#127 Bringing 3D scanning to the delivery phase
Show notes
Kevin Bauer, lead for BIM and Digital Twin at Siemens Smart Infrastructure in Europe, is back on the channel, to let you know everything on how to bring 3D scanning to the delivery phase of a smart building. Tune in!
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Buildings of Tomorrow. My name's John Lester, and in today's episode we are talking about bringing 3D scanning into the delivery phase and using as its own discipline to help derive value, not just through that delivery phase, but also through the operational phase. I'm joined today by Kevin Bauer. He is the lead for BIMM and Digital twin at Siemens Smart-Infrastructure in Europe. Kevin, thank you for joining us. Hi. Welcome, John. Really happy to be here again today. It's an absolute pleasure. We always have a great discussion, so I'm excited about having another one today. In the past we've talked a little bit about BIM and the digital twin, constructing this, you know, through the BIM process, constructing that level of detail into that digital twin to really enable not just all the benefits that we know BI BIM as a process brings, and you as a, as a certified trainer at Building Smart International, know and understand that as well as anybody. But also leveraging that information, building that operational twin which enables us to find benefits in that process. And through those discussions we've touched a little bit on integrating 3D scanning almost as its own discipline as part of that delivery phase. As we jump into that, let's start at the start. Give us an idea. Why did this idea come about? Why did you start to think about 3D scanning in this way? And, and what was it that created or, or, or drove you to take the plunge with 3D scanning in these particular projects? You know, uh, for us at Siemens, what the infrastructure is all about optimizing the billing operations from a, uh, technical facilitational perspective and from a, uh, energy perspective, and there, we work a lot on the topic, digital twin. So how can we combine data, IoT and billing automation data to enhance again energy optimistic, energy and technical billing operations? Uh, but the big question was every time, yeah, how do we get to this digital twin, yeah, you know, digital twin definition is the digital representation of, um, digital asset, officially, physical asset, which also allows the command and control. But as we know, you know, the construction industry is a little bit chaotic. And, you know, um, um, from our experience, we know we have some often hard times, it's getting really to this is built. Which is let's say the digital representation. And then we thought about, let's say, why not integrating mobile 3D scanning. In the construction process to bring them from our S plant phase to an SP phase, or let's say, um, get 3D scans, which we can take tend to check against the S build models to then afterwards, um, control the contractors, the electrical, mechanical, and the structural contractors. To check if, let's say all the spilled documentation delivered is really a spilled because a digital twin is as good, just as good as the data it has, yeah. Yeah, so, so that process, because, because a construction phase, a delivery phase is, is a, is a crazy time at the, you know, at different stages throughout that process, um, you had that experience that when you got to the end of that delivery phase, those as-built drawings, which really should be updated and represent exactly what's handed over on completion day, they weren't up to the standard or accuracy that you expected. Exactly, yeah. It was like this, um, at the Aspen project in, in Vienna, which we talk, talk all the time, yeah, it was like this. That we had this 3D scans and then we sat together with the billion owner. And asked, asked the installer, yeah, because we already checked in advance. Lovely installer, yeah. You know, we checked up your documentation. And, but you know, youril documentation is just, you just change the name as your, from your execution design. And changed the name to SBuilder, um, but it's not SBuild because we see it from the 3D scans there. And he said, he does it every time like this, because he said it's industry standard. Right, so as an industry, sometimes we're not, in general, we're not really delivering these as-built drawings as you know, as the name suggests, and that leaves us a big gap, especially when you want to start like you describe, using those drawings as the basis for operational activities, you know, whether that's maintenance or or space optimization or location tracking or whatever it might be, the detail and the data. It directly impacts the ability for those kind of operations to work well, um, So, you went through the construction phase, you realized that that information that's handed over on the last day, on handover day doesn't give you the level of, of detail or the accuracy that was required. How then did you build this 3D scanning approach into your process in this Asper project as an example? It's, it's really important to really integrate, uh, 3D scanning and 3D mobile scanning into the construction process. So what we did is let's say we, we went through the uh construction schedule. I thought about, yeah, how could we integrate as its own discipline to at the end have really built 3D scans. And then let's say we, we identified that we have 3 main phases. Phase 1 is the structural phase. Uh, you know, you do all the concrete stuff, uh, phase 2 is the equipment phase, you know, where you integrate HVAC systems, uh, um, piping systems, you know, the, all the, The sanitary, then you have all the cable traces kind of stuff, and the 3rd phase is the SP phase where you do all the finishing, the floors, spend it fillings, and this kind of stuff. So, so we have had 3 main phases, and then we really integrated the mobile scanning into the port, porters, which means when the people, uh, the workers worked in the 2nd floor because they already finished the structural work in the 1st floor. They work on the 2nd floor, we scanned the 1st floor, and when they were working the 3rd floor, we scanned the 2nd floor, yeah. And when they put the, the, the electrical cable trays, we scanned the cable trays and this kind of stuff. At the end, we did 18 3D scans, yeah. Wow. Yeah, and, and that was my next question, and you described it a little bit there as well, especially if we talk about high rise constructions and things like this. That means you're out there doing quite a lot of scanning and then managing that data depending on the different phases of