#149 Types of wireless technologies in the building industry

Buildings of Tomorrow ·

Show notes

Michele Remonato is back on the podcast with Jon Lester. After a first episode explaining how wireless is used in buildings, this episode focuses on the different types of wireless technologies available in the building industry and the wide range of applications where these technologies are being used. Tune in!

Transcript

Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name's John Lester, and today we are talking about wireless protocols, wireless technology, and all of the different types of protocols that sit within this wireless space. Why is that the case and what are some of the, the, Uh, the benefits and some of the, the applications where we see these technologies best used. I'm really happy and excited to be joined by Michela Remanato today. He is the head of IoT product management at Siemens Smart-Infrastructure. Michela, thanks for joining us. Hi John, great to be back. Hey, great to have you back as well. Um, in our last conversation, we, we took a little bit of a view around wireless technology from a facility manager, an owner, and operator's perspective, and started to, and we talked a little bit about, uh, you know, when, when is it the right time to choose wireless, when is it the right time to choose a more traditional wired technology, um, and part of that we talked a lot around, Uh, you're making this decision, there's lots of variables that need to, to be considered when you're choosing a technology, and if you decide to go wireless, there's a lot of decisions you have to make to choose what kind of wireless, cos wireless is not, uh, one size fits all, as I think you mentioned in that conversation, there's lots of different aspects and technologies that all sit under this umbrella of wireless. So, so give us an introduction before we dive into, cos we really want to get into some nitty gritty for some of these uh popular and well-known protocols around wireless, but give us a little bit of context. Um, what is the landscape and why is this the situation? Yeah, so, First of all, we could talk about wireless protocols for 2 days in a row and still be just at the very beginning of it. So let's try to bring some structure into the topic. There are a lot of variables at play, but uh, the first thing, most relevant variable is the range that you want to cover when you talk about wireless. So do you just want to cover a few 100 m, then normally you talk about short range, or do you wanna uh cover a much wider range, for example, kilometers, and then you talk about wide range. So for someone that is just moving the first steps into this world of wireless technologies, it is good to start, uh, breaking down the, uh, the problem into short range and wide range. And once we've made that decision, Uh, what's the next step? Like what do we do with it once we've, we've got a connection, once we've got a, a signal, let's call it? Yeah. So there are additional variables, of course, that come into play, and today we will try to navigate some of them. Uh, the first one is energy consumption, which is a very important topic, right? So, um, is the device that is actually connecting to this wireless network battery powered or is it main powered? How much energy does it consume to perform its functions? So that's one topic. Another topic is, um, what kind of latency. So how fast do you want to collect this data, right? There may be cases where every 15 minutes is fine. There may be cases where you want to do it in a millisecond. Another variable is how much data do you actually want to transmit. So, um, you have the range, you have the battery, or in general, the power consumption, you have the latency, and you have the throughput and how much data you want to consume. So these are some of the main variables at play. And again, uh, it's very easy to get into very deep technological discussions. There are a lot of people passionate about technology, but more from a customer point of view, uh, it's good to start from the end goal. What do you want, what are the problems that you want to solve, and then work backwards, um, towards what is the right technology, right? And so it's good to have different examples of different, uh, protocols, different standards, uh, that are out there today. And sort of how to navigate them, right? That's how normally we do it, especially if you are the, just move with the first steps into this world. Understands, and, and when we talk about problems and talk about you know, what are the, the issues that we're trying to solve with this technology, how, how quickly does that get to what we're trying to do, you know, whether it's a monitoring, whether it's a controlling, does that also build into this where you talked about how much information is sent, uh, battery life, uh, range, etc. is it how we're using the information and what happens at the other end, let's call it, that also helps us or, or is important for us to consider when we make these decisions? I think it's a very nice