Crossrail - mega project, game changer, partnership paradigm
Show notes
When it comes to a brand new railway with 41 step-free stations, 42 km of tunnels, and the capacity for 250 million journeys a year – then it is all about Crossrail! This mega project is a true game-changer in public transport and will leave a lasting legacy not just for London, but for sustainable, digitalized, urban rail travel around the world. Twenty years in the making, the Elizabeth line, as it will be known, has only become a reality thanks to partnerships and teamwork on a scale never seen before.In the third episode of “Moving beyond”, our host Sally Eaves is joined by Mark Wild, Crossrail Ltd Chief Executive Officer, and Rob Morris, Siemens Mobility’s Managing Director for Rail Infrastructure in the UK, to reflect on the successes and challenges faced during this ground-breaking project Follow all participants on LinkedIn:Prof. Sally Eaves: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sally-eaves/Mark Wild: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mark-wild-32488521/Rob Morris: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rob-morris-83b3b716/ Want to know more about our podcast? Visit https://www.mobility.siemens.com/global/en/insights/mobility-podcast.html or follow Siemens Mobility on Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook or Instagram What other mobility topics would you like us to discuss in our podcast? Leave a comment with your wish at Apple Podcast. Or if you have any questions, please contact us via E-Mail at podcast.mobility@siemens.com.
Transcript
Hi everyone, and welcome to the Siemens-Mobility podcast, Moving Beyond. I'm your host, Professor Sally Eaves, and in today's episode, we're discussing Crossrail, the project of the century for London and a fantastic example of partnership. In our discussion, we'll be exploring how a brand new railway is a game changer for travel infrastructure, even in a mega city like London, and of course relevant to cities all across the world. World. We'll also look at the ways in which digitalization is an enabler for modern urban mobility. But within this, there's still no substitute for testing all the processes in real life. And we'll also learn what's happening right now in this key area. And underpinning it all, the vital importance of strong collaborative relationships and how ecosystem partners can work together to develop and implement the right solutions at the right time. And to do this, I'm delighted to be joined by Rob Morris, who is managing director for rail infrastructure at Siemens-Mobility. Welcome to you, Rob. Thank you, Sally. Great to be here. Oh, thank you, Rob, my pleasure. And equally a very warm welcome to Mark Wilde, who is Chief Executive Officer at Crossrail Limited. And this is the company established in 2001 that was set up to build the new railway and will ultimately become known as the Elizabeth. Line, a warm welcome to you too, Mark. Hi Sulally, it's great to be here. To get us started, I think it's always excellent to know a little more about the people behind the technology and the project we're discussing today. So first, turning to you, Mark, I'd love to find out a little bit more. And both of you have clearly worked in infrastructure and the transport industry for some years now. And excuse my, my little pun here, but in a certain way, the rails of your two lives are really kind of intersecting at the moment, and I think it's a great transition to discuss Crossrail in detail. So I'd love to hear how you describe your relationship and what you really appreciate about one another. Thanks, Sally. Yeah, it's a good metaphor, isn't it, about uh railway people's careers crisscrossing like tracks, I suppose, but. I guess Rob and I have known each other for for quite a while. And my background is I'm an engineer. I, I grew up in the northeast of England, went into the power industry, but I've been in the rail industry for for 25 years, 30 years I suppose. But I've also been the managing director of the Tube, London Underground. I've run public transport in the state of Victoria in Australia, and latterly I've been the person in charge of Crossrail, the special purpose vehicle building. This um this immense railway underneath London, you know, Siemens are a key partner, key technology partner in the delivery of Crossrail, so we work extensively together and I certainly value Rob's leaning in to me because we certainly can't get this railway done without our supply chain partners and, you know, Siemens are number one in our supply chain in terms of importance, closely followed by Alstorm, who've built the trains. What, what about you, Rob? I'm really pleased to follow on from that. I've worked uh in many cultures across uh lots of countries, and I guess I've benefited from the diversity of doing things differently in, in different ways and, uh and the many challenges different high profile projects and programs bring in, in such places. I guess the one thing in common with everything I've been involved with is, is people. Um, things to be successful, even in the face of diversity, a rich and honest relationship built on trust must be there. That's a really insightful and really personal, um, description there, kind of the liberation of collaboration