the different pieces of the building at that time. Uh, then the question for me is, so you went through this process, you know, you identified the need, you've built in 3D scanning as a discipline, you've built it in as part of the standard process. So these three different phases of the delivery, uh, you know, the delivery piece of a building, uh, at the, the structural, uh, the services, and then the, the as built. You've collected all the scan information. Uh, and you gave us a little bit of an insight already as to, you know, comparing the, the plans or the documentation to the, the reality. Let's have a little bit of a discussion about some of the other values or the things that you discovered along the way that, that you could use these 3D scans for, um, to, to add value to the different stakeholders. Um, let's, let's start with that, that first one that you've already described, which is comparing. The plans, so comparing what's what's been approved, what's been, what's then expected to the real thing. How did that work when you started to use these 3D scans to really compare, even at the structural phase, the positioning and the, the, the, the, you know what is really delivered compared to what's expected? Mhm. Yeah, probably, let's talk a little bit about the pain, what people have today, today. Construction is a little bit of a complicated industry, and you know, there you have uh uh site super consultants, a site supervision. Uh, whose job it is to control the construction progress for the owner. And, you know, um, construction is really complicated because, you know, you have, um, for example, equipment or outlets, for example, in the floor, but you, you know, you just can't control them if they are built, uh, uh, like they should until the floor is not there. So, um, Dess which you guys have often a hard time, it's, let's say, really following the progress because the contractors, they're also not, they're also quite smart, and let's say, uh, uh, do the things that's quick, that let's say, you often afterwards cannot control everything, yeah. Did they really build like it was defined in the contract, yeah? And yeah, what we, and the, the, uh, mobile scanning helped a lot because, you know, as we indicated the scanning, the construction progress there, the site supervision could did not, let's say, didn't need to be there all the time, yeah, or at a specific time, yeah, we scanned it and afterwards, they could, let's say, take the scan. And check the scan against the, the contractor. So through this day, it was easier for them to do all the project management, the, the tracking of the construction progress, and And, um, then this lead in, let's say, really good anti-claimage because afterwards, we identified, for example, that there weren't enough outlets and that the documentation of the central tech technical central units was, uh, not correct, and we could use a 3D scan to, to, yeah, to anticlaim management and to get big money for the owner. Yeah, right, so, so through that process, as you say, you know, a site supervisor can't be everywhere. Someone who's responsible for checking the quality can't, can't be at every single step of every single discipline along the way. So if you disappear for a day or you're somewhere else on site for a day, then certainly the walls or the floor or the ceiling go up, and what's behind them, maybe you don't have the chance to see. So with these 3D scans you're able to collect more information. And also set a staging, let's call it that this scan must happen before the next step comes along, and that gives you that information. So I can imagine that that would pay dividends throughout that whole construction phase right up until delivery day because you have the chance to really look in detail into every part of the building that's scanned and perhaps in more detail than you would be physically on site at the time. Once we get then to the The operation phase, so the building is handed over, the scans are then as part of the as built drawings, you've constructed this, this representation of the building as it's delivered and through combining all of the information you collect through the BIM process, etc. etc. you, you end up with this, this set of data that really represents the physical building. What happens next? What are some of the other use cases and some of the other values for the stakeholders that are operating the building, owning and operating and using that building? Yeah, you know, the cool thing is, um, through this small person can we helped the site separation really do a great job. We brought in transparency and then the contractors at the end really deliver api data because they cannot hide. And then the cool thing is, yeah, that they again talk a little bit about the pain point without this, uh, process. It's like this that, um. Um, the, the FM guys, yeah, they normally come, come in into a into a project, let's say, uh, after the building is finished, yeah. And you know, the, the contractors, mechanical general contractor, whoever, their main task is to say, RDC already on in the horizon, uh, the, the construction project will be finished soon. Yeah, let's quickly do our stuff and then run our way as quickly as possible, yeah, that we do not get in contact with the FM guy and then the FM guy comes in later. And yeah, he has, let's say some orders of documentation paper, and then he identifies often not this documentation doesn't reflect reality. And then he, let's say has to do a lot of freework or let's say, um, um, go through all the material, check up if, how the things work, is this really a speed this kind of stuff, yeah, and, um, yeah. And if we do our homework early on, integrate 3D scanning, bring in transparency, and get really, really good SB data, you know, the FM doesn't need to do this job again, yeah. So the value is, uh, let's say we can save time and, and money for the FM guy, yeah. Yeah, already fits together. Yeah, perfect. And, and maybe a quick note before we move on, you know, this is just that individual example. In general, we have a lot of great contractors out there that do a lot of great work, and, and I can imagine that this information that you collect through the 3D scanning can also be useful for them to really verify and check their work along that process. So we have that scan. We have the as-built documentation. It really does reflect what is on site. So this saves the facility manager a huge amount of effort when he comes and takes over through the operation phase. How about the owners and the operators, those that, you know, are responsible for the building, that's