#152 Decision-making in wireless adoption projects

Buildings of Tomorrow ·

Show notes

Wireless technology is back with Michele Remonato! In the last two episodes, we uncovered the different types of wireless technologies available in the industry and how these are used within buildings. In this episode, we will dive into the decision-making aspect of adopting wireless, from the perspective of facility managers & buildings owners.

Transcript

Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name's John Lester, and in today's episode, we are talking about wireless technology for a facility manager or an owner of a building. Now, when are the right times to use it and what's the decision? What are some of the things that have to be considered when we're deciding against traditional wired technology and wireless? I'm really lucky today to be joined by Michela Remanato. He is the head of IOT devices at Siemens Smart-Infrastructure for product management. Michaela, thanks so much for joining us. Hi, John. Great to be back. Amazing, yeah, and, and thanks so much for joining us again, I'm excited. So we've had a, a, a previous conversation, we talked about different technologies, you know, you know, some of the areas where, where these technologies have, have advantages, technically, some different applications. Today we wanted to talk about making that decision. We have this technology available to us. If I'm a facility manager, an owner, an operator of a building, What are some of the situations, what are some of the pieces of information I need to make that decision, whether I go in a traditional route and, and use wired technology, or I go in the, in the wireless direction. So, so to start off with, give us a little bit of an introduction. What are some of the things that we need to, to think about, what are some of the, the, the topics that need to be considered, and, and give us a little bit of a highlight about some of those introductions about where wired and wireless sit within this scope. Absolutely. There are many facility managers and building operations companies that are already looking into wireless. There are also many that are moving their first steps today. So, um, the first step is really to understand that there is no one, fit all technology when we talk about wireless. And, um, the, the first question that we often get asked is where does it make sense to actually use wireless? So there are a lot of variables at play energy efficiency, installation cost, range, latency. So it can be a bit overwhelming, especially for a facility management company that is just getting started with wireless, to figure out when it does make sense. So let's start with, uh, first of all, some major indications. So for new build, uh, for new buildings, um, that's a space where often wireless is in very tight competition with wired technologies. Um, wired technologies tend to be cheaper on a hardware level because they have less complexity and they have better economies of scale as of today. And also there are. More trained installers and companies that can do the installation fast. So for new builds, um, it is very often the case where wireless tends to be less interesting. And I like to start from where it is less interesting because often we start from uh trying to selling it. Actually, I like to start from where does it make less sense as of today. So, in, in general terms, uh, new build tend to be less interesting, right? Nevertheless, there are huge opportunities because there are, most of the buildings today are built are already there. So, um, yeah, that's maybe a first step where to start. Understand. So, so in general, uh, you know, in those, in those new buildings, wired technology is what we know, it's what the industry's been doing for years. This is where we, we tend to find the, the, you know, the eco as you mentioned, the economies of scale, the different skill sets, the some of the complexity, um, makes wireless not the, the preferred solution. In these new builds, are there any situations or any applications where we see this, this balance shift a little bit, where we see wired kind of bring, you know, with its flexibility and these kinds of things, bring an additional value which outweighs the kind of traditional economies of scale. Yeah, that's a very interesting question. That's also where I really like, uh, uh, the idea of technology with purpose. So there is a space, a use case, uh, which is a thing becoming really popular where wireless makes a lot of sense also for new build, and that's the case when you have a frequent relayout. So let's imagine that you are a building owner and you invest in a commercial building. where you maybe have 2 year contracts and you want to relay out either offices or even shops and so you have a commercial building with multi-purpose and you have an interest to relay out frequently. And, uh, and, and you want to do that at scale, you want to do that efficiently, then wireless is definitely an extremely interesting solution. It reduces the, it reduces the complexity of wiring, right? So you can just move the devices around, um, and it reduces the amount of cable, that is in the building. Um, it also allows you to basically reach any corner of the building. And uh I think it fits very well also with uh the design companies, the architecture companies, the engineers, depending on who is managing the, the, the plants, the floor, floor plans to get creative. So I think it's a perfect example where wireless could also make sense uh for, for a, for a new build. And uh finally for the building owner, but also for the facility manager, there is um. A higher value per square meter of the building, there is less cost in doing the relay