#169 Beyond Rip-and-Replace: A Strategic Approach to Building Modernization
Show notes
Outdated building systems aren't just inefficient; they lead to critical compliance gaps and significant security risks.
In this episode, Jon Lester, Siemens Smart Infrastructure Marketing Expert, shares insights from his research on why organizations struggle to keep pace despite the critical triggers pushing for it. He then unpacks why a strategic, stepwise approach isn't just faster, but the only way to move from reactive "rip-and-replace" emergencies to a proactive, planned future. Tune in to learn how to do Modernization right.
Transcript
Hello and welcome to the Buildings of Tomorrow podcast. My name is Hedger, and I'll be your host. Today we are diving into the increasingly important topic of building modernization. SES has recently conducted a market research to uncover valuable insights into modernization strategy, and with me to discuss the findings is John Lester, who brings a wealth of expertise on the subject. Hi John, how are you? Hey, Ajo, I'm well, thanks. And, uh, thanks so much for having me. I'm excited because normally I sit where you sit, but now I'm sitting on the other side, still behind a microphone, but I'm excited. Bring it on. John, uh, let's start with the basics. Um, what do we mean when we talk about building modernization? Explain it in plain language for our listeners. Yeah, absolutely. So when we talk about modernization, it's about, uh, upgrading and replacing the technology, the operational technology within a building and bringing in the, the latest and greatest, the, the, the most recent innovations that then start to deliver that additional functionality. So modernization is around changing and upgrading the building and its control systems to the latest systems. And give us a bit of context here as to this market research, what prompted it, and what were you looking to uncover? Yeah, so, I, like, modernization is, uh, uh, has always been a really important topic, uh, uh, across our industry, of course, uh, depending on the system, uh, you know, every 5 or 10 years, systems tend to need to, to require some kind of modernization. But one of the things that we see at the moment in the industry is, firstly, innovation and the adoption of technology across the building and construction industry is, is accelerating. So things are getting faster. That means the difference between technology today and 10 years ago is much, is much bigger than it was perhaps, you know, 10 years ago and the 10 years before that. So things are getting faster, technology is changing, the expectations and the requirements of customers are also changing. So, one of the reasons, while this has always been an important topic, uh, one of the reasons we wanted to do a bit more of a deep dive was firstly because of that speed and also with that speed, the whole industry, Is struggling a little bit more to understand how do we do this well, how do we bring those new technologies in, what should we consider and, and how do we manage that, and that's a really interesting and important topic for us to, to kind of facilitate and understand at a deeper level. Mhm. Indeed, it's taking a lot of um. Of of the limelight out there and, but when we talk about the risks, right, we hear more about it and uh, but there are also risks of not modernizing, right? What are those? Yeah, and, and, and let's talk a little bit about why would you modernize. So of course it's not, it's not just the latest bells and whistles, it's not the, the just new functionality because of course, uh, all the systems that we've had within the industry over the last decades are all quite capable, um. You know that those risks continue, so there's operational risks, uh, you know, protecting the continuity of your operation, you need to make sure that the systems you have are, are maintainable, that you can get spare parts, that you can find expertise in the industry that can support those systems, um. The, and, and those operational risks kind of expand more and more, as I said, as connectivity becomes more, more of a thing, uh, integration across systems is now standardized. Topics like cybersecurity, etc. start to become more important. So again, you go back 10 or 15 years, maybe cybersecurity was a consideration, but not really at the top of the list. Today we see that that's more and more important as we start to step into this next generation of, of technologies. So that's there, and then of course there's financial risk, there's, there's regulatory requirements, there's compliance, um, you know, uh, I take the example of the EU and you have some expectations around reporting your, your carbon footprint, your Scope 12, and 3 emissions, etc. Uh, systems from a decade ago weren't designed with those in mind. So you have those operational risks that you have to consider and then you have additional to that financial or or or, or compliance risks that you need to manage and modernization's a great way to kind of maintain and keep yourself in the right space for those areas. Mm, you mentioned um regulatory