question. Actually, uh, I started by talking about the technology and let's move into talking about the problems. So, the first, uh, is really, um, do you, what is the end goal that you want to achieve? Uh, uh, do you want to monitor? Do you want to monitor and control something? And if you wanna do it, uh, to which kind of degree, uh, of, uh, quality do you want to do it? Uh, milliseconds, do we talk seconds, or do we talk minutes? There are then also other um uh problems to deal with. Are the devices fixed in a place or are they fixed, for example, to a wall, or are they moving, right? So these are the kind of problems that you have to look at. And then again, we look, as we discussed in the last uh session together, uh, whether we're talking about new build, we're talking about retrofit. So, um, this also has an impact in terms of power supply, in terms of what you can actually do in the building. So, I normally look at monitoring versus automation. I normally look at, um, um. Is it a new building? Is it a building that is already, uh, constructed and where basically there are limitations, um, and are the devices fixed in a place or are they moving around, right? These are some of the, uh, problem-centric questions that uh we normally ask. And then, of course, uh, different technologies have different qualities, um. Just to mention a few cybersecurity, uh, standardization, and, um, the wealth of devices available in different ecosystems, and we can talk about that uh when we did dive into the different uh protocols. Well, well, let's do it. So thanks for that summary because I think it's really important because the, like, like every technology, it's been developed to solve a problem, and this is one of the reasons why we have so many different technologies because we have so many different problems to solve. Some are, some are are short range, some are wide range, some are for monitoring, some are for controlling, some are to send large packets of information, some are for just small ones, so. So all those problems that you just described, all those variables that that uh you just introduced, you translate then into many different technologies. So let's, let's get deep, let's get deep in this, let's dive into, into some of the technologies and hey, exactly what you, you mentioned earlier. There's a heap heap of these, we could talk about wireless and technologies for days, uh, so we're not going to cover everything, that's not the intention or the goal today, but let's pick some of the, the, uh, let's call it the, the best-known ones, the most prolific ones, like you mentioned, uh, it's also an important thing, depending on your application, to know that there are lots of different devices available that help you achieve your ultimate goal. So let's talk about some of those, the, the ones that we would know the best, the ones that are most important, uh, at on a, you know, at the top of the list, let's call it. Um, you talked about short range, wide range, why don't we split it into this? So let's start with the short ranges, um. In the short range world, Uh, one of the ones we hear a lot about is Ziggby. Uh, give us a bit of an insight. What, what's Zygby, uh, where does it work, where, where are its benefits, and, and, and, you know, why is Ziggby as it is? Yeah, so ZIGB is a standard, uh, based technology, and, uh, again, I, I like to use examples. So, uh, while we go through the different protocols, I try to focus more on the use cases rather than the deep dive in the technology. I think there is already knowledge and, uh, data available online. So ZIGB is extremely popular, has become extremely popular, um, in the space of home automation. Uh, also in commercial buildings, uh, it's quite popular and even in some industrial applications. It has a quite rich ecosystem of devices that have been developed over time and it's basically a mesh technology for short range. So it means that the devices can connect between each other, so it provides a quite reliable network because you don't have a single point of failure. And it normally, uh, it normally, uh, covers, uh, a range between a few meters to 100 m or, or maybe a bit more. And, uh, it works quite well and reliably for this kind of use cases. It was, uh, started in the early 2000s and, um, it, it has grown in adoption because I think of its reliability. And also the quite wide range of devices available, so there are a lot of sensors, thermostats, controllers, lights, so there is a rich ecosystem. And it has grown into a standard, so it means it can be adopted across the board from different vendors, different companies, and I think that's also one of the strengths. And um Maybe also looking a bit at what is challenging with ZIGB. It is um challenging, uh, that you have to normally build a, a custom gate gateway or anyway, there isn't a very standardized gateway solution. So, uh, depending on, uh, the end goal, uh, different gateways may be necessary also to connect different devices. Um, so that's, that's one of the challenges. And the other challenges is