out. There is less cost in maintenance, and I think it's a very interesting space and we are seeing it more and more, not only in Europe but actually across the world. Yeah, right, so, so in those situations where the initial hardware cost, uh, you know, is not something that you can invest in and you're leaving this for 1020, 50 years, you expect things to change, you expect people and, and the function of the spaces to change regularly, uh, wireless sort of brings in that additional ability to, to support that use case, to support that functionality with its own flexibility, uh, backed up in the technology. Uh, that, that links really nicely and really closely to the kind of standard conversation or, or let's say the use case that we talk the most about with wireless, which is around retrofits, uh, where you, you have something existing and like you mentioned before, uh, you know, for every building we build, there's 100 buildings that already exist that, that also need new technology deployed into them. What are some of the key, uh, you know, situations, challenges, and, but, but also benefits that we can address with a retrofit leveraging this wireless technology? Yeah, I think retrofit basically in very practical terms means touching or changing something in an existing building that has already been designed, that has already been constructed, and where pretty much everything is already configured. So it's not so simple to bring in new devices, uh, for example, sensors, for example, uh, actuators. It could be a quite demanding task and it could also be quite invasive for the building, um. So, um, why would a company be interested in retrofit? Well, there are different reasons. First of all, uh, technology may be outdated, so there may be a new possibility to sense, for example, indoor air quality or to, um, collect data from meters or to do new use cases that were not possible in the past. And there may also be a regulation-driven use cases. So, uh, we saw that, for example, for indoor air quality, uh, during the COVID time, there was a wake-up call. Actually, there were many experts um across the world, uh, demanding more transparency for tenants and for, for the people living inside the building to have better, um, transparency on indoor air quality data. That was not really enforced by law, and now we see it. We see it in the US, we see it in China, we see it in Europe. So, uh, we can either use technology to do new things. We can do, we can use technology, wireless technology to comply with regulation. Finally, also adding value for the tenants. So there is a quite interesting space there. And finally, wireless devices are really easy to use. You can bring them in the building. You don't need to have any invasive measure, break walls or damage the property. And uh you can reach any corner of the building and so I think they are extremely practical and they also, um, are becoming more and more popular, uh, so there are more people that are understanding also the value that they generate. Yeah, and I think that's a, a big shift that we've seen in the market, you know, the more people are using this, more people are developing the skills. I think that the trust and the understanding of the technology is, is growing every day, and, and that's, it's kind of maybe the, the, the next step I'd like to dig that conversation, but before, you know, to understand then, because, because wireless is not just wireless, there's many things behind it, there's many different versions of, of, of technologies that are best for different applications. But before we get there, Uh, if I was a, a facility manager, a building owner, uh, uh, an operator who was trying to make this decision, because you mentioned earlier and, and in the use cases you just described, there are many different situations that could help make this decision for, for us. How would it influence the decision between going in a wireless technology wide technology approach? Yeah, so, as you correctly described, uh, there are a lot of variables at play. And, uh, wireless is, of course, a technology, so it's very easy to get into a very deep and detailed technology discussion from the, from the get-go. Um, the first recommendation is really to start from what is the business objective or what is the value that we want to create or finally, the problem that we want to solve. Um, is it for retrofit? Is it for relay, relayout? So, I think it should start from a, uh, from a business goal, from a value creation goal, and then we can work backwards towards the technology. And some of the key variables that, that we need to answer is Um, for example, what is the range that we need to cover? Range is the first most demanding variable around wireless. And the next one is, what do we actually want to do? Do we wanna monitor? Do we wanna actuate something so automate things? Uh, how much data is generated? And then, how, how does this data, uh, uh, relate between the different devices? Is there a central gateway or do we have an expectation that this network is extremely reliable? So, as you can see, there are a lot of variables at play. And then, um, very often we get asked, why isn't there one single solution? Well, there isn't a one fit all technology. We need to pick the technology starting again from, from, um, the business goal. And so, navigating these technologies can be overwhelming, but I think there are a lot of expertise, there are a lot of experts in Siemens. We do have a lot of experts on this. And we can help our customers, our partners to, to navigate, um, the complexity of the technology and of course, um, consult them to, to make the best choice. No, it's, it's a, it's a really good point that I'd love to