditional terms where the energy is consumed. So, the meter or behind the meter, um, so really the edges of the grid if you want, um. Why that is these days so interesting is because obviously consumers are not only consumers these days, but everyone has a PV, a storage. In the future, many e-cars are around, so that grid edge becomes much more complex, much more lively, and it's not about only consuming, it's also about producing, by storing, and unusual places for the grid, at least. Yeah, and I guess that's the huge shift that we've seen, isn't it, that that centralized model, let's call it, that was always how grids were designed, has slowly but surely been shifted, has slowly but surely evolved, and now we find ourselves at a state where, where it's almost the not the exception to the rule, but the rule that there is, you mentioned PV, so, so solar generation or these other aspects that come into this grid edge space. Why is it so important? Why have we found ourselves in this position where these additional components, these consumers and prosumers and different roles of people have become so prevalent? What's driving this? I mean what's driving it, it's pretty easy. It's the energy transition, right? And I think why we think it already is the new normal, in essence, it's just the beginning. So when we look at the projections, we see a 7. fold increase of decentralized energy resources coming onto the grid. So really what we think like wow, there's so much solar, at least here in Bavaria on the roofs already, then it really is just the beginning and that. That that 7 times growth is really a revolution that is still upcoming and very exciting, uh, exciting thing. And it's a revolution that's not only upcoming, it must come because the energy transition, if we want to achieve it, if we want to, uh, achieve, like a, a serious measure against climate change, then, um, you must get to those levels of 7 times what we have today. Um, and, um, it really is also the fastest way for the energy transition to happen. Yeah, and I, and I like one of the points you said there is that it's, it's not that it's a nice thing to have. This is something that we must have. And, and it's not that 7 times is, is 7 times growth even fast enough, or do we need to be faster? Absolutely agreed, and I think the interesting thing is it's like swarm intelligence, right? It is many different small places where things can happen and where things can accelerate extremely fast. If you look at how fast the switch from conventional mobile phones to smartphones happened, I mean this was within a year or two, almost the entire population had changed, so that was also. very many independent decisions of independent, um, entities that, that made that extreme pace happening. And that's really what excites me about the grid edge so much is that for the, for the good of the energy transition, we can make that happen, um, and really accelerate that path, um, maybe to even unthinkable, um, speed. And I like the analogy as well because there's something to say for this evolution or revolution also being technology driven because that all of these, these new independent, you know, generation and storage spaces, they need to be controlled. They need to work in harmony, they need to be connected and integrated effectively, and this has to be driven by available technology. Absolutely, and I mean if we weren't at the stage with the internet with AI technologies and so forth that we are now, I would be scared of that pace and about blackouts and that being something uncontrollable or a waste of resource because then you build a dir and decentral energy resource and you can't really use it because it because it can't be connected to the grid. Um, so technology plays a huge role in there, um, to control that, to manage that, to commercialize it, um, you're spot on. Yeah, and, and that's another interesting part which I'd like to touch on because you know you talked about the connection, uh, you talked about the commercialization of it. How important is that commercial conversation when we're talking about these distributed energy resources orDOUOuvres like you mentioned. It, how big a piece of that, of the conversation is that commercial viability? Uh, a very, very big one. I mean, ideally, if you want independent, um, entities like a university, like a hospital, like Any other industrial campus or um also larger, um, larger residential spaces. If you want them to take that decision, it must be two things. It must be A, easy, And be worthwhile because if it's not easy, I mean all of these uh the investors or builders, they're not experts in, in energy, right? They're not experts in PV and solar in storage in trading in. Whatever, um, so it must be extremely easy for not to have like search costs and it really be a lengthy, complicated process. And the second thing, it must be worthwhile. I mean, everybody will calculate the return on invest of such an investment and And so the availability of markets is really where the rubber hits the roads. So if I can guarantee that I can achieve a good return on investment by trading my flexibility, by trading my kilowatt hours onto different markets, I can hedge my risks on that. And then it becomes a no brainer to do it. If I'm dependent on subsidies, if I'm not sure what the markets will be, if it's too few markets that might dry out, then my risk is too high, and you see that in Germany at the moment there was There were subsidies in. People did solar for the sake of subsidies, and then now the subsidies are running out, and there was nothing to replace it with. So we were in a situation where people were thinking about deinstalling their solar panels because it was just no longer viable to have them, and that's the worst case, really. Yeah, I can imagine this is the