their assets, and they have to maintain and, and, you know, use it to generate the revenue or the business that they expect. Yeah, um, for the owner, the, the, there's also a big failure because, um, at the end, you can use the 3D scan, uh, for something called an indoor fuel from Navis, yeah. And also thank you for, uh, Navis to this great product and which you use a lot. And, um, yeah, the owner can use it this, this indoor viewer which looks like a Google Maps indoor also for marketing. For example, if he has some tenants or he wants to get new tenants, he, let's say can show the people online, uh, guide them like through the real building but it's just Twitter. In the 3, in the, in the viewer, you can also measure, let's say, let's say for example, how, how high is the, the room, how bright is the room. And all this kind of stuff. So you say you can't do all the marketing stuff a building owner needs to do today, and he can also give it give access to the tenants. And then also, also the FM guys can use this and really important in this, uh, in the interviewer, it's also open to integrate other, uh, data. So for example, we integrate it in there, um, data from our billing automation system. So you can look up in the in the interviewer, which is web-based, which is really easy to use the live data from the billing automation systems. So you can look up there and what's current, the current value of the pump or what's the current value of the, the heating systems. You're right, so then the owner gets this asset, this information that doesn't just go in a drawer and sit there, but it really can be used for him as you, as you describe, to represent their building space, even to start to plan or think about things, maybe work with an architect for a fit out or many different use cases that that that kind of information could be useful. And that last use case that you just just described where all of a sudden we have a space that not only can you navigate through it, but it also represents or delivers the live information that have been collected by the management systems, you know, all of a sudden this is starting to give you real transparency on your building and not just transparency right now, but then also back historically to say, you know, what happened in this space, you know, what components were put in here, when were they, where were they placed, etc. Anyone else on your list that you found through this experience that really benefited from, from bringing 3D scanning in as such an integral part of that delivery phase? Um, yeah, but, I think it's, it's generally, you could say nearly everybody benefits a little bit, yeah. But the most important, uh, for example, also the project managers and this kind of stuff in the construction phase, yeah. But in general, let's say it's really important to highlight that this, um, this mobile 3D scanning is something, let's say, which delivers value to many stakeholders for like the site separation, also the contractors. And then the FM guys, the billing owners, the, the tenants, it's really important that we, let's say, share also the values and not that just 11 stakeholder does, just does it for himself, yeah. It's really important to share it because let's say, if you share the costs, then the return of invest for the values you get is much higher. Yeah. No, that's a good point which I like because it, it goes in line with, with the values or the core of the BIM process in general as well. It's that collaboration, it's the sharing and the accessibility to data, and it's the, the single source of truth, you know, the, the, the fact that everyone's working off the same information which can deliver so many benefits, not just through that, that delivery phase, but then also moving into the operational phase. Maybe my last question on this topic, you know, you went through this process. You did 18 different 3D scans throughout the building in this particular example. It delivered benefits for the, for the construction company, for the owner. In the end, you use it through the operational phase for facility managers, for the operational teams. What, what would your suggestion be if you were talking to To a consultant, a company, a construction group of stakeholders that were about to kick off a project, and, and they were thinking about bringing 3D scanning in as one of these, these additional disciplines as really a core part of the delivery phase and then moving into the operational phase. What would your suggestion be or a couple of notes that you discovered and learned along this process? Um, yeah, at first we did, we did at the beginning, yeah. Think again, think about, let's say, what are Uh, what kind of building you have and what are the, uh, what's the strategy in the building operations? And what's important in your building? Is it, uh, technical building operations? Is it energy efficiency? And then think about how, which use cases, twin use cases using beam IOT mobile skating, whatever are important to leverage or support your strategy. If you know this, yeah, then you can think back how, what kind of data and what kind of stuff you need to do in your construction process, yeah. So at first when you think about this operational thing. And then think about step two, what you need in the construction phase, yeah, because then let's say, sometimes, you know, it's also about prioritization. What kind, what is really important for you, yeah? Do you want to do a, a full-fledged mobile scaling like we did, full integration, uh, probably you need for you, the, the, the HVAC system is the most important, yeah, because, you know, you have some huge cases which require this data. Yeah then really focus on getting all the HVAC data, yeah. Uh, through the mobile scanning, yeah. And then let's say, so really focused. And the second thing is, uh, the, the 2nd and 3rd thing is then it's really, think, if you know the use cases, then also think about integrating all the stakeholders. Yeah. So, uh, talk to the consultants, site supervision, talk to the contractors, talk to the FM guys, the, the owner, the project managers, the tenants, and think about the, how to share the value. Because if you share the value of the mobile scanning, Then it's, uh, much the return of investors, is, is much easier to get, yeah. Understand. So, so like, like always, make sure you put in the thought to decide what you want to achieve, um, so that, uh, you know, you have a direction and you have a place to get to. then focus on those spaces so you can really control the effort, but then also make sure you do collect the information you need. …