that of course the technology has been around for a while, so there are now even better options which we can discuss later if time allows in terms of energy consumption, so the duration of the battery, uh, in terms of cybersecurity and in terms of, uh, yeah, in general IP based technologies. So there are more modern options coming up in the market, but still it's a very popular double digit. dominance in most of the wireless markets, so it's, it's a very popular solution. Perfect. Uh, hey, thanks for the explanation, I like that structure, absolutely, let's use applications and talk a little bit about the good stuff and, and some of the challenges for each of these. Uh, the next one I wanted to ask you about is one that we know really well, but, um, we, we probably know it more because of our phones and our headphones and this kind of stuff, and, and that's Bluetooth. How does Bluetooth fit in this wireless building technology, operational technology space, and where and when does this make sense for us? Yep. So Bluetooth is born, especially in the consumer space for, um, uh, connectivity for mobile phones and for transferring, um, small chunks of data. And, um, it's also a short-range technology. You can feel it. So if you connect your phone via Bluetooth, uh, just to transfer a file with one of your friends, uh, you, as soon as you walk away from your friend, the, uh, the transfer will not work after a certain distance. So, it was designed for that. It's a short-range technology. Uh, but now, uh, with the advent of Bluetooth low energy and other Bluetooth variants, it can also be used in commercial applications and especially in smaller spaces like rooms or floors, um, it can be used to track devices, to do real-time tracking of devices. It works quite well, and I think there are also different solutions already available commercially for commercial buildings. Uh, it's clear limitation is really the range, right? Uh, but of course, uh, it works quite well for real-time tracking and, um, it also has a very good latency like Zigby and, uh, here I also want to introduce the concept of latency. What does it mean latency? Uh, it's a measure, but for the user, what does it mean? Let's assume you are at home and, uh, normally your eye, your perception. Uh, when you trigger a command, let's say you turn on the light, is in milliseconds. So let's say you push a button and you would like that action to have almost immediate, uh, loop, um, towards you. So, uh, that's why short-range technologies with a very low latency are very, um, are, are, are very popular because they, they fit very well, especially when there is an end user, right? So ZIB and also, uh, Bluetooth, they have the strength, right? But again, range is weak. And also, when we talk, we talk about Bluetooth, there is limited amount of data that can actually be uh transmitted. So it does fit well, but especially for short range and sort of real-time tracking, um, uh, use cases. Cool. Hey, thanks, thanks for that explanation because it is something that we see more and more in those, in, in let's say the, the advanced applications, uh, real-time location services, this kind of stuff, um, uh, you know, great for these things, uh, but maybe not great for, for everything like we talked about, uh, with Syby. Let's have a little chat about one of the new kids on the block, so maybe something not as established as Bluetooth in our daily lives, not as uh as, as established from a technology perspective, you know, 20 years odds with Zygby. Let's talk about Thread, because Thread is uh somehow something new, but one that is starting to, to really take hold. What is it and, and, and why is it such an interesting thing for the industry that we're, we're starting to adopt this so clearly? Yeah. So for the ones that don't know Thread, uh, it is, um, a new mesh technology comparable. There's a lot of, uh, features in common with ZIB. And uh I hold it back a bit uh because uh I was expecting to talk about Thread and uh basically, Thread is sort of, I like to think about it as the next generation or the evolution of Ziggby in a way. Um, some of its features are extremely interesting. For example, energy consumption. So many of these devices are battery powered. That's also something I didn't mention before. So when you look at the battery, of course, as a customer, it doesn't matter if you are in a commercial customer or a private customer, you would love the battery to last as long as it can. So, um, Uh, Thread really focuses on reducing the battery consumption, the energy consumption, which I think is anyway also important in general for all wireless technologies. It also relies on IPV6, which is the latest IP-based communication, and it also has enhanced cybersecurity features. It also has, uh, an even more advanced, uh, mesh technology so that it's extremely reliable network. So if you wanna do automation, it is, uh, really it is probably the best in class that you have today. Uh, it is getting already traction in the consumer space, especially for homes, uh, but I expect