worst case scenario because if we want to be fast like you described before and we want to, we want to ensure that this revolution happens so we can try and reach some of the goals that we have because we know that global warming is here. We know that not only do we have to slow down, but we have to stop and go backwards. If anything, we can't afford to take two steps forward and one step back or we won't get there. Uh, you mentioned two things there, making it easy and making it viable. And then you also touched on something around subsidies. Let's get into that in a second, but maybe we can go into a little bit more depth around, around ease and, and viability, just so that, so that we can understand a little bit more and the listeners can get a bit of insight because like you mentioned, the If we're talking about a university who want to to have one of these distributed energy resources, they're not an energy retailer, they're not a utility. How can we, what do we need to do to make it easy enough so that individual, uh, individuals or institutions can invest in these kinds of resources? I mean, ideally you're looking for a one-stop shop, right? So you call a number and um or go to a website and You, you basically have it all thought through for yourself. So from where do I, like, what is it worthwhile, what's the calculation? How large is the invest? How do I get the financing right? Um, that's a huge thing um where also we now offer new solutions ourselves because we saw that as a really big. hurdle to get not an initial invest and then a long payback but get that right. How do I get then the installer? How do I get it installed? How do I connect it to a market and if you look at cases in Finland there you have a large shopping mall called Sello. And with them we we really put it all into 11 stop. So it's about connecting from the building, the technology to the market and really optimizing whether it's self-consumption, whether it's trading, whether it's storage, so the one. Stop shop, uh, be it online or be it just the the trusted partner that you can call, um, really is, is the ease, um, that, that it requires that we're looking for. And, and, you know, you're just speaking through all those different decisions, it highlights that this is not simple, you know, it's not as simple as putting, uh, solar panels, putting PV on your roof and plugging it in and walking away. There is so much more that comes through the process that's required. You, you touched on a couple of, of, uh, of examples there and, and actually had a, a, a specific example with Solow Shopping Center that around trading and self-consumption and these kinds of things, these sound like business models and I guess this fits into that second point which you mentioned, which is viability and the different business models that are possible to make these investments viable. Exactly, and the thing is you need to have predictive capabilities in order to understand whether it's viable or not. You need to be able to predict how much kilowatt hours do I self consume, how much would I store, how much would I feed back into the grid, what would be the price points for The feeding back into the grid. How can I on top um trade flexibility? Flexibility helping grid congestion, helping, um, grid stability and, and so forth. Um, so all these different uh revenue models if you want, um, are layered on or cost saving models are layered on. One on top of the other and, um, sometimes you can't do both at a time, um, so you need to decide which one is, is worthwhile. So you need to have sophisticated tools, a lot of, um, algorithms, uh, to be able to predict that, um, in the first place to make that investment decision. And the second thing is Then you need to operationalize it. So when it happens on the spot, the system in an autonomous way needs to take the right decision for you every second of the day. And that's a huge undertaking, isn't it? And this is where that technology comes in to be able to swap from self-consumption to trading back to storage and vice versa every second of the day has to be facilitated. Like you said, you have to operationalize this with automated technology, and that's a huge undertaking. I think the interesting thing and where we optimize with our technology. is to optimize for the technical feasibility, so the physics of it, right? You need to get those right because we're still talking electricity and on the other side, the monetary aspect. So you don't want to break anything or create a break uh blackout or something. So that physics side of things you get, got to get that right and you don't want to degrade your battery unnecessarily. Da da da. And, and on the other side, you want to optimize for, uh, for the financial return and you want to keep the, the CO2 uh balance in uh in place. So it's three different uh things that you want to optimize for, um, and, and that's really where, where we invest a lot of, um, thought into getting that right for our clients as well. Yeah, and it's, it's almost the magicians spinning plates, isn't it, to try and keep the perfect balance between these three is, is, is certainly no mean feat. You mentioned flexibility, and, and maybe we jump back a little bit to, to, you know, what's driving this revolution and, and how does, how do these new energy resources. Interact and cooperate with more of the traditional centralized resources, is flexibility, that driving force, is that one of the key value propositions that this distributed approach brings to, to the energy market? Absolutely, it's, it's a key part of that value proposition because I mean, uh, in, in the past, um, the grid was considered a copper plate. Copper plate means it's regardless of where you feed in um a given amount of energy or and It's regardless of where you take it out. Uh, with