through that trusted partnership came to the fore for me. I absolutely love that. So thank you both for sharing. I think that's that's fantastic. So I think now maybe we'll dip into more about Crossrail. This is just giving some context there to how big a project this is. Clearly this is a huge, ambitious project and I'm thinking probably the biggest one of your careers so far. So I'd love to hear a bit more about everything that makes this project so special and unique. So perhaps to, to you, Mark, first on that one. Yeah, well, it is a special project. At its time, it was Europe's biggest construction project and the 6th biggest project in the world. It'll have a few piers actually in the world as a railway when it opens. It's 42 kilometers of tunneling underneath London, which we would all know is a real, a real challenge to work in, probably the most complex city in the world in terms of its archaeology and its kind of mega city infrastructure. The point of Crossrail is to join two regions of southern England together, the western region, which includes Heathrow Airport, and in the eastern region out out to the east beyond London and. A bit like RER in Paris or the S-SPAN in somewhere like Munich, the point of Crossrail is not to bring big intercity trains into the terminus and then get onto small tube trains like London Underground works at the moment. It's to bring the trains all the way through. So from Heathrow Airport straight through to Paddington, then dive into a tunnel, take you all the way through to Canary Wharf, which is one of the financial centers of London. It's very much an unusual thing. In Britain, a game changer really, uh, the point of Crossrail is to create capacity. 10% boost to London's rail transport network in one go. It'll carry 250 million trips every single year, which will make it the second busiest tube line in London. We'll take people on very economical fares straight from Heathrow Airport to Canary Wharf in 41 minutes, completely step-free. That's the other big attribute of the Elizabeth line, which stretches all the way from Reading. To the west of London, to Shenfield in the east, 70 odd kilometers of completely step free railway, so it's a genuine game changer and also technologically, 9 new big. Deep tube stations in London, all of them 9 stories deep down to 30 to 40 m depth. Huge digitization. It's the first genuine digital railway in Britain, and it'll have few peers in the world actually, and of course Siemens have been instrumental in that. It's a game changer. Interestingly, it's been envisaged since 1820 when the Regent's Canal in London got full and somebody decided they needed another canal east to west. Then, of course, the railways came along in the 1840s in London and Britain. So, Crossrail's been around for decades, hundreds of years, and it's in its current incarnation. It started 20 years ago, so it's taken 20 years to get to this point, and we are in the phase of trial running now and looking forward to opening the railway in the next 6 to 9 months. So it's a, it's an exciting time, but it's, it's certainly had its challenges, so. Absolutely, and we'll we'll definitely dive into those as well, Mark, thank you, but the numbers you mentioned there, I mean that's certainly a service I would benefit from and I think that's that's incredible. So, um, Rob, from your perspective, the partnership involved in making this happen, you know why is this so special to you? I, I, I'm sure there's gonna be some echoes here of what Mark's mentioned, but I'd love to just hear your perspective too. You just have to say wow. You know, I've been blessed with working on some great programs through my career, the 2012 Olympics being a particular highlight. But Crossrail stands out for its complexity, you know, and the sort of the long term beneficial impact to the Capital, and of course the rest of the UK. As Mark says, you know, it's also been a vanguard project introducing, you know, many new ways of doing things and it's a techno technological showcase which I think will bring a long lasting legacy but also set the benchmark for all future transport projects here in the UK and and and worldwide. You know, for me, uh, Crossrail is a once in a lifetime thing, and it's brought the whole industry together. It really is marvelous. Fantastic. And it kind of brings me on to another topic area really to drill in a little bit more about how this is a game changer for travel infrastructure. Um, but I'm just thinking for non-loononers in our audience today, can you explain a little bit more about why that connection is so, so important, and what the Elizabeth line is delivering for London but also for the Southeast, um, maybe to Rob first this time. Mark has articulated many reasons around um why Elizabeth Line is so important, and I think the first one for me is, is actually the economic benefit of bringing jobs for many Londoners and people from across the country for the construction, operation and maintenance of the line. Uh, on top of that, uh, will be the time saved by improved transport connections along with enhanced accessibility for many millions of folks. Uh, and I, I believe it will also act as a leveling up lever for want of a better way of putting it, as it improves connectivity, not just across the