highlight because as you say, IoT wireless, uh, you know, some of the, the different technologies behind this like, like Bluetooth and all the rest that we, it's so easy for us to dive into the technology, uh, into the solution, we might forget about what we're trying to achieve, and, and maybe here is some, somewhere a challenge that wireless has had in the past where people have thought, uh, you know, it's, it's difficult to have a retrofit or it's difficult for me to get a wire somewhere. I'll buy this wireless thing without thinking about what's required, what are some of the limitations like the range that you mentioned, what are some of the, the goals that I'm trying to achieve before I then actually go and pick the solution itself. Um, you, you mentioned there are a few things about range, about application, whether we're monitoring, whether we're trying to automate and really actuate and drive a building. Etc. uh, my, my thought is that our next episode should be a little bit about this because here we do dive into the technical, uh, and talk, we wanna talk about every single, uh, you know, or some of the, the big protocols and some of the big technologies that we're talking about here. So, so maybe that's our next discussion, but, but to close this one, you know, you, you mentioned that, the, you know, these different variables, these different considerations. If, if the building manager needs to know those end goals, if the building manager needs to start to think about that, where should they start? Uh, you know, is it, is it just functionality, or should they look at, they should they look at the, you know, the, the breadth and or the time that they're gonna be using this technology? How, what are your kind of final words for a facility manager or or a building owner making this decision that, that they can take into that, that thought process and that consideration before making this decision? Yeah, it's a very uh challenging question. So, let's try to break it down. I think there are 3 main, um, uh, points to look at. So, the first one, what are the most pressing problems where IUT can help, right? So, one of the key reasons why many IUT projects have failed in the past is because of a lack of focus. So I think identifying what are the problems that uh um is, is the key step, right? And sometimes IUT may not be the answer. I, I believe very often it will be, but it may not be all the time. So for example, for relayout, I think it's a very strong uh story or again, uh, for a retrofit it's also a very strong story, but let's start from the problem. That's the first one. The second is looking at what is the budget. Uh, what is the investment time horizon that the, that the, that, uh, the building owner has in mind? And, um, I think when we look at increasing value per square meter, making the building more flexible, then wireless adds definitely a lot of value, right? And, and the third one is looking at the total cost of ownership. So wireless is not just a piece of hardware that is installed in a building. It requires certain competencies for installation. It requires certain competencies for managing over time, right? But it provides us some value back, uh, as we discussed earlier. So to summarize, I would definitely focus on the problems of what are the key challenging pain points that the customer have, right? And bringing, bringing that to the table. I would try to understand better what are the budgets, the willingness to invest, um, and, and eventually also to get value per square meter for the building. And the third one is really looking at the total cost of ownership and that, whether that could fit, right? One of, a second reason why many AUT projects fail is also because the, the investment versus the cost is, is, uh, they're sort of not fitting between each other. And so that, that would be my recommendation to, to ensure that there is, uh, a good return on investment, uh, that creates value and it is sustainable over time. That, that's, uh, how I would suggest it. But of course, it's a complex problem and you always need help navigating it. Yeah, for sure. Especially in a space like this where things move so quickly, like uh, like everything uh you know, when we talk about IoT and things that are driven with these new technologies, we're able to leverage so much that happens around us, uh, not just within the industry, but it also means that we're fast and things change on a daily basis, so that, that support, that partnership, that conversation, that expertise is such an important part of the decision. Uh, Michaela, thanks so much for today, uh, a really great conversation, so, and really interesting. Uh, so thanks so much for joining us, it was a real pleasure. Thank you, it was also a pleasure for me and looking forward to the next one. Yeah, and the next one, I think, uh, you know, like we discussed, let, let's dive into some of those technologies. So for, for those out there who, who then wanna hear a little bit about, you know, what are some of these wireless protocols, what are some of these wireless technologies, where are they useful, where, you know, what are their strengths, what are their weaknesses and what applications do they fit the best with, that's gonna be the next conversation. Um, together with Michaela, so keep your eyes open, but until then, thank you so much for joining us, thank you so much, uh, for sitting with us for this conversation. Please remember to like, share, comment, subscribe wherever you're listening or watching this conversation, and always keep your eye out in every two weeks or so for the next conversation around buildings of tomorrow. So thank you, and we'll see you soon. See you soon.

Full transcript (WebVTT)