pressure. You mentioned also cybersecurity risks. You mentioned operational risks and I'm assuming also efficiency, the desire for building owners to have their building more efficient, but are there other events, other factors that trigger organization to take action and, and really start the modernization process or. Yeah, well, like you mentioned one there, so of course there, there's those, those risks of keeping the lights on, let's call it, uh, then, then of course you have those expectations. We know that we can operate buildings more effectively today with our latest technology, so there's additional benefits in energy savings, and operational savings, so there's, there's an upside to modernizing, not just minimizing risk. Um, so it's a little bit of that balance of, of minimizing that risk, finding and, and realizing those additional on top benefits and values, whether that's for the owner and operator of the building or the customers. Again, we know so much more now about controlling indoor air quality, delivering the right light, uh, level and, and, uh, warmth, um, delivering more seamless, uh, workflows and, and workspaces for people. New technologies, new systems that you would implement during a modernization process have more capabilities in this space as well, so, there's a lot of those triggers that, that go out there, of course, um, from a business perspective, they tend to be quite unique, you know, depending on the business, depending on the company, uh, the, and the goals that they're trying to achieve, there'll be different targets, but what we see from the research is certainly system, systems are expected to be more integrated. And, and, and that's a focus of a lot of our modern systems that wasn't such, uh, previously. So that drive for integration, that drive for, for data and data product, uh, and, and collecting that information and enabling other technologies is, is so much higher today, so it's one of those key drivers. Um, we talked about regulation, but it's not just regulation. When we talk about ESG and sustainability goals, also, a lot of companies have their own net zero goals, they have their own expectations and goals that they've set themselves. And it's difficult to achieve that with some of the technologies uh from yesterday. And then a, a, a whole list of those other things, depending on the customer. So, uh, is the maintenance cost too high or, or challenging? Are they getting the support from their vendors that they want today? Do they want, um, to, to find other suppliers that can maybe provide the, the service that they expect? Is the system even able to achieve what they're looking to achieve? Does the performance meet the expectations? And again, we touched on it before, but later, um, You know, labor shortage is a topic in general in our industry, uh, it's, it's harder and harder to find skilled labor, um, who, who really have the understanding of the mechanical and electrical systems, and the, the control systems that, that, uh, govern them, um. Not only that, if you're talking about a system that might be 15 or 20 years old, you also have to find someone who knows that system and, and understands how it work, how it works. And obviously the new, the new, uh, talent coming into our industry don't have that legacy, uh, capability and knowledge, so there's also that risk of, of bringing in newer technologies that come with all those benefits, that mitigate all those risks, but also then have the opportunity to be operated by the, the next generation of talent and skilled staff in our industry. That don't rely or don't uh hold the, the, the legacy knowledge that might be required for those older systems. Mhm. So it's a mix of uh of triggers, right? It's an internal pain point, uh, external pressure, as, as you just, uh, you've just explained. Yeah, absolutely. And, and, and it depends on those systems as well, you know, of course, uh, you, in a building, you have many different systems. You have a fire safety system, which is life critical. There's a lot of regulation that you need to comply with, and at the same time, those regulations don't change quickly. So, you might be OK, uh, if you have a fully functioning system from 10 years ago, and you might be OK for the next few years. But then other systems around ESG and sustainability, certainly without the, throughout the research, we found that those systems around energy management, Uh, and, and sustainability management, decarbonisation, reporting and, and insights. They're in a regulatory space that's changing really significantly and has changed really significantly over the last years. So, so they're the ones that are under the highest pressure, even though in many cases they might be some of the newer systems, they might only be 2 or 3 years old, but actually the landscape and uh that they're operating in has changed so much in those 2 or 3 years, the functionality still might not be there, and that drives modernization decisions. So, depending on the customer requirements and their goals, and then also depending on the individual system within the