southeast. Uh, but the whole country and I think, uh, during these current economic times, um, that is of, uh, of great importance. Absolutely, Rob. And Mark, how will this new line really integrate into the existing London transport system, just to give a little bit of a view of that area. Yeah, well, London, as most people will know, even if they've not been to London, that it's got a highly interconnected, uh, advanced transport system, you know, 10,000 buses, 10 tube lines, a lot of rail, tram networks. So London's already hyper connected in terms of its transport offering. And the Elizabeth line, which is the thing that Crossrail creates, really, really enhances that. So all of our nine central stations, they're all either associated directly with the London Underground station, like somewhere famous like Farringdon or Paddington, but also it creates new opportunities, new journey opportunities, which is the key, the key thing about Crossrail. East west matters because in London, the east-west transfer of people, particularly for economic reasons, whether they're moving to a financial center in the city or the Canary Wharf Financial Center, or if you're a construction worker who lives in the east, in Essex outside of London. And wants to traverse east-west into employment opportunities are really important. So this, this new artery of London is really very important. At the moment our central line covers a lot of this ground, but it's completely full, and most people who've traveled on the central line would realize it's, it's, it's overcapacity. And I think interestingly, I don't know what Rob would think about this, but the, the, the era of coronavirus, I, I think, is temporary. It's clearly got a significant effect of travel patterns, but you know, we build these, you know, Crossrail's built for 120 year design life, it'll be here for decades, not even hundreds of years. So I think you'd agree, Rob, that even in the era of coronavirus, these sort of investments really count, both for the construction jobs and technology jobs they create in the making, but also for the future. Would you agree on that, Rob? Yeah, I totally agree, and I think we're already seeing signs of, uh, if you like, the nation bouncing back in terms of use of, of transport. So I think we will get to similar levels, if not greater, uh, in time. So um I think Crossrail is, uh, you know, a great investment and a much needed one and will be a sustainable one. And thinking a little bit more about the Elizabeth line from its digitalization, um, point of view, I'd love to share a bit more about how this is different to other metros. So for example, why the railway's been designed with 3 signaling systems and also why did you decide the need to integrate those 3 instead of, for example, selecting 1 supplier. So Mark, if you could, um, elucidate a little bit more about that, that would be fantastic. It's interesting, isn't it, Crossrail, that a lot of its problems in 2018 are because of its immense complexity, and if you go back in a time machine to um, 2004, 2005, the key risk perceived in Crossrail was tunneling under London, and interestingly, it went really well, the tunneling. The major civils on the tunneling were expertly done, in fact, set a benchmark that's now replicated all around the world. But at that time, the architects of Crossrail made a decision to be very bold in terms of digitization. They wanted a full height platform screen doors through the central section. They wanted automatic train operation, GOA 2, just like you find in the Jubilee line or the Victoria line, but they also wanted ETCS capability in the classic network, the classic national rail network. So they were very, very ambitious in 2005, 2006. Not only that with the signaling systems, they also wanted the state of the art in terms of digital condition based monitoring, maintenance tools, they wanted the, these new stations to be heavily digitized, and I guess it was the first use in the UK anyway of tools such as BIM, digital twins. So it was an immensely ambitious project, Crossrail, and we've learned loads in the digitization. I'm sure Rob would agree that we've had some very interesting twists and turns in the road, but I think the fascinating thing about Crossrail for future mega projects is the tunneling was perceived to be the greatest risk. What actually transpired to be the greatest risk in Crossrail was the immensity of system integration. And also how leadership was as important as the technology, and I guess Rob, you and I every single day deal with this, don't we, and I'd be interested in your perspective and your journey because you clearly won these contracts and it's been a few twists in the road, Robin teams, but I'd be interested in your view on that question. I think um as the construction project progressed, um, and many challenges that occurred during that time, uh, the time for testing and commissioning actually got crunched up. Uh, and so when Mark came on board, um, he not only had to deal with, um, uh, finalizing the construction activities and, um, and pushing those on over the line, which is largely done, still some work to do, um, but it was also how to get a fully coordinated approach around systems integration. Assurance to allow us to get to that and um all the testing