that gradually, uh, it will become more and more of a standard. Of course, it takes time, it takes, um, a certain degree of, uh, Uh, you know, uh, knowledge also from the different, uh, industrial players, but I think over time it will become really popular, uh, because of its reliability and also because it's relying on the latest and greatest, um, technologies available. Yeah, and of course, there are already devices available and Siemens is also active in this field. Understand. And, and do you see, you know, you mentioned Zygby is established, is really established in the residential automation market, in the home automation market. Is that because of the technology, or, or, and, and we expect Thread to go in that direction, or has Thread got broader applications because of this cybersecurity, because of this, this latest technology, where do we expect this to grow, um, within the industry as it develops? Yeah, so I think first of all, the success of these, uh, technologies is not driven by the technology itself, it's driven by the value, right? Uh, it, it's, um, and I think, uh, ZigBM has been successful in creating value and also, uh, in scaling the ecosystem. So there are many devices that can connect between each other and solve multiple problems at the same time. Um, so I think the key, one of the key success criteria is how rich is the ecosystem. There is no one player that can provide all the devices that can cover all the use cases, right? And in home automation, I think the success is especially driven by the wide range of of disciplines that you can cover from security cameras, lights, uh, sensors, thermostats, and so on. And I think it's a little bit the same. Uh, but now, uh, especially in the, in the commercial space, cybersecurity, uh, energy sustainability, it's even more important. So I expect this value generation, uh, to be driven out of, of thread, and of course it's never a single answer. There are multiple reasons why a technologies are not successful, but I would expect this to be very impactful, especially in the, in the, in the commercial space. And uh you can see already the impact uh also in the, in the residential space because, uh, there are major players that are, have also adopted this technology. Yeah. Amazing. Hey, thanks, thanks for the insight into Zigby. We talked about Bluetooth, we talked about threads. Uh, time flies, so we're having a lot of fun. Let's, let's jump out of the short range world and jump into the wide range world. Uh, and, and here are 22 names that I think we know well. Um, let's talk about uh Laravan first. So, uh, Lora, a wireless application, what is this and, and what are the characteristics and where do we see this used? Yep. So, uh, Laaan is a wide area low power technology. It means that it can reach kilometers of distance first of all, and it also consumes very little energy. Uh, which means a battery can last for 5 to 10 years depending on what is the frequency at which the data is picked up. It fits very well for monitoring and uh it is now very popular for um Metering of heat and water. So in general, when you want to collect a measure from uh a meter or equivalent device, right? So it's very good at collecting that kind of, it's very good for collecting data, but it could also be used for indoor air quality, for example. Uh, you don't have, uh, you don't need to read indoor air quality data every second, probably not even every minute, every 15 minutes could be good depending on, on, on what is the regulation. So it does actually have uh quite good use cases and very strong use cases actually in the, in the monitoring space. And, uh, of course, the fact that with one gateway, you can cover a wide area, it also, it's interesting from a cost and installation point of view because the investment to get started is uh lower compared to other technologies where you maybe need to have repeaters and more network equipment. So, Conceptually, it's also simpler. You normally have one gateway and then you have all the devices around it and you don't need to have major setup costs uh beyond that. Right. And um, Where it is maybe less interesting is of course when you want to start to automate things, when you want to start to have real-time um uh commands, then it's maybe not the right solution. Uh, it, again, connecting to our discussion at the beginning, it really depends on what you want to do. Perfect. Uh, thanks, because I think LoRavan is one that, that we hear a lot about, especially in this wide range scope. It's really interesting when you talk, uh, you know, you make that differentiation between the operation and also let's say the automation versus the monitoring, and that huge difference between sending information, not every second, but every 10 minutes, every 15 minutes, uh, you know, that, that is a big decision to make, um, when you're, you're choosing that technology. Uh, let's jump into the last one for today, um, and, and, and please correct me if I, if I'm, uh, mispronouncing it, but, uh, NBIOT. What is this? …

Full transcript (WebVTT)