building. Those drivers, that balance that you talked about between operational risk, regulatory, uh, staffing and labor, etc. they all change, and, and that starts to move some systems to the top of the list and some systems further down. Exactly. I mean, I was about to ask you, is there a building system in particular that usually is most impacted by modernization? Yeah, it's tough. Like, I wouldn't say most impacted because all of them will need some kind of modernization eventually. But what we do see is that some systems are updated and modernized more often, and some less. So, I, I, I gave a few examples there. The, the fire safety systems we certainly see are modernized, have a longer life cycle, and modernized less regularly, uh, and, and that is sometimes 10 years plus. Uh, those sustainability, uh, and, and decarbonisation systems, ESG, energy management systems in this very dynamic kind of energy world, uh, are, are getting modernized more regularly, closer to 3 to 5 years. And in the middle, and, and one of the biggest sources of those risks and challenges around the building management, building automation systems, they tend to be in that 5 to, to 8 year phase. So, depending on the system, those things all shift and change, and then as, As the requirements around or or the challenges and risks around cybersecurity or energy, uh, you know, and regulatory compliance raise or fall, we see more, but that's certainly the trend that we're seeing in the market today. Mhm. You touched a bit on on risks and cybersecurity. I think it's obvious that modernization can help reduce these risks of cyberattacks. Can you tell us how and what systems are most vulnerable? Yeah, hey, like, cybersecurity is always a, is a tough topic because, uh, no one's system is cybersecure. It's about that really complete cybersecurity approach from a business, from a building perspective, and that, that goes from physical security and training the staff and the users of the building through to the actual technology itself. Uh, what I'd say in general is, is, uh, you know, we talked about some of the benefits that we see and, and the, the need for integration, and, and that need is, is absolutely growing and will continue to grow. So the expectation, no matter what the system is that integration is quite high. The data that systems create, they wanna share it across systems, they don't wanna be siloed, they don't wanna be disconnected, um, and that data is, is extremely important. For, you know, AI enabled systems, for, for, uh, common data environment use use cases, digital twins, etc. So, so certainly what we see in a general trend across all systems is the integration and the sharing of, of information and data between those systems has grown, and of course that comes with a, a, a, a, an expansion in, in kind of attack surface, in, in expansion of cybersecurity risk, but that goes hand in hand. So, so I wouldn't say that there's any particular system, so certainly that the, the more integrated, uh, the, the higher the risk and the more critical. So any system that is really critical to operation, and, and that comes then down to the use of the building, you know, is it a hospital, is it a data center, is it a manufacturing facility, all of those critical operations, uh, that have, uh, a serious impact on business continuity and business operation, then that risk is, is magnified, irregardless of the, of the system. But, but what I'd also say is that the, the capabilities and the understanding of cybersecurity and how we can better design systems, deploy systems, manage and maintain systems with cybersecurity in mind is also increasing. So the risks are growing, but also our capabilities and, and knowledge as an industry are also growing, and I think that um, again, uh maybe a, I, sometimes I forget it's 2026 already, but maybe you go back 20 years and cybersecurity wasn't, uh, wasn't a topic at the top of the list, it absolutely is now. Uh, and, and all of these systems, uh, whether it's through a modernization process or just a standard deployment, cybersecurity is always top of mind through the design, deployment, and, and, uh, maintenance process. Mhm. So it's clear the need to modernize is urgent, is necessary. Uh, that comes with it also a number of barriers, challenges, right? So we mentioned a few of them earlier, but what, what are the common blockers? Yeah, I, like, uh, it's a really good question, because I guess, uh, from the first half of the conversation, you'd say, oh, great, modernization's amazing, let's just modernize. But it's actually a really complex process. Um, when you compare modernization to, to installing a new system in a greenfield building, so when you're building a new building and you deploy new technology, here you have the opportunity to design everything from scratch, and you have, uh, all of the, the, the, the devices and all of the networks set up and, And all of the wiring and cabling and and uh network, network considerations, connectivity, etc. built into the design, baked into the design, so everything is, at least on day one, ideal for the