those grid edge DUI, uh, installations, um, it's no longer the case. So flexibility on not only keeping the copper plate a copper plate, but really Making that um location dependent on, on which feeder of the grid is what's happening? Am I overloading a transformer, how can I balance the, the intermittency of the renewable energy resources. Um, is a much, much more difficult undertaking, and the role of the DS, also the distribution system operator, will change greatly, and their task is really unthinkable, complex in the future. And again, here we are back to the technology topic, right? So without technology, just a human brain. I can't, I can't imagine a guy with a hard hat sitting with a lot of sweatshirts, you know, chopping and changing, depending, and, and maybe that brings us back to that initial point, which is why, you know, why is the grid edge and the, the thought process and the technology behind it so important or essential for this revolution? It just can't happen without the grid edge. Now, uh We've gone into the two points that you mentioned, you know, if we're going to make this revolution happen and if we're going to make it to be fast, we need independent organizations to take the leap, you know, to invest and go through the process, and for them to do that, it needs to be easy, and we talked about the different processes that we have to enable for them. It needs to make sense fiscally as well. Um, you mentioned through those conversations, and you use an example actually of Germany where there were subsidies. Now the subsidies run out and this challenges the business model or the viability of the investment that has been made in the past. We talked about trading and markets. Some of this has to be at least enabled by governments. What is the, what is the government role in this, this whole process? Um, excellent point. I think you summarized it extremely well, and, uh, that is really the point that we haven't touched upon yet because the, the regulatory framework and the ability of, for instance, the DSO what roles can they take, um, is, is governed or regulated by by governments, uh, both on the national level as well as uh the supranational level like the EU's, um. It is something that that is super important, um, and At the and that that's maybe where the the pace is the slowest so you see that with the internet as well I think upload filters or whatnot, right, regulations is, uh, is always like a little bit slower than technology advancement, um. And here I think that that's the biggest thing to get the regulation right for those markets. If you think about the US, for instance, there's a great market in California happening where the influx of renewables has decreased significantly. because of that market being there, um, if you look at Europe, there are some countries, um, in the Nordics that are that are pretty advanced in that, um, there, and then it's a spotty picture. There are some really advanced countries, some not so advanced, and, um, the, I think for technology to play out its full force. Homogenization or standardization of such market approaches really helps because then you don't build something for one market and then the next one for this market and the next one for this market, but you can really invest into one technology that makes it happen for many markets, and here regulation and especially the EU can help. To have a common framework to have faster regulations and also help itself to get out of this subsidy game, right? Yeah, and as you mentioned, it's not the speed is essential and if the speed of the technology or the capabilities is, is throttled, let's call it like an upload limit for By this legislation, then our chances of being successful are are severely diminished, and, and this is something we have to avoid somehow. I would agree. So I just look at the time. Thank you so much for joining us. Maybe I'll pass to you for, for a quick summary. You know, we talked about Grid Edge and what it is. We talked about why it's so important for this this energy transition and then some of the key features or journeys we need to take as an industry and as a company. If if you were talking to a uh uh an institution, uh, a university, a uh shopping mall, uh, or a government, a local government, and you, and you have one sentence or one statement to say to them, to say, listen, you know, this is, this is something you need to focus on, what, what would you say to them or what do you think's important for them to consider? I would just say it's worthwhile now and it's not. Green or um financially viable today it's both because the tipping point has been reached and it's It it's something that is worthwhile and you should be doing now. The thing is, let's, let us help you to make it easy. Perfect. I like it because now that tipping point is so important, right? It's no longer, you're no longer donating money to be green. It can, it can be green and viable at the same time, and that's a huge difference from a position that perhaps we were in 10 years, 20 years ago. Exactly. Amazing. Sabina, thank you so much for your time. Thank you. It was a pleasure, uh, discussing. Likewise, I hope it's not the last discussion we have because I feel like we've scratched the surface, but there's plenty more in, in this topic to, to talk about. Uh, thank you also to all those out there listening, please feel free to like, share, or comment on this episode. Ensure that you subscribe where you're listening or watching us, and keep an eye out because there will certainly be more episodes, but there will definitely be more episodes around the grid edge, uh, and how distributed energy resources can, you know, can be the vehicle for us to achieve these sustainability goals. So thank you, and we'll see you again soon.

Full transcript (WebVTT)