and commissioning that was required, and to join up a couple of things really, um that sort of multi-dimensional view of life because of the various experience from different backgrounds, but all in harmony with um, Um, with what we wanted to achieve to bring those rail systems in operation, has allowed us to, to actually lean in on each other. I'd love to ask you, Rob, a little bit more information from, from what you're doing from a Siemens-Mobility perspective. So obviously you're delivering signaling, um, for Crossrail's central section, um, but you also have a, a separate role as well around covering communications and control. So that capacity to talk to each other and the train, all the different integration elements here are so, so key. So I'd love to know, you know, is this a standard project for you or are there special challenges involved? Well, it's actually a bit, a bit of both. You know, the fundamentals of what we are doing on the Elizabeth line and what we do every day really, uh, whether that be the communication control package that you mentioned or the signaling, uh, so in that way, it's pretty standard. As an example, to sort of put some context around that, the, the train guard MT system we use for signaling and train control in the central operating section is probably 80 to 90% standard, uh, with the balance being novel to Crossrail. Uh, the real complexity comes with the scale. And tailoring to the nuances of the infrastructure and the operational needs of the operator and particularly the complexity of the interfaces and other systems which we Uh, need to integrate with. So I can explain a little bit more perhaps, uh, the train itself, which is provided by Alstom, you know, carries its own train control and management system which has oversight over its own subsystems and functions such as brakes, doors, uh, passenger information, and the like. Uh, so essentially all the on board stuff. On top of that, each train carries 3 types of onboard signaling units which control the safe and reliable passage of the train from east to west and vice versa as Marcus explained. Um, as the trains pass through the, the central operating section, it's our CBTC, uh, system or communications-based train control system that guides and control, controls the safe and, uh, uh, timely passage, uh, whilst also interacting with things like the opening of platform screen doors and other infrastructure related systems. So the additional complexity comes when our system also has to shake hands with and take over or give control to either of the other signaling systems which operate on the mainline railway either side of the Elizabeth line or en route to Heathrow. All three systems have to be developed to suit the needs I've mentioned, and each, uh, as each configuration of software is dropped onto each system, you can imagine the testing required is, is actually immense. You know, it really is a massive undertaking to bring all that lot together and make it work like a, a Swiss, a Swiss watch. Um, and, um, we're in that process, uh, now of, uh, trying to achieve that, uh, and, uh, we're getting there. So Rob, just moving on from, from your last point there, I understand the frequency of trains using the Crossrail route will be up to 24 per hour in each direction in the central section. So what special challenges come up here with these particular requirements? As a business, um, you know, we have proven experience of delivering high frequency systems in, in both a metro environment as well as on mainline. Um, for Thameslink, which has an automatic train operation capability with ETCS we have a 24 train per hour capability and on the Victoria line, which Mark will be very familiar with. Um, we, we are achieving 36 trains per hour, so both very high. The trains continuously calculate and communicate their status and position to the wayside along the line, uh, and this includes the exact position, speed, direction, and braking distance. The main challenges are around tuning for maximum performance and reliability, particularly around uh integration with all the other. Uh, interfacing, uh, systems and, and we've actually, uh, been through that process, um, on Crossrail, uh, over the last few months, and we're now into that next phase of, of trial running, um, to, um, uh, actually move into effectively resilience testing. Mark, if I could pass back to you a little bit, just to give a little flavor of the changes that um commuters can expect or visitors or residents when the Elizabeth line comes into operation. Well, I think they'll um I hope that they'll be er amazed and blown away by what what we've built. Here we've built very, very large cathedral-like stations, they're very spacious, they're very open, they're architecturally striking, and I think we'll stand the test of time. Platforms are 250 m long, full height platform screen doors. It's got all the appropriate customer information system, connectivity. Because it's being built on a really brilliant tunneling and great track formation, we expect it to be a smooth ride, you know, limited noise in the cab, full Wi Fi and 4G capability, so I think the customers certainly in London will be amazed at, wow, this is a real modern, you know, futureproof, state of the art metro that's been bitten. …