systems as they're designed. Modernisation's different, of course, you've got buildings who are, that, that are, that are 1020, 50, 100 years old, and especially when you look in, In in in those older buildings, it's not so easy, uh, and in some cases it's not even allowed to, you know, to drill holes in the wall, to drag new wires, to, to, uh, to create, uh, you know, the new requirements, um, from, from a, a, a baseline perspective to deploy these new technologies. And, and that's just the actual deployment. Before you even start talking about undertaking modernization, there's a lot of understanding that you need to, to, to gather. You need to really understand what you have installed already today. What is that system, what does it do, how does it work, uh, who programmed it, how does the program work? Is the program fit for purpose, how many controllers and devices and, and, and, uh, different pieces of that system exist? Um, and then once you've understand that you've done that audit, then you have to start to talk about, OK, what is the goal of the future, what are we trying to achieve? How do we then go and achieve that? What's that gonna cost? What's the return on investment going, gonna look like? How do we get funding for that? How long is it gonna take? How's it gonna disrupt the people within the building? So that's another big thing, you know, you can imagine you've, you've got people working in an office and, and people are drilling holes in the roof. Uh, this doesn't facilitate the, the operation of the building itself, um, right through to then actually taking the, the action, making a decision and going through there. So, there's, there's a lot of challenges and barriers around. Around just the complexity of the procurement process, the, the long tail of, of preparation that we have within modernization projects. Uh, understanding and, and you can imagine through this long process, and I mentioned a few of those different phases, um, different stakeholders have different stake in the game, and at some point you, you are going to run into, uh, you know, your finance colleagues, your, your IT and technology colleagues who are all gonna have different questions about this modernization, how's this going to affect the system, you know, what considerations like cybersecurity have been taken, the finance colleagues are gonna want to understand. How much is this gonna cost, how much is this gonna cost ongoing, uh, what's the return on investment gonna be, and also there's, there's gonna be a lot of challenge because remember, the, you know, a lot of systems are still working to some extent when you undertake a modernization, so there's, there's a regular question that you get from, through that kind of uh finance and justification phase is, why do we need to spend this money, you know, what we have works fine, like uh what, what's the problem, why, why do we need to do this, so, So there's kind of this challenge of building a, a business case internally for the companies that drive modernization to help explain to those different stakeholders through the process, why do we modernize, what are the risks that we're, we're, we're addressing and we're trying to minimize or avert, um, what's the on top value that we can deliver, you know, what are the cost savings, operational savings, uh, energy savings that we can deliver or improve to, you know, user experience. Um, and then what's that, that return on investment and what's the disruption to, to daily business. So all of those questions have to be answered, and that's one of the biggest barriers. It's just painful. Um, or it can be painful, and, and, and that's one of those, those topics that makes a modernization conversation difficult and also what we see in the research is that that's one of the things that push people back from actually undertaking the process. They know they need to modernize. They know they've got problems. You know, these systems can't do what they want them to do, uh, they're struggling to get the service that they want, uh, they, they, they're, they've, they've got 100 manual workarounds that they've created to try and bridge the gap between what their system does today and what they actually need it to do on a daily basis. But undertaking the modernization process can be such a challenge that they, they put it off. It's a next year problem, it's the year after problem. And, and that's one of the big things that we see. So you see this disruption, you see the challenge, you see the, the risk that comes with it, the stakeholders, the need to really build that, that business plan or to build that really clear idea of return on investment and total cost of ownership of undertaking modernization. All of those things kind of create this wave or this, this, this barrier of, of entry. That then ultimately push modernization projects back. In the priority list. Um, and then of course what we see is it. Is the less time you have to actually modernize before an issue becomes critical, the worse it is. And, and I think, uh, you know, at some point we'll dive into a little bit of that. …